Wisconsins Defense Has A Growing Problem At The Worst Time

Injury woes left Wisconsin's football defense vulnerable as they faced off against Maryland, amplifying concerns about the team's future prospects.

Wisconsin’s defense took a hit in more ways than one Saturday, and the 24-21 loss at Maryland left the Badgers with plenty to sort through on that side of the ball. Injuries forced lineup changes, the pass rush never really got home, and a few key breakdowns in the secondary helped Maryland’s backup quarterback find a groove.

The biggest absence came up front, where Sebastian Cheeks was unavailable and Wisconsin felt it. Tyreese Fearbry managed two pressures but didn’t deliver the kind of impact the Badgers needed, and his 18.4 PFF tackling grade reflected a rough day.

Nick Clayton’s role grew to a career-high 45 snaps, and while he held up better against the run with five tackles, he didn’t make much noise as a pass rusher. Inside, Nolan Vils stood out with four tackles, half a tackle for loss and a team-best 80.7 PFF overall grade.

Charles Perkins and Hammond Russell IV each added a pressure, though Perkins had trouble finishing plays and missed two tackles.

Even with the pressure issues, Wisconsin did what it usually does against the run. Maryland was held to 107 rushing yards on 39 carries, a 2.7-yard average.

The trouble came when the Terrapins threw the ball. Backup quarterback Cardell Williams settled in and finished 21-of-23 for 183 yards and a touchdown, and Wisconsin never found a consistent way to speed him up.

The Badgers need Cheeks back to help a pass rush that couldn’t disrupt Maryland’s rhythm.

Mason Posa was the busiest defender on the field for Wisconsin. He piled up a team-high 13 tackles, added 2.5 tackles for loss and collected the Badgers’ only sack.

He also briefly left with what looked like an injury before returning a few plays later. Posa wasn’t perfect - PFF charged him with three missed tackles - but he still drove the middle of the defense all afternoon.

Cooper Catalano also turned in a solid effort with 10 tackles and a tackle for loss. Jon Jon Kamara played only 14 snaps, while Thomas Heiberger and Aaron Witt saw limited action.

Posa and Catalano have been two of Wisconsin’s most dependable defenders, and that held true again even in a loss that exposed bigger problems around them.

The secondary had its own issues, starting with the absence of Jai’mier Scott, who didn’t play despite not being on the injury report. Javan Robinson then went down in the second quarter and never returned, which pushed Eric Fletcher Jr. into a season-high 63 snaps. Fletcher was targeted once and gave up a 10-yard catch.

Bryce West had a difficult day in the slot, allowing four catches on four targets. He also appeared to be beaten on Maryland’s 39-yard touchdown pass in the fourth quarter, and Fletcher took a bad pursuit angle that helped the receiver get into the end zone.

Donovan Dunmore was asked to do more than usual at cornerback and showed some promise as a tackler, finishing with seven tackles and a tackle for loss. But the coverage results were shaky: he allowed completions on all three of his targets for 36 yards and posted a 49.8 PFF coverage grade.

The safety group was also shaken up when Matt Jung suffered what looked like a leg injury while recovering a fumble near Wisconsin’s goal line late in the second quarter. Matthew Traynor then got his first meaningful run, playing 30 snaps and finishing with six tackles and a 66.3 PFF overall grade.

He also picked up a personal foul in the fourth quarter for a late hit out of bounds. Marvin Burks Jr. earned a 72.6 overall grade while allowing two catches for 12 yards, and Cairo Skanes showed some improvement with five tackles and an eight-yard completion allowed on his lone target.

The lack of pressure made life harder on the back end, but the secondary also didn’t help itself. Allowing Williams to go 21-of-23 was too much, and the late touchdown breakdown was especially costly. Jung’s injury appeared serious, and Wisconsin will be watching the status of Robinson and Scott ahead of next week’s trip to Purdue.

On special teams, Gavin Lahm stayed steady, knocking through field goals from 42 and 36 yards and making his only extra point. Sean West had a mixed afternoon punting, averaging 38.4 yards on five kicks for 192 total yards.

His worst moment came late in the second quarter when he shanked a 21-yard punt that gave Maryland the ball at Wisconsin’s 40-yard line. The mistake nearly turned into a disaster, but Jung’s fumble recovery near the goal line kept the Terrapins from cashing in.

Darrion Dupree added 56 yards on two kickoff returns, though neither changed the game. Outside of West’s miscue, Wisconsin’s special teams were mostly steady.

In Other News...

Greg Gard Addressed Wisconsins Injury Scare After A Tense Comeback Win

Wisconsin had to work for its 89-81 comeback win over Coastal Carolina, but the bigger concern for much of the afternoon was Braeden Carrington, who left the game after an injury scare. The Badgers were down at halftime before regrouping behind a strong second half, improving to 4-0 and getting a major lift from Owen Foxwell, who poured in 33 points with six assists and was later named Big Ten Freshman of the Week.

Greg Gard pointed to the teams adjustments and the way his players responded after the break, but the injury situation added an uneasy layer to an otherwise encouraging result. For a Wisconsin team still early in the season, the win showed resilience, but it also left one important question hanging as the Badgers move on from a tense afternoon. [Read more 🡒]

Cooper Catalano Gives Wisconsin Fans One Defensive Reason To Keep Watching

Even in a season where Wisconsin has spent plenty of time searching for steady answers, Cooper Catalano has given the defense one reliable reason to keep tuning in. The sophomore linebacker reached 100 tackles for the year during the game against Maryland, adding 10 more in that outing and reinforcing just how central he has become to the Badgers defense.

Catalano entered the matchup already leading the Big Ten in tackles and has been one of the few consistent bright spots for Wisconsin on that side of the ball. His production has also put him in the conversation for bigger national recognition, with semifinalist status for the Bednarik Award underscoring how much his season has stood out even as the team has worked through its larger struggles. [Read more 🡒]

Wisconsin's Quarterback Plan Suddenly Feels Wide Open Again

Ryan Hopkins got the start against Maryland, but the afternoon turned into a difficult one for Wisconsin in more ways than one. Hopkins struggled before leaving with an injury in the fourth quarter, and Colton Joseph finished the game in his place as the Badgers fell 24-21, a result that only added to the uncertainty around the position.

Luke Fickell now has a decision to make with the final games of the season approaching, and the timing could hardly be trickier. Wisconsin entered the day looking for stability at quarterback and left with more questions, as the staff has to sort out which direction gives the Badgers the best chance to close the year on a better note. [Read more 🡒]