Eagles Fans Completely Split On Controversial OC Hire

The Eagles are betting on potential over experience with their surprising choice for offensive coordinator.

The Philadelphia Eagles didn’t waste time reshaping their offensive identity. After a two-week search, they’ve tapped into the Green Bay pipeline, hiring Packers quarterbacks coach Sean Mannion as their new offensive coordinator.

It’s a bold move - and one that says a lot about where head coach Nick Sirianni wants to take this offense.

A Fresh Voice in Philly

Mannion, just 33 years old, steps into the role after Kevin Patullo was let go following a disappointing season as OC. While Mannion may not bring decades of coaching experience or a play-calling résumé, what he does bring is a fresh perspective and a recent, hands-on role in developing young quarterbacks - something the Eagles clearly value.

Over the past two seasons, Mannion worked closely with Jordan Love in Green Bay. Love’s growth in 2024 was one of the league’s more underappreciated storylines, and Mannion played a key role in helping him take that next step.

He also helped guide Malik Willis, who stepped in admirably when Love was unavailable. That kind of quarterback development doesn’t go unnoticed - especially by a team like Philadelphia that’s looking to unlock more consistency and explosiveness from its own signal-caller.

The Experience Question

Let’s be clear: Mannion’s coaching resume is short. Just two years on the sidelines and zero play-calling experience.

That’s the biggest question mark here. But the Eagles aren’t just betting on a resume - they’re betting on relationships, football IQ, and potential.

Mannion’s playing career gave him a front-row seat to some of the NFL’s brightest offensive minds. He played under Sean McVay with the Rams and Kevin O’Connell with the Vikings - two coaches known for their creativity and QB-friendly systems.

Then he jumped into coaching under Matt LaFleur in Green Bay, another offensive architect with a strong track record. That’s a trio of mentors any young coach would be lucky to learn from.

The Hiring Process

Mannion wasn’t the only name in the mix. The Eagles reportedly brought in multiple candidates for second interviews, including Colts offensive coordinator Jim Bob Cooter, Buccaneers OC Josh Grizzard, and Texans quarterbacks coach Jerrod Johnson. All three brought more experience to the table, but the Eagles ultimately leaned into potential over pedigree.

That decision speaks volumes about the kind of offense Sirianni wants to build - one that’s innovative, adaptable, and quarterback-centric. With Mannion’s recent experience developing young passers and his exposure to some of the league’s most forward-thinking schemes, he fits that mold.

What’s Next for the Eagles’ Offense?

This hire isn’t about continuity - it’s about evolution. The Eagles know they need to get more out of their offense, especially after a season that fell short of expectations. Mannion’s challenge will be to bring fresh concepts to the table while helping elevate the play of the quarterback and surrounding cast.

There will be growing pains - that’s almost a given with a first-time coordinator. But if Mannion can translate what he’s learned from McVay, O’Connell, and LaFleur into a cohesive game plan in Philly, the payoff could be big.

For now, the Eagles are betting on upside. And in today’s NFL, sometimes that’s exactly the kind of swing you need to take.