It seemed almost inevitable that the Miami Dolphins would part ways with All-Pro wide receiver Tyreek Hill this offseason. Once that decision was cemented, it didn't take long for the rumor mill to link Hill with the Washington Commanders as a potential new home.
However, for Commanders' general manager Adam Peters, steering clear of this move might be the wiser path as he looks to revamp the roster swiftly.
Hill remains an electrifying playmaker, still operating at an elite level. The Dolphins, entering a new chapter, are shedding experienced players who no longer fit their vision for the future. Despite this, Hill is sure to attract interest, and one NFL analyst even suggested the Commanders could be in the mix.
Maurice Moton from Bleacher Report identified the Commanders as a possible destination for Hill. He suggested that Hill could be a perfect complement to Terry McLaurin, especially with Deebo Samuel Sr. set to hit free agency. Moton also noted that Hill's presence could aid quarterback Jayden Daniels in crafting a comeback season.
"Although [Tyreek] Hill is in the latter stages of his career, he could be a high-end No. 2 option behind Terry McLaurin, who's set to be the focal point of new offensive coordinator David Blough's offense. Following an injury-riddled down year, quarterback Jayden Daniels could post gaudy passing numbers in a rebound season with a McLaurin-Hill tandem on the perimeter."
It's a tempting proposition, but there are significant concerns that Peters must consider.
Hill is recovering from a serious knee injury, and his timeline for return is uncertain. If he's not available until the latter half of 2026, that's a deal-breaker for a team needing immediate help. The Commanders aren't just one player away from becoming Super Bowl contenders.
Additionally, Hill is nearing 32 years old. Washington's strategy of signing aging veterans with limited longevity didn't yield results in 2025, and repeating that approach now seems unwise. This is aside from the potential cost of acquiring Hill.
The Commanders should focus on younger, more durable talent. Hill's history of being a locker room distraction when things go awry adds another layer of complexity. Ultimately, the decision seems clear-cut for Washington.