Wisconsin’s early season has already put one of Greg Gard’s biggest questions under the microscope: is this bench actually deep, or just full of guys still trying to find their footing?
The Badgers don’t have the kind of star power they’ve leaned on in recent seasons with John Tonje, Nick Boyd and John Blackwell. What they do appear to have is a group that can cover minutes, and maybe more than that. That depth showed up against Fairfield on Tuesday, but it’s still fair to wonder how reliable this second unit will be once the games tighten up.
Gard has already had to lean on his reserves in meaningful spots because the first two games - against Denver and Delaware - were closer than expected. The rotation is still being sorted out.
Austin Rapp has been coming off the bench for now, and he’ll play. So will Jack Janicki and Will Garlock.
Beyond that trio, the rest of the minutes are still up for grabs.
The biggest lineup question right now sits in the frontcourt. Victory Onuetu has started next to Nolan Winter, and it’s worth watching whether Gard sticks with that look all season.
Wisconsin has also used Winter and Rapp together, and that pairing works. Still, there’s a case for keeping Onuetu in the starting five.
The concern with moving Rapp up is what happens to the scoring punch behind him. If he’s starting, the second unit loses the one bench player who has shown he can consistently provide offense right now. And in the Big Ten, Onuetu figures to draw foul pressure anyway, which could mean Rapp is playing starter-level minutes whether he’s listed with the first group or not.
Rapp’s numbers through three games tell the story. Against Denver, when Onuetu was dealing with foul trouble, Rapp logged 30 minutes, scored nine points and pulled down five rebounds.
Against Delaware, Onuetu was excellent, so Rapp played only 14 minutes and didn’t score. Then came Tuesday against Fairfield, when he put up a team-high 15 points and added six rebounds in 21 minutes.
The bench production around him has been uneven. In the opener, Janicki and Jackson Ball combined for seven points outside of Rapp.
Against Delaware, Janicki scored seven, and Zach Kinziger added a free throw - and that was it from the reserves. Against Fairfield, the Stags game being out of hand opened the door for more bench output across the board.
Janicki remains the most experienced guard coming off the bench, and at this point in his fourth season, he’s pretty well defined. He brings energy, can stir things up defensively, and whatever he gives Wisconsin on offense is a bonus.
Tuesday did bring a little more from the other reserve guards. Kinziger scored all seven of his points in the first half, hitting his first 3-pointer and then knocking down four free throws. Ball got downhill for a pair of first-half layups and added another one late to finish with six points.
Then there’s Trey Autry, the newcomer who averaged double figures in the Atlantic 10 last season and entered with some expectation that he’d be a real piece for this team. So far, though, he hasn’t played rotational minutes. Among the bench guards, he has the strongest scoring résumé at the Division I level, but he’s not in the regular mix yet.
Maybe that changes. Maybe Autry settles in and becomes the scoring option Wisconsin needs behind Rapp. But right now, the Badgers probably need a step forward from Kinziger or Ball if this bench is going to matter in a high-major league.
That’s where things stand for now: no final answer, just a moving target. Rapp could end up starting later.
If he doesn’t, he looks like the most likely bench scorer. Either way, Gard still needs his young guards to grow if this second unit is going to hold up when conference play arrives.
Three games in, Wisconsin’s bench looks better than it did on opening night. That’s the good news. The rest is still a work in progress, and how those reserves affect games is going to stay on the radar as the non-conference schedule rolls on.
In Other News...
Wisconsin Recruiting Loss Just Got More Painful For Badgers Fans
Wisconsins 2027 basketball class took a hit when Jack Thelen, the 7-foot-1 center who had previously pledged to the Badgers, backed off that commitment and landed at UConn instead. Thelen, ranked No. 88 nationally in the class by Rivals, had given Wisconsin a promising frontcourt piece for the future, and his departure changes the look of an early group that had already started to take shape.
The Badgers still have two four-star guards committed in the class, so the foundation is not gone, but losing a big man of Thelens size and profile stings. It also adds another layer to the challenge of holding off blueblood-level competition, with UConn continuing to build one of the nations strongest classes and sitting No. 2 nationally on 247Sports. [Read more 🡒]
Racine Case Just Ended A Drought Wisconsin Fans Will Appreciate
Racine Case gave Wisconsin high school football fans a familiar kind of thrill with a finish that came down to the final kick. Senior kicker Colin Gardner drilled a 28-yard field goal as time expired to lift Case past Muskego 6-3 in the WIAA Division 1 state quarterfinals, sending the team on to the state semifinals against West De Pere.
For a program with a long history but a long wait, the moment carried extra weight. Racine Case is headed to the state semifinals for the first time since 1980, ending a 46-year drought and giving its supporters a milestone they had waited generations to see. [Read more 🡒]
Wisconsin Has A Nolan Winter Problem Fans Cant Ignore
Nolan Winters start to the 2026-27 season has been quieter than Wisconsin fans are used to seeing from the senior big man. His numbers are down across the board, and his shooting has not matched the efficiency he typically brings, even though he is still helping the Badgers with rebounding, passing and rim protection.
The bigger question for Wisconsin is what comes next, because Winters value has not disappeared, it has just been uneven so far. If the Badgers can get him more involved offensively and he continues to move past whatever has slowed him early, there is still a path for him to look more like the player Wisconsin needs in the frontcourt. [Read more 🡒]