The Washington Commanders head to MetLife Stadium on Thursday night trying to claw back into the NFC East picture, and the opponent waiting for them is the same one that left them with a bitter memory in Week 5: the division-leading New York Giants.
That first meeting had just about everything. Washington built a 14-point cushion in the fourth quarter, then watched it slip away after cornerback Amik Robertson’s interception of Jameis Winston was wiped out by a penalty.
New York made the most of the second chance, scoring on the next play and then finding the end zone again to force overtime. The Giants were on the verge of a game-winning field goal before running back Cam Skattebo fumbled, giving Washington the recovery.
Even then, the Commanders still had a chance to steal it. Jayden Daniels moved them into position for a potential winning kick, but Washington called another play instead of throwing the ball away, Daniels was tackled, and the clock expired.
Since that loss, the Commanders have had late chances against the 49ers and Rams and couldn’t close either one out. They did beat the Eagles, but otherwise the season has been a string of losses.
So what changes in the rematch? To get a better read on the Giants, Commanders Wire spoke with Giants Wire managing editor Dan Benton.
The quarterback spot is the first big swing point. Benton said JJ McCarthy would bring a different look than Winston did in Week 5.
“It will be different than what the Commanders saw in Week 5 against Jameis Winston. Even with McCarthy dinged up, his presence under center allows the Giants to use the entire playbook that was designed for Jaxson Dart.
His mobility opens up the opportunity for RPOs and designed quarterback runs. If a play or protection break down, McCarthy is lso more agile and capable of escaping the pocket and making things happen with his legs or somewhere downfield.
Beyond that, McCarthy boasts impressive arm strength and he’s far more likely to throw into tight coverage than Winston was, meaning more 50-50 balls to Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely.”
The Giants’ run game, though, is not something Benton labeled a true strength. McCarthy helps, but the ground attack has been held back by a shaky interior line.
“McCarthy certainly helps, but I wouldn’t call the Giants’ ground game a strength. That’s what head coach John Harbaugh wanted entering the season, but the interior offensive line has been a mess and their run blocking grades out near the bottom of the league. The return of Cam Skattebo should help because of his ability to gain yards after contact, break tackles, and fall forward, but as a whole, New York averages 3.9 yards per carry, which is in the bottom third of the league.”
Beyond Nabers and Isaiah Likely, Benton pointed to a few more names Washington has to account for. Rookie Malachi Fields has emerged as a useful piece, Darnell Mooney is settling in after early drop issues, and Jalin Hyatt remains a deep threat.
“Rookie Malachi Fields has been a pleasant surprise and getting better each week. He’s a very unique athlete, who provides an outlet when Nabers and Likely are covered and McCarthy is going through his progressions.
He’s also a tall 50-50 guy who can win in the red zone/endzone, and he’s found a niche on third down. There’s also Darnell Mooney, who is overcoming early-season drop problems and factoring more and more into the offense.
Also, keep an eye out for Jalin Hyatt on a deep ball or two.”
On defense, Benton said the Giants’ vulnerability still shows up against the run, even if that area has improved lately. He singled out D.J.
Reader as a standout and Shelby Harris as the weak link. The bigger story, though, is the secondary.
“The weakness remains their run defense even though it has improved in recent weeks. D.J.
Reader is a stud, but Shelby Harris has been underwhelming and a liability at times. But that’s about it when it comes to weaknesses on defense.
Their biggest strength is coverage, where cornerbacks Deonte Banks and Greg Newsome are playing like a pair of All-Pros, especially in man coverage. That allows Dennard Wilson to use the blitz to create pressure on opposing quarterbacks, which is effective even if the team isn’t recording sacks.
Disrupts the timing and get the quarterback off his mark and good things happen.”
As for a prediction, Benton sees a tight one, even while leaning toward New York.
“John Harbaugh has made it crystal clear how significant this game is for the Giants. There’s no way the players don’t recognize that, and they will be looking to wipe away their Week 5 blemish.
However, the daunting task of stopping Jayden Daniels remains at the forefront, and how they handle him on the ground will likely determine the outcome. I’m picking the Giants this week, but I am not 100 percent confident in that prediction.
This is really a 50-50 game, as are most NFC East contests. Giants 24, Commanders 20.”
In Other News...
Dan Quinn Finally Addressed A Costly Commanders Problem
Late-game trouble has become a familiar and frustrating theme around the Commanders, and Dan Quinn finally acknowledged it after the recent loss to the Rams. With two first-year coordinators in David Blough on offense and Daronte Jones on defense, Quinn suggested there are bound to be some growing pains as the staff and roster continue to sort out how to finish games cleanly.
The ending against Los Angeles only sharpened the issue, with Jayden Daniels involved in a controversial play call that ended in a fumble and a loss. Daniels and Quinn both declined to go into much detail afterward, leaving the Commanders with the same lingering question they have been trying to answer all season: how to avoid letting games slip away in the final moments. [Read more 🡒]
Jayden Daniels Faces A Week 10 Test The Giants Just Complicated
Jayden Daniels is heading into another one of those early-season checkpoints that can say a lot about where a young quarterback and his team really stand. The Commanders have already seen what Daniels can do at the helm after his electric rookie year, when he pushed Washington all the way to the NFC championship game and earned Offensive Rookie of the Year honors. Now he is working through a new offensive coordinator and a different system, which makes every week feel a little more revealing than the last.
Week 10 adds another layer because it brings Daniels back across from J.J. McCarthy, another member of the 2024 rookie quarterback class who has taken a far different path. McCarthy missed his rookie season because of injury, then wound up with the Giants after losing the starting job in Minnesota, and he is now settling in as New York's starter following a midseason trade. Their second meeting as starters has the feel of a familiar matchup with a very different backdrop, and for Washington, the Giants have just made the test a little more complicated. [Read more 🡒]
Commanders Face One Week 10 Decision That Could Swing Fantasy Lineups
The Week 10 matchup with the Giants has turned into a tricky fantasy puzzle for anyone building a DraftKings showdown lineup around Washington. Jayden Daniels remains the obvious centerpiece after his recent production and dual-threat upside, while the rest of the Commanders offense has to be sorted through a matchup that also puts New York playmakers like Malik Nabers on the radar. Tight ends Isaiah Likely and Chig Okonkwo, along with kickers Dominic Zvada and Drew Stevens, round out the pool of names that could matter in a one-game format where every touch and every field goal attempt can swing the slate.
Washingtons backfield adds another layer of uncertainty for fantasy managers trying to read the game script. The Commanders have settled into a two-man running back committee, which makes it harder to project volume and forces a closer look at how touches will be divided in a matchup that could stay tight. For a team still trying to balance efficiency with opportunity, that split could be the difference between a useful lineup play and a frustrating fade. [Read more 🡒]