The Washington Commanders are entering a pivotal offseason, with roster construction at the forefront of their agenda. Among the potential targets is Brandon Aiyuk, a name that sparks both interest and caution.
Aiyuk, a second-team All-Pro in 2023, shares a notable connection with Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels. Their camaraderie dates back to their days at Arizona State University in 2019, and they remain close friends. However, friendship alone can't dictate roster decisions, and Commanders' decision-makers must weigh Aiyuk’s potential impact carefully.
Kevin Sheehan of The Team 980 voices a common sentiment about Aiyuk: proceed with caution. Aiyuk missed the entire 2025 season and only appeared in seven games in 2024 due to injury concerns. Sheehan acknowledges the allure of Aiyuk's 2023 form but warns against assuming that level of play will return without reservations.
The buzz around Aiyuk involves a potential trade, as his contract with the San Francisco 49ers extends through 2028. Yet, speculation also hints that he might be released, turning him into a free agent.
This development could be a double-edged sword for Washington. While acquiring him as a free agent might be financially appealing, the circumstances surrounding his relationship with the 49ers raise red flags about his fit in Washington.
Despite these concerns, Sheehan suggests that if Aiyuk becomes available at the right price, he could be worth the gamble, especially considering his impressive 1,300-yard season just a few years ago. The Commanders must keep the door slightly ajar, assessing the risk versus reward carefully, and not let the past camaraderie between Daniels and Aiyuk cloud their judgment.
In essence, while Aiyuk's potential addition could bolster the Commanders' offense, the team must tread carefully, ensuring any move aligns with their long-term vision and stability.