Days after the Nationals won the 2019 World Series, the celebration gave way to a fresh round of frustration. Stephen Strasburg opted out of his contract and joined Anthony Rendon as another major free agent, and suddenly fans had a new target for their complaints. The same ones, maybe, who had griped about the parade route.
That reaction came after Washington had already brought back Howie Kendrick, Yan Gomes, Asdrubal Cabrera, Daniel Hudson, Adam Eaton, and Ryan Zimmerman. The club also committed big money to Strasburg, whose new $245 million deal was a record at the time. Even so, some fans were still unhappy that Rendon left, with the story becoming that he wanted to be closer to his home near Houston, even though Los Angeles really wasn’t closer.
Looking back, the bigger question is whether the Nationals had any real path to keep the run going. Former GM Mike Rizzo had to make those calls without knowing how the story would unfold, and that matters.
The 2019 team was built around aging veterans known as the Los Viejos, plus Juan Soto, who had just turned 21 a few days before the World Series. It was also a club that stumbled badly out of the gate, with injuries to Trea Turner, Rendon, and others helping drag down a season that followed an underwhelming 2018.
By late May of that year, the mood around the team had already turned sour. In the Washington Post on May 23, 2019, ex-writer Barry Svrluga published an article titled: Who Cares About Davey Martinez?
In a Lost Season, Nationals Face Tougher Decisions. The next day, the Nationals began the run that carried them all the way to a championship.
Svrluga was wrong then, and Davey Martinez still had the energy and the clubhouse support to lead that group. The article also notes that after the 2022 season, Martinez should have been fired, and that in 2023 a new coaching staff arrived and things still went badly.
Even with the title in hand, the path through October was razor-thin. The Nationals were this |--| close to getting bounced in the Wild Card round.
They faced elimination five times, and in each of those games they were trailing before coming back. Kendrick, Rendon, Strasburg, and the rest delivered huge postseason performances.
None of that is meant to shrink what happened. For the writer, it was the high point of a lifetime as a sports fan and someone who had covered the return of baseball to Washington, D.C. since 2004.
But even with the championship, the 2019 club may have been one of the weakest teams in the eight-year stretch from 2012 to 2019. And even if Rendon had returned, the more likely outcome was that the window was closing anyway.
The loss of Rendon mattered, though. He was near the top of the roster in offense throughout the 2019 season, and the Nationals never really replaced him, aside from a short stint from Jeimer Candelario.
Third base and first base have been problems ever since. Brady House may become a star, but that remains to be seen.
Rizzo also made a run at Josh Donaldson, which showed he still believed the team could compete.
Still, trying to run it back with the same core, minus Rendon, was not a sustainable baseball plan. At the same time, a champion always feels pressure to defend the title with the same group that won it, so this isn’t framed as a criticism piece.
It’s more a look back before the hot stove really starts heating up. The Milwaukee Brewers may face similar pressure.
With hindsight, other choices might have been possible. The Nationals could have traded Max Scherzer and Turner earlier and gotten more back in prospects.
Keibert Ruiz is finally producing, and there is still the final stretch of Josiah Gray’s tenure to watch. But the bigger picture points to a team headed for a fall.
By the end of 2019, there probably wasn’t much that could have stopped it.
The conclusion here is blunt: years of poor drafting and developmental failures left the Nationals with little room to pivot. Going all in year after year was the only route available, and eventually the franchise had to start over from scratch. That’s where things stand now, with hope tied to Paul Toboni and whatever comes next.
In Other News...
Nationals Young Core Is Starting To Earn Real League-Wide Attention
The Nationals rebuild has started to look a lot less theoretical as award season arrives, with several of the clubs young names showing up on league-wide ballots and shortlists. Daylen Lile is in line for his first Gold Glove consideration in left field, while James Wood and CJ Abrams have both pushed themselves into Silver Slugger contention after establishing themselves as central pieces of Washingtons next core.
There is also broader recognition building around the group beyond the major awards. Jacob Young picked up the Nationals Heart & Hustle honor for a second straight year, Jarlin Susana looks like a strong candidate for the AFL Fall Stars Game, and Abrams, Wood and Cade Cavalli all landed on the All-MLB Team ballot. For a franchise still shaping its identity, it is a useful sign that the attention is no longer limited to what happens in Washington alone. [Read more 🡒]
Nationals Already Face Tough Calls In Paul Tobonis First Roster Crunch
The Nationals wasted little time making their first move of the offseason roster shuffle, claiming right-hander Braxton Roxby off waivers and designating Zak Kent for assignment. It is the kind of transaction that barely registers on its own, but for a club already dealing with the constraints of players on the 60-day injured list, it is also a reminder that the work of trimming and rearranging the roster has already begun.
Paul Tobonis front office is expected to stay busy as it evaluates the full picture and looks for ways to reshape the group heading into next season. More moves are likely on the way, including possible non-tenders for players such as Jake Irvin and Jose Tena, which would only add to the sense that this winter will be less about tweaking and more about making hard choices. [Read more 🡒]
Nationals Deadline Trade Still Hinges On One Risky Rotation Bet
Paul Tobonis deadline move brought Connelly Early back into his orbit in Washington, a familiar name for the Nationals new decision-maker after he drafted the left-hander in Boston. The trade also came with Curtis Mead, whose season was derailed almost immediately by a wrist injury that cost him the rest of the year, leaving the deal to be judged less on what it produced right away and more on what each player can still become.
Early was hurt when the trade was made, but he made it back late in the season and looked effective in a brief appearance, which only adds to the intrigue around how Washington views his role going forward. For the Nationals, the real question now is whether this kind of rotation gamble pays off, or whether the return they got will be defined by the health and development of a pitcher whose path has already been interrupted once. [Read more 🡒]