Nearly four years later, the coaching shakeup that changed Wisconsin football still carries plenty of weight for the people who lived through it.
Paul Chryst and Jim Leonhard have finally spoken publicly about the end of their time in Madison, and both made it clear they saw things differently than the decision-makers who moved on from them. Chryst was fired, Leonhard was passed over, and Luke Fickell was hired from outside the Wisconsin tree - a move that left plenty of Badgers fans scratching their heads then and still fuels debate now.
Chryst didn’t hide how he felt about being let go.
“I didn’t agree with being fired,” Chryst said with a laugh, via The Athletic’s Tim Graham. “But they, obviously, wanted something different.”
He also said Leonhard was the coach he wanted to see take over after his exit.
“I thought (Leonhard) was the right one to take over,” Chryst added. “I didn’t see the change happening, but in that instance it’s hard to switch and not care about the good of the team anymore. I wanted him to be the next guy, absolutely.”
Leonhard, too, made clear how he viewed the situation. He had turned down several NFL coordinator chances to stay at Wisconsin, and he believed he had already laid out a blueprint for what came next.
“I knew how to make that place better,” Leonhard said. “So, given the opportunity, I felt like I had the plan, the structure, the organization set and a plan for a lot of the people. So you get really excited about what that could look like, and they went in a different direction.”
He added: “I never planned on leaving. I was happy at Wisconsin,” Leonhard added, via the article.
Chryst said Leonhard had earned the chance that came his way, and that his decision was about family, not chasing a bigger paycheck.
“He earned the right to have those other opportunities,” Chryst said about Leonhard’s connection to Wisconsin, “but in the end he did what was right for his family. He never came across to me like he was chasing the money, and I think he knew he’d have other opportunities. Jimmy had confidence he was only going to get better as a coach.”
Chryst also reflected on the circumstances around his firing, saying he believed Wisconsin was moving in the right direction before the program pulled the plug after a home loss to Washington State and back-to-back blowouts against Ohio State and Illinois.
“To make a change like that at Wisconsin? That was …” Chryst said before his voice trailed off, per Graham.
“The big picture was we were doing some pretty good things, but they wanted change. I don’t spend a lot of time on things you can’t control, but as a head coach you feel responsible for the players you brought and the coaches and staff that you hired.
You didn’t know to what extent, but you knew things were going to change, and it was going to be hard.”
Since then, their careers have gone in different directions. Leonhard spent a year as an analyst at Illinois before moving to the Denver Broncos coaching staff as a pass game coordinator for the past two years. This offseason, he landed his first coordinator job since Wisconsin, taking over as the Buffalo Bills defensive coordinator.
Chryst has stayed much quieter, though his name has surfaced for various jobs over the years.
As for Wisconsin, the aftershocks of that decision still haven’t fully settled. Three seasons into the Fickell era, the questions remain, and the Badgers’ 4-8 finish in 2025 marked their worst season in more than 35 years and their second straight year without a bowl game.
In Other News...
Wisconsins Defense Has An Early Problem Fans Cant Ignore
Through two games, Mike Tressels defense has already offered a little bit of everything, and not all of it reassuring. Wisconsin flashed real control in the first half against Notre Dame, then lost some of that edge after the break, and the same unit also had trouble settling in against a mobile Western Illinois quarterback. The overall picture is less about one bad stretch than an inconsistency the Badgers can feel early in the season.
What stands out most is the missing takeaway. After spending the offseason stressing turnovers, Wisconsin still has not come up with an interception or forced fumble, and coaches and players have openly pointed to the need for more physical play and more pressure up front. For a defense built to set the tone, the next step is less about surviving drives and more about changing them, which is where the real concern now lives. [Read more 🡒]
Wisconsin Fans Have One Real Complaint About A Huge Luke Fickell Test
Wisconsins early-season schedule has already given fans plenty to chew on, but the next stretch comes with a different kind of test for Luke Fickell and the program. The Badgers are 1-1, and two of their upcoming games are set to land on NBCs Peacock streaming service, a setup that has added a layer of annoyance for a fan base eager to follow along without jumping through another subscription hoop.
The bigger gripe is the Penn State matchup, which ESPN Analytics sees as a low-probability upset for Wisconsin and which would have been the kind of game that draws plenty of attention on traditional TV. Instead, airing it on Peacock has frustrated Badgers fans who now may need to subscribe just to watch a key conference game, and that kind of broadcast decision can make even a compelling test feel harder to embrace. [Read more 🡒]
Wisconsin Gets One More Tune-Up Before Penn State Arrives
Wisconsin gets one more chance to clean up the details before Big Ten play begins, and the final stop on the non-conference schedule comes Saturday morning against Eastern Michigan. After a 36-9 win over Western Illinois in Week 2, the Badgers have some good tape to build on, especially in the running game, but there were also enough offensive inconsistencies to keep the staffs attention focused on the finer points of execution.
The defense had its own uneven start against Western Illinois before settling in, so this matchup offers one last opportunity to sharpen things before Penn State arrives. Wisconsin and Eastern Michigan will kick at 11:00 a.m. CT on Peacock, and for the Badgers it feels less like a glamour spot than a needed final tune-up with the schedule about to tighten up in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]