Let’s rewind to the 2025 NFL Draft, where the Washington Commanders found themselves in a familiar conundrum at pick No. 29.
The pressing need? A dynamic pass rusher.
It was a hot topic, with everyone wondering if a top-tier talent might slip through the cracks to land in Washington's lap. Analysts speculated on whether Jalon Walker from Georgia or Shemar Stewart from Texas A&M might fall due to questions about their fit and college performance, respectively.
Then there was James Pearce Jr. from Tennessee, a standout pass rusher with undeniable talent but some off-field concerns. The buzz was palpable-if Pearce could somehow be available at 29, it would be a game-changer for the Commanders' defense.
Draft night unfolded with Walker going at 15 and Stewart at 17. As the picks rolled by, Pearce remained on the board, tantalizingly close.
By pick 25, the Falcons made their move, trading up with the Rams to snag Pearce at No. 26, giving up their 2026 first-round pick in the process. It was a bold move, betting on Pearce's potential to transform their pass rush.
Meanwhile, the Commanders took a different route at No. 29, opting for Oregon's OT Josh Conerly. Though he faced challenges adapting to NFL pass rushers initially, Conerly’s second half of the season showed promise. Commanders GM Adam Peters’ decision is looking increasingly wise.
Pearce’s draft slide was attributed to a series of red flags, including past legal issues. While one misdemeanor might not deter a team, the accumulation was enough to spook several GMs. Despite the concerns, Pearce delivered on the field with 10.5 sacks, 16 QB hits, and notable turnovers, marking the best rookie pass-rushing performance since Micah Parsons in 2021.
However, recent allegations have clouded Pearce's future. Reports surfaced of an altercation with WNBA player Rickea Jackson, leading to a police chase and charges of aggravated battery, stalking, and eluding police. It’s a stark reminder of the gamble the Falcons took, weighing talent against potential off-field issues.
The Commanders, on the other hand, may have found a reliable asset in Conerly. The age-old adage rings true: the best ability is availability. While Washington missed out on Pearce’s explosive talent, they might have secured a cornerstone for their offensive line, emphasizing stability over volatility.