Through two weeks, the clearest worry around Wisconsin’s defense isn’t the points allowed or even the yardage. It’s the empty takeaway column.
The Badgers came into the season expecting that side of the ball to carry real weight. Mike Tressel is back for his fourth year as defensive coordinator, last year’s defense finished top-25 nationally, and linebackers Mason Posa and Cooper Catalano returned as the unit’s top two playmakers.
That setup created real optimism. Two games in, though, the defense has not delivered the kind of impact Wisconsin needed.
The opener against Notre Dame started with promise. Wisconsin played a rugged first half, then watched the game slip away as soft coverage and poor tackling took over after halftime.
A week later, the Badgers avoided giving up a touchdown against Western Illinois, but they still spent too much time on the field. The Leathernecks held the ball for 34 minutes to Wisconsin’s 25 and pieced together long drives of 11, 11 and 14 plays, each ending in a field goal.
Western Illinois finished with 302 total yards, splitting that almost evenly with 154 on the ground and 148 through the air. Wisconsin did a decent job against the running backs, but quarterback Kennedy McGill was the problem. He ran for 88 yards and consistently made plays both on designed runs and when he escaped after the play broke down.
Even so, the bigger issue isn’t just the Notre Dame second half, the trouble with McGill, or the fact that Wisconsin has only one sack through two games. The real red flag is that the Badgers still haven’t forced a turnover.
That’s the number that stands out. Wisconsin has not recorded an interception or a forced fumble through eight quarters, even though it came close early when CJ Carr was strip-sacked against Notre Dame before the Irish recovered. The defense has helped swing momentum in other ways, including multiple blocked punts, but the takeaway drought remains.
That lack of turnovers is especially frustrating because forcing them was a major point of emphasis all offseason.
“The turnovers, man," Catalano said in fall camp when asked what's different about this defense this year. "That’s been a huge emphasis in our unit meetings with Coach Tressel."
“Yes we do tally it, yes it’s a competition and yes we’re creating more turnovers than last year, for sure," Tressel said during fall camp.
With the offense likely needing some shorter fields if this season is going to get moving, the defense’s inability to create takeaways becomes an issue that reaches beyond its own performance.
Fickell said at his Week 3 presser that the defense has seen chances.
"We’ve had some balls in the air, we’ve had our hands on balls, there’s been some tips. Those will (result in turnovers) eventually. But our ability to attack the football, be physical enough to dislodge the football is still where we’ve gotta do a helluva lot better job," Fickell said at his Week 3 presser.
For now, Wisconsin’s defense is still waiting for the game-changing play that turns pressure into possession. The Badgers have flashed it in moments, but through two weeks, they have yet to make it a habit.
In Other News...
Wisconsins Coaching Reset Is Back In Focus After Long-Awaited Comments
Nearly four years after Wisconsin changed course and moved on from Paul Chryst, the programs coaching reset is back in the conversation thanks to public reflections from both Chryst and Jim Leonhard. Chryst said he disagreed with the decision to fire him, but he also made clear he believed Leonhard was the right choice to take over the program at the time. It is a reminder of how abrupt that transition felt then, and how much lingering interest there still is in what came next.
Leonhards comments add another layer, since he said he had planned to stay at Wisconsin and was surprised when the job ultimately went to Luke Fickell instead. Since then, Leonhard has moved into NFL coaching and was recently hired as the Buffalo Bills defensive coordinator, while Chryst has kept a much lower public profile. For Wisconsin fans, it is a look back at a defining fork in the road, with both men now far enough removed from the moment to speak more openly about it. [Read more 🡒]
Wisconsin Fans Have One Real Complaint About A Huge Luke Fickell Test
Wisconsins early-season schedule has already given fans plenty to chew on, but the next stretch comes with a different kind of test for Luke Fickell and the program. The Badgers are 1-1, and two of their upcoming games are set to land on NBCs Peacock streaming service, a setup that has added a layer of annoyance for a fan base eager to follow along without jumping through another subscription hoop.
The bigger gripe is the Penn State matchup, which ESPN Analytics sees as a low-probability upset for Wisconsin and which would have been the kind of game that draws plenty of attention on traditional TV. Instead, airing it on Peacock has frustrated Badgers fans who now may need to subscribe just to watch a key conference game, and that kind of broadcast decision can make even a compelling test feel harder to embrace. [Read more 🡒]
Wisconsin Gets One More Tune-Up Before Penn State Arrives
Wisconsin gets one more chance to clean up the details before Big Ten play begins, and the final stop on the non-conference schedule comes Saturday morning against Eastern Michigan. After a 36-9 win over Western Illinois in Week 2, the Badgers have some good tape to build on, especially in the running game, but there were also enough offensive inconsistencies to keep the staffs attention focused on the finer points of execution.
The defense had its own uneven start against Western Illinois before settling in, so this matchup offers one last opportunity to sharpen things before Penn State arrives. Wisconsin and Eastern Michigan will kick at 11:00 a.m. CT on Peacock, and for the Badgers it feels less like a glamour spot than a needed final tune-up with the schedule about to tighten up in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]