As the Nationals kick off Spring Training in West Palm Beach, there's a familiar name echoing through CACTI Park: Max Scherzer. The 41-year-old free agent, known for his fierce competitiveness, is still very much in the game, and while the Braves and Blue Jays are reportedly interested, the Nationals have yet to make a move. But with their recent signing of Miles Mikolas, the case for bringing Scherzer back to D.C. is not just compelling-it's practically screaming to be made.
The Nationals front office described Mikolas as a "stability" addition. Yet, if you're investing in a veteran pitcher, why settle for a back-end starter when you could reignite the fire with a franchise icon like Scherzer?
Mikolas brings consistency, but Scherzer offers more than just innings. He represents a seismic cultural shift and a veteran presence that could profoundly influence a young Nationals roster.
Look at what Justin Verlander did for the Tigers. The Nationals' clubhouse is brimming with young talent, players like Cade Cavalli and Josiah Gray, who could benefit immensely from Scherzer's mentorship and competitive spirit.
The departure of MacKenzie Gore left a significant void in the rotation. While acquiring prospects is valuable, the Nationals now lack a true ace. Bringing Scherzer back on a one-year deal could reinvigorate the fan base and fill seats every fifth day, as long as he stays healthy.
It's not just a public relations victory-it's a strategic baseball move. Scherzer proved during the 2025 postseason with Toronto that he can still rise to the occasion when it matters most, reminiscent of his 2019 heroics with the Nationals. If the team is serious about redefining its culture in 2026, they need a leader who embodies winning.
The Nationals are already investing in innings eaters, so why not bring back the man who helped build the franchise's legacy? A one-year deal would allow Scherzer to potentially finish his career in the jersey that feels like home, while providing the young roster with the mentor they truly need.