The Nationals just got a reminder of what Max Scherzer can still do, even at 41.
On a rehab assignment for the Blue Jays, Scherzer faced the Rochester Red Wings, Washington’s Triple-A affiliate, and delivered five no-hit innings with seven strikeouts. That’s not the kind of line that screams “finished,” even if his six big league starts this year have told a rougher story. His ERA is over 10, and the old ace has looked every bit his age at times.
Still, if the Blue Jays are out of the race, there’s at least a case for Washington to kick the tires on the greatest pitcher in franchise history. If Scherzer looked anywhere close to that rehab outing, he’d be an upgrade over the likes of Mikolas and Littell. It’s a long shot, but it’s not hard to see why the idea has some appeal.
The biggest reason is simple: this would be a cheap flier on a pitcher who still has some upside. Scherzer gave the Blue Jays valuable innings in the playoffs last year, and he showed he could still start a World Series game when he took the ball in Game 7. Even now, there’s a version of him that can rise to the moment.
That matters if the Nationals somehow sneak into the playoffs. In that scenario, Scherzer could fit as the team’s No. 3 starter, and there’s a strong argument he offers more upside than Littell, Mikolas and Alvarez. He may not have anything close to a full season left in him, but the old stuff still shows up in bursts: the fastball a little livelier, the slider sharper, the command tighter.
The price would be minimal. Scherzer turns 42 in a few days, and because he hasn’t been effective this season, he likely wouldn’t cost much more than cash or a player to be named later. At worst, Washington might have to part with an org player who isn’t expected to make the majors.
There’s also the atmosphere angle. Scherzer would instantly matter to the crowd, and Nationals Park would feel different with him back on the mound.
The Nationals haven’t had much of a home-field edge this year, and in fact they own the worst home record in baseball. A reunion with Scherzer would bring buzz, and with it, better crowds.
Then there’s the clubhouse effect. A young arm like Cade Cavalli could gain plenty from being around one of the great power pitchers of all time.
Cavalli likely grew up watching Scherzer, and may have even talked with him during 2021 Spring Training. That kind of knowledge doesn’t show up in a box score, but it still matters.
Scherzer would also bring playoff experience to a roster that doesn’t have much of it. And if this were to happen, it would almost certainly lock in his Hall of Fame path as a National, which would make for a fitting ending. Seeing the best player in franchise history finish in Washington would be a special thing.
This probably doesn’t fit neatly into Paul Toboni’s model, and it’s not the kind of move that screams long-term logic. But the Nationals do need a third starter who could take the ball in a playoff game, and Scherzer has shown very recently that he can still be effective in that kind of setting.
Maybe it’s a dream after one rehab start. Maybe it’s delusional. But if there’s one last chance to see Mad Max in a Nationals uniform, rocking the Curly W at Nationals Park, it’s hard not to want it.
In Other News...
Nationals Have Two Rotation Problems They Cant Ignore Anymore
The Nationals have reached the point where their rotation issues are no longer just a midseason annoyance. Zack Littell and Miles Mikolas have not given the club enough length or consistency, and the strain has shown up in a bullpen that keeps getting asked to cover too many innings. When two starters are regularly working short outings, the rest of the staff feels it, and Washington has been living that reality for weeks.
There are only so many ways to patch it, which is why the conversation has started to turn toward outside help and internal options alike. The trade market could offer names such as Seth Lugo, Reid Detmers, Dylan Cease, Casey Mize and Tarik Skubal, while the organization also has to decide how aggressively it wants to test its own depth. Jackson Kent has not yet been pushed to Triple-A, leaving the Nationals with a rotation question that is becoming harder to postpone. [Read more 🡒]
Nationals Offense Is Building A Storyline Fans Cant Ignore
The Nationals are heading into a six-game homestand with a lineup that has started to look like more than just a collection of young bats. Washington opens against the Diamondbacks before turning to the Blue Jays, and the early signs are hard to miss: the club leads the majors in stolen bases, Nasim Nuez is pacing the sport individually, and James Wood has become a constant threat at the top of the order while ranking among the National Leagues top hitters in several offensive categories.
Woods production has given this offense a different kind of edge, one that blends power with pressure on the bases and makes every inning feel a little less settled for opposing pitchers. CJ Abrams and Wood have also put themselves in rare company among MLBs all-around threats, and the bigger question now is whether Washington can keep stacking those kinds of performances as the homestand unfolds and the lineups momentum gets tested by a pair of different pitching staffs. [Read more 🡒]