While Beau Pribula has grabbed plenty of the spotlight in Virginia’s fall camp, Eli Holstein is the quarterback who keeps reminding you why he was such a big-time recruit in the first place.
Holstein arrives in Charlottesville with a résumé that looks more like a starter’s than a backup’s. He was a consensus high four-star prospect, and some services had him as a five-star.
He already has 14 college starts. He was a semifinalist for the 2024 Shaun Alexander Freshman of the Year Award, earned ACC Rookie of the Week honors five times and even matched some of Dan Marino’s college records.
Nick Saban once called Holstein “a fine young quarterback,” and the answer for Pitt.
That’s why the idea of Holstein as Virginia’s No. 2 feels a little misleading. He may be listed behind Pribula, but the Cavaliers know they’re not dealing with a typical backup.
Pribula brings the dual-threat element; Holstein is the pocket passer. Still, reducing Holstein to a rhythm thrower misses what he can do.
He looks bigger than his listed 6-foot-4 frame, he can pull the ball down and run when defenses lose track of him, and he has enough arm talent to attack deep down the field.
On tape, the comparison that jumps out is Kenny Pickett. Like the former Pitt quarterback, Holstein has size, movement and the ability to hurt a defense in more than one way. That showed up in a big way during his historic 2024 redshirt freshman season.
Holstein threw for 2,228 yards and 17 touchdowns, both Panthers freshman records, and added 328 rushing yards and three scores. He averaged four yards per carry and finished third nationally among all freshmen in passing yards per game and total offense per game. He also won his first seven starts, making him the first Pitt quarterback to do that since Dan Marino.
Then came 2025, and the season turned hard. Pitt opened by rolling over Duquesne and Central Michigan, but once the schedule filled with Power Four opponents, the results changed fast.
After a blowout win over Syracuse Oct. 24, 2024, Pitt did not beat an ACC opponent until Oct.
4, 2025.
The low point came in the Backyard Brawl at West Virginia, where Holstein threw a costly interception in a one-score loss. A week later against Louisville, he threw two interceptions in the second half.
Pat Narduzzi had seen enough and went to veteran backup Cole Gonzalez, who also threw an interception. After that, Narduzzi turned to true freshman Mason Heintschel, and Heintschel remains the starter.
Holstein entered the transfer portal after the 2025 season with two years of eligibility left. He was the first quarterback to commit to Virginia this offseason, with Pribula following one day later.
So even if Holstein is QB2 right now, that doesn’t mean he’s just waiting around for a chance. There’s a real path for him to matter, both immediately and down the line.
If he stays, Holstein would be the favorite to start in 2027. Before that happens, though, he has some adapting to do.
Virginia’s pro-style offense is a different world from Pitt’s up-tempo spread. There are some shared elements, especially with RPOs and wheel routes, but the play-action concepts are run in a completely different way.
The Cavaliers also lean on the run more heavily than Pitt did with Holstein. Virginia has built its offense around an elite offensive line and an absurdly deep running back room, which should help any quarterback. Even so, Holstein is stepping into a system that asks for something different.
Turnovers are another major piece of the puzzle. Tony Elliott is relentless about winning the turnover margin, and a quarterback who gives the ball away too often won’t stay on the field for long.
Maybe that’s where the upside lives for Holstein: behind an elite offensive line, with a run game that can keep things on schedule, he could become a steadier version of himself - one who punishes defensive backs and holds up against ACC competition.
In Other News...
Virginia Is Finally Getting ACC Respect But Fans Still Want More
Virginia football is heading into 2026 with a little more buzz than it had a year ago. The ACC preseason poll pegged the Cavaliers to finish sixth, a major jump from 14th last season, and four Virginia players landed on the All-ACC Preseason Football Team, the most in program history. For a program that has spent plenty of time trying to climb out of the conference cellar, it is at least a sign that the league is taking the Cavaliers more seriously.
The bigger test comes quickly, with NC State set to visit Scott Stadium on Aug. 29 to open the season. Preseason respect is nice, but Virginia fans have seen enough cautious optimism to know the real answer comes once the games count, and the schedule opens with a chance to see whether this upgraded outlook is built to last. [Read more 🡒]
Virginia Could Suddenly Get A Huge Boost From One Ruling
A potentially major eligibility wrinkle is hanging over college sports, and Virginia could be one of the programs that feels it most if it ever becomes official. The proposed Class of 2022 ruling would give athletes who began competing in the 2022-23 academic year and have used up four seasons of eligibility a chance to play again in 2026-27, opening the door for a handful of former Cavaliers across multiple sports to potentially re-enter the picture.
For Virginia, the appeal is obvious: a rule change like this could create unexpected roster help without the usual transfer portal hunt or recruiting cycle. But the situation is still unresolved, with litigation still working its way through the system and no official confirmation yet, so any talk of a reunion remains more concept than certainty for now. [Read more 🡒]
Two Virginia Transfers Are Turning Up The Heat On Key Position Battles
Preseason practices have given Virginia a closer look at two transfers who could end up shaping the offense before the first snap is ever taken. Offensive coordinator Des Kitchings singled out running back Jekail Middlebrook and receiver Jacquon Gibson as key contributors, and head coach Tony Elliott has also been pleased with Middlebrooks steady play and versatility as the Cavaliers sort through some important August depth chart questions.
Middlebrooks value is easy to see because he can help in more than one way, which is exactly the sort of trait that can tilt a camp battle. Gibson has brought similar energy to the receiver room, where Virginia is still sorting out roles and looking for the right fit in the slot, so both players have made this one of the more interesting position stories around the program as practice rolls on. [Read more 🡒]