Phil Steele’s preseason magazine always gets college football people talking, but his 2026 “surprise teams” list doesn’t exactly scream shock value. Alabama, BYU, Oklahoma, USC and Utah all make the cut under his rule that teams have to start outside the Top 10. That’s a strong group, sure, but not the kind of long shot that really jolts the sport.
If you want the teams that would actually turn heads, the better exercise is to find one true surprise from each Power 4 conference. And to qualify here, each team has to be listed at +2000 or longer to win its conference in 2026.
In the Big 12, the pick is Arizona State. Kenny Dillingham is trying to rebuild after the Sun Devils lost 49% of their production from last season and watched QB Sam Leavitt leave for LSU.
Still, there’s enough back to work with at the skill spots and along the defensive line, and Dillingham’s reputation as one of the country’s sharpest offensive minds keeps the ceiling alive. The new quarterback is Cutter Boley, who arrives from Kentucky as a 4 Star Transfer Portal prospect with plenty of upside.
The schedule is rough, though. Arizona State is expected to be a heavy underdog at Texas A&M in Week 2, and after that comes a three-game stretch that could get them to 3-1.
But with only two losses likely to be survivable, the Sun Devils probably need to steal one of their road games against Texas A&M, Texas Tech or BYU - and all three are away from home.
The ACC surprise team is NC State. Dave Doeren is entering his 14th season with the Wolfpack, and his 95-70 record there tells you how steady this program has been.
He’s had four nine-win seasons, and QB CJ Bailey gives NC State a real chance to play above its billing. Bailey is described as one of the ACC’s most dynamic signal callers, but he’ll need help from what has to be a better offensive line.
The defense also has to climb from its 12th-place finish in the league last season. The opening stretch matters a lot: a Week 0 trip to Virginia could set the tone, followed by a road game at Vandy in Week 2 and a home date with Louisville in Week 4.
Win two of those three, and 10 wins starts to look possible later on.
Washington is the Big Ten team to watch. Demond Williams Jr. is the kind of quarterback who can sneak into the dark-horse Heisman conversation, and Jedd Fisch has the coaching background to build an offense that piles up points and yards.
Fisch has worked under Steve Spurrier, Sean McVay and Bill Belichick, and Washington has the ingredients to be dangerous. Williams posted more than 3600 combined yards in 2025, four offensive linemen are back from an offense that ranked 5th in the Big 10 last season, and the defense finished 5th in scoring defense in the league in 2025.
The first 10 games look manageable enough that the Huskies should be 4-0 before heading to USC. They also get Iowa and Penn State at home.
If they survive that run, the final stretch brings Indiana at home and Oregon on the road. Getting to 10 wins won’t be simple, but if Williams takes another leap, Washington can make things very uncomfortable for the rest of the league.
In the SEC, the surprise pick is Florida. The Gators check in 11th nationally in the Blue Chip Ratio at 53%, tied with USC, and the roster is loaded enough to matter.
Jon Sumrall also brought in two veteran coordinators in OC Buster Faulkner and DC Brad White, which gives Florida a proven staff around a talented group. The big swing factor is the quarterback situation, along with how quickly the offensive line comes together.
If those pieces settle, Florida has the kind of roster that can steal a win or two nobody sees coming. The schedule offers some openings too.
Of the five road games, only one comes against a preseason Top 10 team - the Oct. 17 trip to Texas. The other four road opponents, Auburn, Missouri, Kentucky and Florida State, combined for a 23-26 record.
Sumrall has never won fewer than nine games in a season as a head coach, and if he gets Florida to that number in Year 1, he’d have a strong Coach of the Year case.
None of these teams is being picked as a playoff lock. But that’s not the point. These are the programs that could actually create a buzz if things break right - and in July, that’s enough to keep hope alive.
In Other News...
Danny Sprinkle Makes Another Overseas Push With Washington Still Not Finished
Danny Sprinkle is still working the overseas trail as Washington builds toward the 2026-27 season, and this latest stop underscores how international the Huskies roster plan has become. The head coach is in Europe again, with Washington continuing to look for ways to use its remaining scholarship space on a player who can add size, skill and lineup flexibility on the perimeter.
The search has taken Sprinkle to a tournament setting where a promising Slovenian guard is drawing attention while competing for his national team. Washington already has several international pieces either committed or in place, so the next move matters not just for depth but for how the roster takes shape around that final opening. [Read more 🡒]