The Nationals’ shortstop picture is still blurry, and Blake Butera isn’t pretending otherwise.
Asked who would handle the position on Opening Day 2027, the manager stopped short of naming a lock. Instead, he pointed to CJ Abrams and left the door open for spring to sort things out.
“We’re going to see what [ CJ Abrams ] looks like in Spring Training. I think what he’s shown us at second base, he’s been unbelievable over there.
But he’s also been unbelievable at shortstop since we had that conversation, right? So I think that he’s absolutely earned an opportunity to continue to work at that this offseason, and if he plays shortstop the way that he did these last, whatever it is, six weeks or so, that’s a good shortstop.”
Abrams’ case is complicated by the numbers. In August, the Nationals said he would get time at second base, where Toboni believed he had Gold Glove potential. Abrams appeared in 14 games there and posted a Statcast OAA of 0.0, right at league average.
At shortstop, though, the story was much rougher. Abrams finished with a -17.0 OAA, tied for the worst mark in baseball.
Nasim Nunez didn’t separate himself much either, turning in a -5.0 OAA in just 144 chances. Because OAA is cumulative, the total workload matters, and Abrams had 511 chances at shortstop.
On a full-season pace, Nunez’s number would have translated to a -17.7 OAA.
That leaves Washington without a clean bridge option. Nunez had once looked like the short-term answer until Eli Willits was ready, but his play at shortstop didn’t hold up. The other name on the chart is Nationals No. 3 prospect Seaver King, MLB’s No. 51 prospect, who was the primary shortstop at Triple-A Rochester.
The issue got extra attention on Thursday after a post from Punchoutpitch circulated a claim tied to Jon Morosi. The account has a history of twisting context, and the wording in the post sounded like an opinion rather than something Abrams himself said.
“CJ Abrams wants to play shortstop and will only sign an extension with the Nationals if there is “some degree of assurance” given he will play there, per @jonmorosi pic.twitter.com/xkZVuwGlV7”
The message prompted more questions than answers. The reporting notes that Jon Morosi did not respond to a message, and Abrams’ agent, Mike Sanders of Roc Nation Sports, also did not respond to a direct message asking for comment.
For now, the Nationals still hold Abrams’ rights for the 2027 and 2028 seasons, so there’s no immediate pressure to move him. But the bigger question hangs over everything: if that tweet reflects the reality, how much leverage should a player have over where he plays?
A second post from 106.7 The Fan pushed the same idea even more directly:
“CJ Abrams reportedly doesn't want to sign an extension in Washington if the team doesn't view him as a shortstop. The Nationals have already shown their hand here. pic.twitter.com/4K8hJhxA0W”
There’s a real baseball argument here, too. Defense matters.
Abrams’ shortstop work has been a problem. But there isn’t an obvious fallback, and that’s what makes this so tricky.
If Abrams spends the winter sharpening his shortstop play and proves he can handle the position better, the thinking would change fast.
Even if Abrams isn’t the long-term answer, the belief is that Willits is. The problem is timing.
He’s only 18 and won’t turn 19 until next month, so the Nationals have to decide whether it makes sense to rush him. Cooper Pratt reached the majors with the Milwaukee Brewers, but he was 22 and had already logged time in 2023, 2024, 2025, and the first two months of 2026 in the minors before debuting in June.
If Abrams stays at shortstop in the short term, Washington could pursue Luis Arraez for second base on a short-term deal and keep King at Triple-A longer. That path would also leave room for a right-handed first baseman such as Andres Chaparro and/or Yohandy Morales, while opening the door to a left-handed corner outfield bat like Trevor Larnach.
None of that is settled, and the article makes clear plenty of people will disagree with the idea. But the final call belongs to Paul Toboni, the president of baseball operations.
Until then, the message is simple: don’t panic. This still has time to get sorted out.
A possible lineup against right-handed pitching was also laid out with James Wood at DH, Luis Arraez at second, Abrams at short, Chaparro at first, Larnach in left, Daylen Lile in right, Keibert Ruiz behind the plate, Jorbit Vivas at third, and Jacob Young in center.
In Other News...
Nationals Have Three Intriguing Arms Fighting For 2027 Roles
The Nationals spent 2026 getting a better look at three arms who could matter a lot more a year from now, and each one arrived there in a different way. Will Dion handled a multi-inning relief role and showed the kind of performance metrics that make a club take notice, Josiah Gray made his late-season return from injury out of the bullpen, and Ribalta put together a breakout year even while dealing with injury setbacks.
What makes the group interesting is how much of the conversation now turns to fit as much as talent. Washington is heading into the offseason with health as a priority and with role adjustments very much on the table, which leaves the 2027 picture unsettled for all three pitchers. Dion, Gray and Ribalta have each put something on tape, but the Nationals still have to decide how best to turn those flashes into something more permanent. [Read more 🡒]
Jacob Youngs Extension Just Raised The Pressure On Dylan Crews
The Nationals locked up Jacob Young with a four-year extension that covers his arbitration years and the first season he would have been eligible for free agency, with a club option for 2031. It is a clear sign the organization values his defense, speed and role in the outfield, and it also gives Washington some cost certainty as it looks ahead to a young core that includes Daylen Lile and James Wood.
For Dylan Crews, though, the timing adds a little more heat. Washington is planning to keep a similar outfield mix in 2027, with Young still in center, which leaves Crews needing to force his way into the picture by making real progress. There are no immediate changes coming, but if he does not take a step forward, the Nationals could eventually have a tougher conversation about his future. [Read more 🡒]
Jacob Young Deal Just Put Dylan Crews In A Tough Spot
Jacob Youngs new four-year deal, with an option for a fifth season, gives the Nationals a clearer picture of one corner of their outfield future. It also adds another layer to a group that already includes Dylan Crews, James Wood and Daylen Lile, turning what once looked like a promising depth chart into something that may soon require a tougher decision.
Crews still has traits the Nationals like, but his uneven performance has left his standing less secure than it once seemed. With Young now locked in and the outfield getting crowded, Washington may eventually have to sort out whether all of these pieces can stay in place, or whether the surplus pushes the front office toward trade discussions down the road. [Read more 🡒]