Every November, baseball’s awards season turns into a second round of judgment, and the ballots can be just as controversial as anything that happened on the field. The BBWAA still handles the sport’s biggest honors - MVP, Cy Young, Rookie of the Year, and Manager of the Year - and most years the process lands in the right place. Still, the grumbling never really stops.
This year brought a fresh wave of it. Fans of Geraldo Perdomo were irritated that he finished as the third-rated shortstop in the National League and received no votes at all.
His 5.0 WAR stood out, but the rest of the profile didn’t scream superstar: a .747 OPS in a hitter’s park, limited power, and a lot of value tied to defense. Otto Lopez did his damage in a pitcher’s park and got MVP votes, while CJ Abrams landed just ahead of him and also drew votes, though not enough.
Abrams was the fourth-rated shortstop in the NL.
The awards themselves weren’t the issue so much as the way the runner-up spots shook out. Jacob Young didn’t crack the top three in Gold Glove voting.
Blake Butera, by the argument being made here, deserved at least a vote or two for Manager of the Year recognition. Daylen Lile ended up as a Gold Glove finalist in left field and finished third, which raised eyebrows.
Abrams finished 14th in NL MVP voting and James Wood came in 16th, so both were acknowledged - but the placement still invited questions. Bryce Harper was sandwiched between them, and that only sharpened the debate.
Both Philadelphia voters had Harper; neither Washington voter had Abrams, and one of them, Mark Zuckerman, left both Abrams and Wood off his ballot. Todd Zolecki gave Harper a fifth-place MVP vote, even though the award ballot stretches 10 spots deep and Harper ranked 30th in WAR, well behind Abrams and Wood.
That’s where the larger complaint comes in: when outside voters are seeing your players more favorably than the local ones, people start wondering what the hometown ballot missed. Abrams, after all, was a 30/30 player, and when his 100-plus RBIs and 30-plus doubles are added in, he becomes one of only 11 players in MLB history to hit that milestone combination.
The bigger issue, though, is the one that shows up every year: accusations of homerism. Because BBWAA awards voting is built around local beat writers, fans and critics often believe the system gives an edge to the players those writers cover every day. And sometimes the opposite charge gets thrown around too - not favoritism, but a grudge.
The structure of the voting explains why the criticism sticks. For each major award, two writers are selected from every MLB city, creating 30 voters per award across both leagues.
National League writers vote only on NL awards, and American League writers handle AL honors. The ballots use a point system: MVP voters rank 10 players, with first place worth 14 points and 10th worth one.
Cy Young ballots list five pitchers on a 7-4-3-2-1 scale, while Rookie of the Year and Manager of the Year ballots rank three candidates at 5-3-1. And all of it is due before the postseason starts, so the awards are supposed to reflect the regular season only.
The concern is simple enough. Most of the electorate spends 162 games around one team, not the whole league.
That familiarity can color the vote. A writer who watches a player every night sees the clutch hits, the big innings, the subtle defensive plays.
A rival city’s player is often just a line in a box score.
That’s how some of the most famous voting flashpoints have happened. In the 2016 AL Cy Young race, Boston’s Rick Porcello beat Detroit’s Justin Verlander by five points even though Verlander got more first-place votes, 14 to 8.
When the full ballots came out, two Tampa Bay-area voters had left Verlander off their five-man ballots entirely, while Baltimore voters put Orioles closer Zach Britton first. In the 2017 NL MVP vote, Miami’s Giancarlo Stanton and Cincinnati’s Joey Votto were locked in a tight race, and the two Miami-based voters put Stanton first while the two Cincinnati-based voters did the same for Votto.
John Lott put the challenge plainly when he explained why he stepped away from voting: “You cover a player every day, you appreciate him more. You see his rival less.”
The system has changed, though. Since 2012, BBWAA ballots have been made public right after the winners are announced, which means every vote is now open to scrutiny.
That transparency has made writers far more careful. The obvious outlier ballot is a lot harder to hide when fans, analysts, and fellow writers can see it immediately.
At the same time, modern voters lean heavily on metrics like WAR, OPS+, and FIP, which help them compare players across markets instead of relying only on what they saw in person.
That shift has also produced more consensus. In 2026, baseball saw both MVP winners and both Cy Young winners elected unanimously in the same season, a sign that the most extreme regional outliers have mostly disappeared from the top of the ballot.
So does local bias still exist? Sure, at the margins.
Down-ballot spots - the 8th through 10th places on an MVP ticket - can still be where a beat writer rewards a hometown player for a strong year. But the era when one local vote could swing a major award race feels increasingly like a thing of the past.
In Other News...
James Wood Just Became A Bigger Nationals Question Than Ever
The Nationals have made a habit lately of talking about their young core in more permanent terms, and James Wood is now the next name at the center of that conversation. Former general manager Jim Bowden reported that Washington is trying to work out a long-term extension with the outfielder, a sign the club sees him as more than just a promising piece of the rebuild. Wood is already under team control through the 2030 season, but the organizations recent moves with Jacob Young and Cade Cavalli show it is willing to lock up players it believes can matter for a long time.
Woods appeal is obvious. He has already flashed the kind of power that can change the shape of a lineup, with consecutive 30-home run seasons giving the Nationals a real middle-of-the-order presence to build around. The question now is not whether Washington wants to keep him, but how aggressively it will move to make that happen, and whether the sides can find common ground before Woods value climbs even higher. [Read more 🡒]
Nationals Fans Have A New Reason To Dream On Jarlin Susana
The Arizona Fall League is usually where front offices go hunting for one more glimpse of what a prospect might become, and this year gave the Nationals a particularly encouraging one. With fewer elite names in the showcase, Jarlin Susana still managed to stand out above the rest, earning Pitcher of the Year honors after leading the league in strikeouts and carrying a 0.00 ERA in postseason innings.
For a Nationals system still looking for impact arms, that kind of finish matters. Scouts were in the stands anyway, trying to sort through a low-scoring championship game full of errors and a field of prospects whose futures are clouded by uncertainty around the next minor league season, and Susana gave them a reminder that Washington may already have one of the more intriguing pitchers in the pipeline. [Read more 🡒]
Jarlin Susana Just Gave Nationals Fans Another Reason To Believe
The Arizona Fall League wrapped up with plenty of hardware for some of baseballs most closely watched prospects, and Jarlin Susana was right in the middle of it. The Nationals right-hander was named Pitcher of the Year, a recognition that fits the buzz he has been building as one of the organizations most intriguing young arms. Around him, the leagues other top honors went to Welbyn Francisca, Tai Peete, Vance Honeycutt and Jack ODowd, a reminder of how much talent was packed into the desert this fall.
For Washington, Susanas award matters because it adds another layer to a farm system that has been trying to turn promise into certainty on the mound. The Fall League is often where prospects either sharpen their case or fade into the background, and Susana did the opposite by putting himself at the front of the conversation. The performance that earned him the honor is the kind of development the Nationals have been waiting to see, even if the bigger question is how soon it carries over to the next level. [Read more 🡒]
