Commanders Rookies Are Forcing Some Big Trust Decisions

With rookies stepping up in pivotal roles, see who has earned the Washington Commanders' confidence as they gear up for their next challenge against the Cincinnati Bengals.

Three games after the last rookie update, the Washington Commanders’ first-year class is starting to sort itself out. Washington has gone 2-1 since the bye, and the rookies are no longer all living in the same tier.

Some are locking down real roles. Others are still waiting for their next opening.

At the top, Sonny Styles isn’t giving anyone much of a path to pass him. The rookie linebacker has piled up 80 tackles in nine games, and 13 of them came in each of Washington’s last two outings against the Rams and Giants.

He has hit 13 tackles in four of his last five games, with 34 coming over the three games since the previous rankings. Styles has also added five tackles for loss, a sack, an interception, a forced fumble, and four passes defensed.

The production has not lined up perfectly with the Pro Football Focus grades. His overall mark has fallen from 68.9 to 66.2, which puts him 33rd among 82 qualifying linebackers.

But the tape still shows plenty more than a tackle collector. Against New York, he read the situation on a late third-and-three, adjusted to what he thought was coming, and dropped J.J.

McCarthy for a two-yard loss. That stop helped set up one more chance for Jayden Daniels, who finished the job with the game-winning touchdown.

For a rookie who has already logged 567 defensive snaps, that kind of play is why he stays in the No. 1 spot.

Antonio Williams is still hanging right behind him, even if his case is getting a little more layered. He has 28 catches for 326 yards, an 11.6-yard average, and two touchdowns through nine games. One of those scores was the 31-yard grab against the Giants that put Washington up 17-14 in the third quarter.

Since the bye, Williams has added 10 receptions for 121 yards and a touchdown. The bigger story is how much Washington is using him.

He played 50 of 60 offensive snaps against Philadelphia, 52 of 62 against the Rams, and 59 of 69 against the Giants. That’s 161 snaps over three games, more than any other Washington receiver in that span.

His PFF overall grade has dipped from 74.0 to 70.3, but the workload keeps growing. What hasn’t grown is the target count.

He was targeted only twice against New York despite leading the receivers in snaps, a point Dan Quinn addressed this week. With Terry McLaurin out for the season, Washington needs Williams involved more often, especially on early downs.

The next step is not getting him on the field. It’s getting him the ball.

Drew Stevens has also steadied himself after an uneven start. The early extra-point issues haven’t been much of a storyline lately.

Since the bye, he has made seven of eight field goals and all five extra points. For the season, he is 17-for-20 on field goals and 15-for-18 on extra points.

His best outing came against Philadelphia, when he drilled four field goals and became the first Washington rookie to do that since James Tuthill in 2002. He then made both tries against the Rams and his lone attempt against the Giants.

PFF still has him at a 59.0 field-goal grade, but the improvement since the first two games is obvious. The rookie who already set two franchise kicking records earlier this season is looking far more dependable now.

Joshua Josephs moves up a spot, though not because the pass-rush breakout has arrived. His snap count is still modest: 14 defensive snaps against Philadelphia, 18 against the Rams, and 10 against the Giants.

He has played 128 defensive snaps overall and still hasn’t recorded a sack. His PFF overall grade has climbed from 44.6 to 51.9, and while the pressure production has not shown up, he has at least held onto a place in the rotation.

That is enough to edge him ahead of Matt Gulbin.

Gulbin’s latest chance did not go the way Washington wanted. When Lucas Patrick suffered a concussion against the Rams, Gulbin stepped in and played 35 offensive snaps at center.

PFF charged him with a sack allowed, a quarterback hit, and a hurry on 28 pass-blocking snaps. His season grade has fallen from 63.2 to 45.3, including a 27.2 mark in pass protection.

What happened four days later against New York mattered just as much. With Patrick still out, Washington went with Nick Allegretti at center instead of Gulbin.

Allegretti played all 69 offensive snaps there, and the line gave up just one sack in the win. The case for keeping Allegretti involved at center has already been made, and now that Patrick has cleared concussion protocol, Gulbin could slide even further down the depth chart.

There’s not much new with Athan Kaliakmanis. He has not played an offensive snap since replacing Marcus Mariota against Indianapolis in Week 4.

That remains his only regular-season action, a 15-of-33 outing for 186 yards, a touchdown, and an interception. With Jayden Daniels starting and Mariota back in the primary backup role, Kaliakmanis is back in developmental mode.

Tanoa Togiai is in a similar holding pattern. He remains on the active roster but has yet to play an offensive snap this season. He was inactive again against Philadelphia and New York, so there’s still nothing new to evaluate there.

Washington gets Cincinnati on Monday night, which gives this rookie class another chance to shift the board. With eight games left, there’s still plenty of time for these rankings to change.

In Other News...

Commanders Are Turning Bengals Night Into A Full Stadium Spectacle

Ahead of Monday Night Football against the Bengals, the Commanders are leaning further into their spear-themed identity with a limited-edition stadium collectible called the Beer Spear, created in partnership with Bud Light. The 16-ounce item will be available at select locations inside the stadium for the Nov. 23 game, with one per customer while supplies last, adding another layer to a branding push that has already shown up in alternate uniforms and a pregame ritual.

For Washington, it is another sign that the organization wants the home experience to feel bigger than a single game on the schedule. The timing matters too, with a prime-time matchup offering a built-in stage for the teams broader spear campaign, and for fans who show up early, the collectible may become part of the night almost as much as the football itself. [Read more 🡒]

Sam Hartmans Bachelor Turn Just Sparked A Harsh NFL Reality Check

Sam Hartmans latest headline has nothing to do with a depth-chart battle or a practice rep. The quarterback associated with the Commanders was announced as the star of ABCs The Bachelor for its 30th season, a move that instantly pushed him from football back pages into the reality-TV spotlight. The season is set to premiere in March 2027, giving Hartman a very different kind of stage while he remains tied to Washington on the practice squad.

The crossover drew a sharp reaction from retired NFL player Rob Gronkowski, who questioned Hartman promoting a dating show during the football season and wondered how it would look if he were on an active roster. It is the kind of reaction that follows any player who steps outside the usual NFL lane, especially at a time when teams are expected to be all-in on football and little else. For Hartman, the unusual pairing of quarterback and Bachelor lead has already created a conversation that reaches well beyond the Commanders. [Read more 🡒]

Commanders Get Bulletin Board Fuel For Bengals Test

The Commanders head into Monday night with a familiar opponent and a fresh dose of motivation. Washington already beat Cincinnati 38-33 in Week 3 of the 2024 season, and this time the Bengals arrive at 7-2 with a five-game winning streak, carrying the kind of momentum that has made them the clear pick in most preseason-style breakdowns of the matchup.

Washingtons record sits at 3-5-1, but the recent uptick in play gives this game a different feel than the numbers suggest. The Bengals are favored and analysts are leaning heavily their way, which only adds to the sense that the Commanders have a chance to turn outside doubt into fuel when the lights come on Monday night. [Read more 🡒]