Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely gave the Giants a day for the record books on Sunday, but New York still walked away from its 27-27 tie with Washington feeling like there was more on the table.
The two Giants pass-catchers became just the second wide receiver-tight end pair in NFL history to each post at least 11 catches, 90 receiving yards and one touchdown in the same game. The only other duo to do it was Minnesota’s Justin Jefferson and T.J.
Hockenson on Dec. 24, 2022.
Likely led the way with a career day. He hauled in 11 of 13 targets for 94 yards and two touchdowns, turning in his best statistical showing of the season in his first year with New York after spending his first four NFL seasons with Baltimore.
Nabers matched him catch for catch in volume, finishing with 11 receptions on 20 targets for 121 yards and a touchdown. It was his highest catch total since he grabbed 12 against Dallas as a rookie in 2024, and it also extended his scoring streak to two straight games after opening the season without a touchdown over the first three weeks.
Their production put them in the same statistical class as Jefferson and Hockenson, but the Giants couldn’t convert that kind of firepower into a win.
The overtime period slipped away from New York when running back Cam Skattebo lost a fumble on a drive that had pushed the Giants into better field-goal range. Washington later had a chance of its own, reaching the Giants’ 26-yard line with 55 seconds left, but poor clock management kept the Commanders from lining up a potential game-winning kick before time ran out.
The result leaves the Giants at 3-1-1 as they turn to a Week 6 home matchup with the New Orleans Saints, who are 1-4.
In Other News...
Commanders Let Another Division Win Slip Away In Brutal Finish
The closing minutes of the Giants-Commanders game drew plenty of attention, and not for the kind of football either side wanted. Former Steelers coach and current NBC analyst Mike Tomlin was among those reacting to the finish, which unraveled into a sequence of mistakes that left both teams shaking their heads. On the New York side, Cam Skattebo coughed up a chance at a game-winning field goal, while Washington let its own final opportunity slip away in a tie that felt more like a loss than a result.
Dan Quinn and Jayden Daniels both took responsibility for the Commanders' part of the mess, which is some comfort only in the narrowest sense. The bigger problem is that Washington let a divisional win sit there, then watched it disappear in brutal fashion, the kind of ending that lingers because it was there to be taken and never quite was. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Fans Are Demanding Answers After Another Officiating Flashpoint
Week 5 around the NFL brought another round of officiating chatter, and Washington was right in the middle of it. The Commanders game against the Giants featured multiple disputed calls that had fans on social media venting about the referee crew, while the Jets matchup with the Browns also became part of the broader frustration simmering across the league.
For Commanders fans, the irritation was not hard to understand. A pass interference penalty earlier in the game drew heavy backlash, and a touchdown ruling later in the afternoon only added to the sense that the discussion would linger well beyond the final whistle. With Jets head coach Aaron Glenn also reportedly upset about what unfolded in his teams game, the week left plenty of people asking for explanations and, in some corners, even investigations. [Read more 🡒]
Commanders Report Card Reveals What Really Cost Them A Win In New York
Washingtons Week 5 film review makes the result in New York sting even more, because it shows how much the Commanders did right before the finish came apart. The rushing offense held up, the defensive line did its part and there were stretches where Washington looked firmly in control, which is why the 27-27 tie felt so deflating after the team had built a comfortable cushion late.
The deeper grades, though, point to the areas that keep turning close games into missed chances. Pass protection had issues, the secondary never really settled in and the coaching evaluation centered on game management, the kind of stuff that becomes impossible to ignore when a lead slips away. Washington left New York with a tie on the record, but the report card reads like a reminder that the margin for error is already too thin. [Read more 🡒]