Wisconsin’s Week 2 trip to Camp Randall Stadium brings a familiar kind of early-season matchup: a FCS opponent with some returning pieces, a few new faces, and a quarterback situation worth watching.
The Badgers will host Western Illinois on Saturday, Sept. 12, with kickoff set for 6:15 p.m. CT on BTN. The Leathernecks finished 4-8 in 2025, but they closed the year with some momentum, winning three of their final four games.
Joe Davis is heading into his third season as Western Illinois’ head coach. He’s 8-16 overall, and his roster has been reshaped a bit heading into this fall. According to WGEM, the Leathernecks brought back 18 players who have started games and added 19 more with previous NCAA starting experience.
The numbers from last season show why this is still a work in progress. Western Illinois averaged 338.1 yards per game on offense, which ranked No. 85 in the FCS, and allowed 429.2 yards per game on defense, which ranked No. 112.
There are a few names to keep in mind on both sides of the ball. On offense, former Wisconsin lineman James Durand started all 12 games for Western Illinois in 2025 and is expected to be a key part of the lineup again. The redshirt junior was voted a team captain this summer.
On defense, Keshawn Harrington-McKinney is one of the more established returners. He’s played in 21 games over the last two seasons and was recently named to the Preseason Defensive Players to Watch List at the OVC media day.
The biggest storyline may be under center. Western Illinois brings back Cason Carswell, the OVC Offensive Freshman of the Year in 2025, but it also added Kennedy McGill through the transfer portal this winter.
McGill was a true dual-threat quarterback at Central Washington, putting up 1,637 passing yards and 1,040 rushing yards as a redshirt junior. He also won the Lone Star Conference Offensive Player of the Year award after throwing 17 touchdowns and running for 17 more in 2025.
That leaves a real question for Wisconsin: could both quarterbacks see the field at Camp Randall?
Western Illinois’ other notable players include Carswell, running back Ihson Jackson-Anderson, wide receiver Christian Anaya and tight end David Hargro on offense, along with linebacker Nick Reinicke, defensive back Don Paul Keith, punter Luke Droegemueller and kick returner Israel Hiraldo on defense.
The broader outlook points to a tough climb for the Leathernecks. They were picked sixth in the eight-team Ohio Valley Conference preseason poll, ahead of only Eastern Illinois and Tennessee State. They also lost two major pieces through the portal: running back Markell Holman to Wyoming and linebacker Christian Pierce to Michigan.
The matchup looks heavily tilted toward Wisconsin. ESPN’s FPI gives the Badgers a 99 percent chance to win in Week 2, setting up a game where the goal is simple: stay healthy, get backups snaps, and move on to Week 3 against Eastern Michigan.
Wisconsin’s 2026 schedule continues to build from there, with Notre Dame in Week 1, Eastern Michigan in Week 3, and conference and Big Ten play following after that.
In Other News...
Wisconsins Lambeau Opener Will Say A Lot About Luke Fickell
Wisconsins 2026 opener at Lambeau Field already stands out as one of the biggest games on the schedule, and not just because it brings Notre Dame to Green Bay for a neutral-site showcase. It will be the first real measuring stick for Luke Fickell in a season that begins with a national spotlight, a demanding opponent and a schedule that is fully laid out from Week 1 through the regular-season finale. For a program trying to keep moving forward under a coach still shaping the roster and identity, the first Saturday in September figures to carry extra weight.
Notre Dame arrives with the kind of profile that makes an early upset difficult, built around continuity, a veteran coaching staff and more depth than Wisconsin can match on paper right now. Fickell has talked this offseason about the work ahead and the importance of being ready from the start, and this matchup will test how close the Badgers are to that standard. The full slate offers chances to settle in after the opener, but the tone of the season may already be set by the time the teams leave Lambeau Field. [Read more 🡒]
Wisconsin May Be Headed For A Kicking Battle Fans Dread
Wisconsins kicking situation has become one of those quiet summer storylines that can wind up mattering more than anyone expects. Nathanial Vakos, who has handled the job before, is trying to come back for a fifth college season while working through a legal battle for additional eligibility, and that has left the Badgers with an uneasy waiting game as they sort out what the spot might look like if he is not part of it.
For now, the roster picture only adds to the uncertainty. Gavin Lahm and Brady Lelum are both in the mix, but neither has attempted a field goal in college, which makes the competition feel more about projection than proven production. If Vakos does get back on the field, Wisconsin will still have to decide whether his past work makes him the safest answer, or whether this position is headed for the kind of fall battle fans would rather avoid. [Read more 🡒]
Wisconsin May Have Finally Found The Spark Jeff Grimes Needed
Wisconsin has spent much of the Luke Fickell era searching for steadier play at quarterback, with transfers cycling through and too often not sticking around long enough to provide the kind of continuity an offense needs. This offseason brought another swing at solving that problem, but the addition of Colton Joseph from Old Dominion feels a little different because of the way he plays rather than just where he came from.
Joseph brings a dynamic style that could fit what coordinator Jeff Grimes wants to build, and CBS Sports recently ranked him among the 10 most elusive quarterbacks in college football based on several performance metrics. For a program that has been trying to find a spark and an identity under center, the appeal is obvious, even if the real answer still has to be proven once the games start. [Read more 🡒]