The Nationals are getting tied to a pair of pitchers who fit very different needs, and both names have started to pop up as the offseason moves toward the lockout.
Over the weekend, Washington was linked to A.J. Minter and Dustin May.
Neither one is the kind of splash signing that changes the entire market, but both make sense as realistic targets with something to offer. Minter brings dependability and a track record.
May brings upside and the kind of arm talent that can still tempt a team looking for more.
Minter is the safer bet, and maybe the cleaner fit. The Nationals were missing steady bullpen arms last season, the kind who come in, know exactly what they’re doing, and keep the inning from spinning out.
That is the lane Minter lives in. Jon Morosi connected the 33-year-old left-hander to Washington, and there’s a path where the fit works on both sides.
The reported expectation is that the Nats are not eager to hand out multiple years to relievers, which makes a one-year arrangement feel plausible. Minter could fit that kind of setup. He has dealt with durability issues over the last couple of seasons, but when he’s available, he’s been effective.
Last year, Minter put up a 2.56 ERA across 48 outings with the Mets and Twins. His fastball ticked down a bit after lat surgery in 2025, but the rest of the package still played.
He leaned on his cutter, kept the ball in the zone, and walked just 4.3% of hitters. That kind of command would give Washington’s bullpen a different look.
He also allowed some home runs, but because he didn’t give up many hits or free passes, most of those were solo shots. Minter doesn’t overwhelm hitters with huge strikeout totals or flashy stuff, but he gets outs.
He’d profile nicely as a seventh- or eighth-inning option. The NL East familiarity is another plus, since he spent years in Atlanta and was effective with the Mets last season.
Kyle Schwarber is 1 for 16 against him, and Bryce Harper is 4 for 17 with no homers. A one-year, $9 million deal makes sense for both sides.
May is the more volatile name, but also the one with the louder ceiling. He’s the kind of pitcher people keep circling because the stuff is obvious: high velocity, movement everywhere, and a body of work that keeps hinting at more.
Jim Bowden has connected him to the Nationals, and while Bowden isn’t the strongest source in the world, the idea doesn’t feel far-fetched. May’s age and stuff are the sort of traits Paul Toboni would likely value.
There’s also a Boston angle here. The Red Sox traded a surprisingly rich haul to get May at the deadline while Toboni was in Boston, which adds another layer to the fit.
May’s 2026 season looked a lot like a Dustin May season. He finished with a 4.70 ERA over 145.2 innings, but there were still starts where he looked dominant. The deeper numbers were more forgiving, with a 3.63 FIP and 3.96 xFIP pointing to middle-of-the-rotation potential.
The encouraging part is that he has been relatively healthy over the last two seasons. At 29, that matters.
Pitchers with this kind of profile have sometimes found another level in their 30s, and Zack Wheeler is the example that comes to mind. Wheeler spent most of his 20s either hurt or a little underwhelming, then got paid and turned into a Hall of Fame-level arm in his 30s.
May is not that pitcher, but the idea of his best years still being ahead of him is real.
That upside won’t come cheap. May signed a one-year, $13 million deal last year after a worse season and more health uncertainty, and he threw harder and posted better underlying numbers in 2026 than in 2025.
Teams have also paid surprisingly hefty trade returns for him at deadlines, which says plenty about how the league views him. A deal in the three-year, $45 million range seems like a reasonable guess.
For Washington, it would be a riskier swing than Minter, but one with a bigger payoff if it hits. May is one of the few pitchers on the market under 30 with real developmental upside left to tap into, and that kind of profile could appeal to Toboni.
With only a couple weeks left before the lockout begins, the Nationals still have time to act. Several moves could be coming before then, and Minter and May are two names now in the mix.
In Other News...
James Wood Just Became A Bigger Nationals Question Than Ever
The Nationals have made a habit lately of talking about their young core in more permanent terms, and James Wood is now the next name at the center of that conversation. Former general manager Jim Bowden reported that Washington is trying to work out a long-term extension with the outfielder, a sign the club sees him as more than just a promising piece of the rebuild. Wood is already under team control through the 2030 season, but the organizations recent moves with Jacob Young and Cade Cavalli show it is willing to lock up players it believes can matter for a long time.
Woods appeal is obvious. He has already flashed the kind of power that can change the shape of a lineup, with consecutive 30-home run seasons giving the Nationals a real middle-of-the-order presence to build around. The question now is not whether Washington wants to keep him, but how aggressively it will move to make that happen, and whether the sides can find common ground before Woods value climbs even higher. [Read more 🡒]
Nationals Fans Have A New Reason To Dream On Jarlin Susana
The Arizona Fall League is usually where front offices go hunting for one more glimpse of what a prospect might become, and this year gave the Nationals a particularly encouraging one. With fewer elite names in the showcase, Jarlin Susana still managed to stand out above the rest, earning Pitcher of the Year honors after leading the league in strikeouts and carrying a 0.00 ERA in postseason innings.
For a Nationals system still looking for impact arms, that kind of finish matters. Scouts were in the stands anyway, trying to sort through a low-scoring championship game full of errors and a field of prospects whose futures are clouded by uncertainty around the next minor league season, and Susana gave them a reminder that Washington may already have one of the more intriguing pitchers in the pipeline. [Read more 🡒]
Jarlin Susana Just Gave Nationals Fans Another Reason To Believe
The Arizona Fall League wrapped up with plenty of hardware for some of baseballs most closely watched prospects, and Jarlin Susana was right in the middle of it. The Nationals right-hander was named Pitcher of the Year, a recognition that fits the buzz he has been building as one of the organizations most intriguing young arms. Around him, the leagues other top honors went to Welbyn Francisca, Tai Peete, Vance Honeycutt and Jack ODowd, a reminder of how much talent was packed into the desert this fall.
For Washington, Susanas award matters because it adds another layer to a farm system that has been trying to turn promise into certainty on the mound. The Fall League is often where prospects either sharpen their case or fade into the background, and Susana did the opposite by putting himself at the front of the conversation. The performance that earned him the honor is the kind of development the Nationals have been waiting to see, even if the bigger question is how soon it carries over to the next level. [Read more 🡒]
