Drew Mestemaker carved up West Virginia for 389 passing yards and three touchdowns Saturday night, and Oklahoma State walked out of Milan Puskar Stadium with a 41-24 win in front of 57,756.
The Cowboys got their biggest damage through the air, with Mestemaker finishing 20 of 27 for a 224.4 passer rating and repeatedly finding Wyatt Young, who caught eight passes for 192 yards. Oklahoma State also leaned on Caleb Hawkins, who piled up 180 rushing yards on 31 carries as the Cowboys finished with 609 total yards.
That number stood out for more than one reason. It was the most yards allowed by a West Virginia defense since the Mountaineers gave up 616 in a 40-10 loss to TCU on Oct. 29, 2015.
West Virginia coach Rich Rodriguez did not hide his frustration after the game.
"Offensively we were moving okay, but defensively we didn't play well at all," West Virginia coach Rich Rodriguez said afterward. "We gave up 609 yards.
We didn't give our guys a chance. It's the head coach's responsibility to make sure we have a plan that could succeed, and it didn't succeed.
I didn't do a good job of making sure our plan was going to help us succeed."
The Mountaineers actually ran the ball well, finishing with 334 rushing yards, including 193 from Cam Cook and 102 from Michael Hawkins Jr. But the passing game never really matched that production. Hawkins completed 10 of 22 passes for 132 yards and an interception, though Rodriguez said he was hurt by a couple of big drops.
"Offensively, there was some good stuff, but there were some things we missed in the passing game. Defensively, it was nothing," Rodriguez said.
West Virginia (3-1, 0-1) spent much of the night pounding away on the ground and got a pair of short touchdown runs from Hawkins in the first half. Those scores came within four minutes of each other, but the Mountaineers let a chance for more points slip away late in the second quarter, and Oklahoma State made them pay with a touchdown just before halftime.
The first half belonged to the ground game for West Virginia. On the third play of its second possession, Cook ripped off a 75-yard run to the OSU 9 before being tracked down from behind by Mo Horn. Two short Cook runs set up Hawkins’ 5-yard touchdown run.
Later in the second quarter, after Sam Ketner’s 30-yard field goal, West Virginia mounted another long march from its own 25. That drive covered 75 yards in 16 plays, 15 of them runs, and ended with Hawkins scoring from the 3. The Mountaineers converted two third downs on the possession, including a third-and-7 on which Cook took an end-around for 10 yards to the OSU 38.
Oklahoma State (3-1, 1-0) answered with field goals and then started taking control through Mestemaker. The Cowboys got a second Ketner field goal with 7:56 left in the second quarter after a drive stalled at the West Virginia 1, then turned a West Virginia interception into points. On third and 4 at the OSU 18, Hawkins tried a slant to Jaden Bray, but Keviyan Huddleston tipped it and Mose Phillips III intercepted, returning it 30 yards to the Cowboy 45.
Mestemaker immediately went to work. He hit Young on third down for 21 yards, then connected with Justin Bowick for a 21-yard touchdown.
Geimere Latimer II appeared to have Bowick wrapped up near the 10, but Bowick broke free and finished the play in the end zone. Ketner’s kick made it 14-13, which is where the score stayed at halftime.
West Virginia grabbed momentum again to start the third quarter. OSU opened the half with a 52-yard strike from Mestemaker to Chris Barnes, but Kamari Wilson intercepted Mestemaker on the next key snap.
The Mountaineers then drove on the ground again, with Hawkins taking a 12-yard run that included a 15-yard penalty on Ethan Wesloski for hitting him late out of bounds, and later adding a 24-yard burst on third and 8. Cook followed with runs of 17 and 3 yards, and Hawkins finished the march with a 9-yard touchdown run for a 21-13 lead.
That edge did not last long. Mestemaker needed only four plays to answer, with big gains to Terrence Lewis and Young setting up a 4-yard touchdown pass to Lewis. OSU’s first two-point try failed, but after Wilson was flagged for pass interference, the Cowboys got another shot and Mestemaker hit Lewis to tie the game at 21.
West Virginia nudged back in front with a 27-yard field goal from Cassidy, but the Mountaineers could not cash in when they had the ball at the 4. Hawkins was stopped for no gain on third down, forcing the field goal.
From there, Oklahoma State took over for good. Mestemaker hit Young for 48 yards to the WVU 25, and Caleb Hawkins broke loose for a 22-yard touchdown to give the Cowboys their first lead of the night. West Virginia’s next response died at the OSU 40 on fourth and 1 when Amari Latimer was dropped for a 2-yard loss.
Mestemaker kept pressing. He found Young for 48 more yards to the WVU 35, but the drive stalled at the 6 after an illegal procedure penalty pushed the ball back to the 11 and a third-down throw was knocked away by Harper Holloman. That set up a 29-yard field goal by Keltner.
Mestemaker’s third touchdown pass came three minutes before that final field goal, a 6-yard throw to Young in the back of the end zone. Keltner added another field goal with 2:46 remaining.
The result extended Oklahoma State’s run at Milan Puskar Stadium. The Cowboys have now won six straight in Morgantown since 2015, the most consecutive victories there since Miami won six straight from 1986 to 2002.
West Virginia heads to Iowa State next Saturday for its first true road game of the season. That one kicks off at noon and will be televised nationally on TNT and TruTV.
In Other News...
Rich Rodriguez Just Raised Two Big Concerns For West Virginia
Rich Rodriguez used his latest Coaches Show appearance to take a clear-eyed look at where West Virginia stands after the loss to Oklahoma State, and the picture he painted was not especially comforting. He pointed to defensive issues that showed up in the defeat, while also noting the offense had its own share of work to do as the Mountaineers try to steady things heading into a tougher stretch.
The next test comes against Iowa State, a team Rodriguez described as dangerous because of its defense and an experienced quarterback, which only sharpens the margin for error. He also offered an update on Armoni Bomar-Weavers finger injury and touched on the broader questions of player development and roster building, reminders that West Virginias concerns run beyond one game and into the shape of what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Geno Smith Led A Strong Weekend For Former West Virginia Stars
West Virginia had plenty to track across the NFLs third weekend, with nine former Mountaineers active on rosters and several of them turning in meaningful snaps. The headliner was Geno Smith, who delivered one of the sharper outings of the week by completing 31 of 37 passes for 321 yards and three touchdowns, a reminder that the schools NFL pipeline keeps producing players who can still shape games at the highest level.
Rasul Douglas also continued his steady run, starting for the Commanders in their win over the Seahawks and giving the Mountaineers another familiar name in a prominent spot. Beyond those two, the rest of the weekend was a useful snapshot of how wide West Virginias pro footprint has become, with each players snap count and Pro Football Focus grade offering another layer to a busy slate for the programs alumni. [Read more 🡒]
WVU May Be Nearing Lineup Changes Fans Have Been Waiting For
West Virginias Week 5 depth chart for Iowa State did not bring the kind of sweeping shakeup some fans were hoping for, but it did reinforce that the staff is at least keeping an eye on a few spots that could use a jolt. Most of the player positions look the same as the previous week, which suggests the Mountaineers are still leaning on a familiar base as they try to steady things heading into another Big 12 test.
Still, there are signs the lineup could look different sooner rather than later. Georgia transfer JaCorey Thomas is expected to make his debut, and there is potential for some movement in the defensive backfield as the staff searches for the right mix. The offensive line is another area worth watching if the performance does not improve, leaving this weeks chart less like a final answer and more like a snapshot of a roster that may still be in flux. [Read more 🡒]