Jonathan Allens Return Could Reopen A Painful Commanders Debate

Jonathan Allen's upcoming clash with his former team could be a stark reminder of the Washington Commanders' questionable roster decisions.

Jonathan Allen is coming back to Washington on Monday night, and the Commanders may be about to get a reminder they didn’t want.

The Bengals arrive with plenty of firepower. Joe Burrow is the leading NFL MVP candidate, and Cincinnati’s receiver duo of Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins is the best in the league. But the spotlight will also land on a familiar face in the middle of the Bengals’ defensive front: Allen, who spent eight productive seasons in Washington and is having a strong year of his own.

Allen grew up in Ashburn, Virginia, attended Stone Bridge High School and was drafted by Washington in the first round of the 2017 NFL Draft. Over eight seasons with the franchise, he made two Pro Bowls, piled up 42 sacks and 60 tackles for loss, and became one of the team’s most reliable presences.

From 2018 through 2023, he played at least 15 games in each season. He was steady, durable and outspoken in all the right ways, a leader on the field and in the locker room.

Then came the end. After Allen missed most of Washington’s magical 2024 season with a torn pectoral, the team moved on.

That decision looks shaky now. Allen has kept playing at a high level, and the move to let him go - especially with general manager Adam Peters’ overpay for defensive lineman Javon Kinlaw as the consolation - has the feel of a mistake.

Cincinnati has benefited from the change. For years, the Bengals were held back by two glaring issues: a bad offensive line and a defense that couldn’t keep up. Now both units have improved in 2026, and Allen has been part of that turnaround.

Working alongside Dexter Lawrence II, Allen has helped revive the Bengals’ pass rush. The 10-year veteran already has four sacks this season, along with a forced fumble, and he’s brought the kind of presence that makes a defense feel different.

He always seemed like the kind of player Washington would keep forever, or at least until the tank was empty. In a lot of ways, he was the defensive version of Terry McLaurin. His partnership with Daron Payne gave Washington an interior line duo with real chemistry, a connection that started back at Alabama.

If one of the two was going to be the odd man out, Payne would have been the more obvious choice. But the timing of the contracts, along with Peters’ plan for the future, pushed Allen toward a new opportunity.

He has made the most of it, even if his lone season with the Minnesota Vikings didn’t go as well.

Now he gets a prime-time chance to show Washington exactly what it let walk out the door. And the Commanders better hope he doesn’t make them regret it.

In Other News...

Commanders Dream Receiver Target Is Back In Play For Jayden Daniels

Brandon Aiyuk is back in the conversation for Washington after a period of strained relations with Jayden Daniels, a split that grew out of social media posts and seemed to cool the idea of the two linking up. Now the two have reconciled, and Aiyuks name is once again attached to a Commanders offense that could use another dynamic target for Daniels as the season moves deeper into November.

Aiyuk is currently on a two-week NFL exemption while he works through financial issues with San Francisco, and he has also shown interest in joining Washington. The 49ers have until November 23 to decide on his status, leaving the Commanders waiting on a situation that still has plenty of moving parts before anything becomes official. [Read more 🡒]

Commanders Suddenly Have One Brandon Aiyuk Question Fans Cannot Ignore

Brandon Aiyuks name has drifted back into the Commanders conversation for reasons that go beyond a simple social media dustup. After an earlier dispute with Jayden Daniels, the two have reconciled, and now Aiyuk is back in the spotlight while he works through contract issues with the San Francisco 49ers on a two-week NFL exemption. For Washington, that alone is enough to get attention, because any player of Aiyuks caliber naturally invites questions about fit, timing and whether the door is actually opening.

The speculation only gets louder because the 49ers are expected to release him soon, which has made Washington a logical team for fans to watch. Still, nothing official has been reported, and that is where the intrigue sits for the Commanders: a potential addition with obvious appeal, but no clear answer yet on whether the next step is real interest or just another rumor attached to a high-profile name. [Read more 🡒]

Commanders Suddenly Have A Real Rookie QB Decision To Watch

By midseason, the Commanders have already leaned on much of their 2026 draft class in regular-season action, and that includes a quarterback room that has been forced to adapt on the fly. Athan Kaliakmanis, who entered as a third-string pick, got his chance because of injuries ahead of him and wound up giving Washington a useful early look at what it might have in a young passer.

Kaliakmanis showed enough promising traits to make the developmental path worth watching, even with the expected growing pains that come with rookie snaps. For Washington, the bigger question now is how much this stretch accelerates his growth and whether it eventually puts him in position to settle in as a backup down the line. [Read more 🡒]