Wisconsin brought in Malachi Coleman for a reason: the Badgers wanted a receiver with a profile nobody else in that room can really match.
At 6-foot-5 and 205 pounds, the Minnesota transfer is the tallest wideout on the roster, and his background still carries plenty of intrigue. Coleman arrived in Madison after a winding start to his college career, one that began with major recruiting buzz.
He was a consensus top-65 prospect in the 2023 class and ranked as high as the 10th-best receiver in the country depending on the service. On paper, that kind of pedigree makes him one of the more interesting additions Wisconsin made this offseason.
The production, though, has never caught up to the hype. Coleman spent two seasons at Nebraska after initially committing there out of high school, and his only real statistical impact came as a true freshman, when he caught eight passes for 139 yards and one touchdown. He redshirted as a sophomore, then had a quiet season with Minnesota last fall.
Even so, there’s still real ability here. Coleman didn’t draw much attention during Wisconsin’s spring work, but his skill set stands out in a crowded receiver room. He offers size the Badgers can use in ways they can’t with their other wideouts, especially when the offense gets near the goal line or needs a bigger body on the field.
That’s where his best path to playing time lives. Coleman doesn’t need to become a star right away to matter.
He still has two seasons of eligibility left, so the more realistic goal is to grow into a useful piece now and position himself for a bigger role later. If he develops as a redshirt junior and gives himself a chance to compete for a starting job as a senior, that would be a solid outcome.
For this fall, though, a starting spot looks unlikely. The more believable role is rotational: a receiver used in red-zone packages, on jump-ball situations and in spots where Wisconsin wants extra size and blocking on the perimeter. That frame could help him earn snaps even if the target share stays limited.
The upside is straightforward enough. Coleman has the potential to be the kind of receiver Wisconsin can throw to when it needs someone to go win a one-on-one ball. The Badgers haven’t had much of that lately, and his size gives him a chance to fill that niche.
The floor is much less exciting. The comparison that comes to mind is Joseph Griffin Jr., another big-bodied Wisconsin receiver whose traits never really translated into consistent playing time. If Coleman follows that path, he could spend another year mostly on the fringe, use up another season of eligibility and eventually have to think about his next move.
A lot depends on the rest of Wisconsin’s offense. If the passing game takes a step forward, Coleman has a better chance to be part of the rotation. If it doesn’t, there may not be enough opportunities to go around for him to make much of an imprint.
Right now, the most reasonable expectation is modest production. Coleman looks like a player who could help in specific situations, not one who’s likely to drive the passing game. Single-digit catches this fall feels like the most realistic outcome.
In Other News...
Wisconsin Just Raised The Stakes For Luke Fickell
Wisconsins football program has entered a familiar kind of waiting game, one that comes with a new face in the athletic department and plenty of questions attached to the head coach. Luke Fickell remains the man in charge in Madison, but the mixed results of his tenure have kept the conversation around the program from settling, especially now that Shawn Eichorst is the athletic director overseeing the next phase.
Eichorst brings his own history to the job, including a reputation for making hard coaching calls after moving quickly on the sidelines at Nebraska. For Fickell, that means the pressure around Wisconsins direction is not going away anytime soon, and the coming months will matter as the Badgers try to show whether the roster changes and portal additions can finally push the program forward. [Read more 🡒]
Eric Fletcher Jr. Could Change Wisconsin's Cornerback Conversation
Wisconsins secondary has been looking for another piece to help reshape the cornerback picture, and Eric Fletcher Jr. is bringing the kind of athletic profile that can make that conversation more interesting. The redshirt sophomore arrived from Oklahoma State with a little bit of game experience already on his rsum, and his speed and quickness have stood out as traits that fit what the Badgers need on the back end.
Fletcher is still in the early part of his Wisconsin story, but there is enough there to suggest he can push for a rotational spot and keep climbing from there. He showed some playmaking ability in his previous season, and if that carries over, the Badgers may have found a corner who can do more than just add depth. [Read more 🡒]