What would the Vegas Golden Knights look like without Jack Eichel?
That question hangs over everything the center has done in Vegas, because his arrival changed the shape of the roster and the ceiling of the team. In the version of the story where Eichel never leaves the Buffalo Sabres, the Golden Knights don’t have the 2023 Stanley Cup, and they’re still hunting for the kind of top-line center he became for them.
Eichel came to Vegas in the 2021-22 season after Terry Pegula did not want to perform the neck surgery Eichel requested. From there, the alternate paths start piling up fast.
In one universe, maybe Eichel ends up in his hometown of Boston. In another, maybe he lands with the New York Rangers, possibly with Pavel Dorofeyev.
But in the real one, he’s in Vegas, and the Knights have a franchise centerpiece.
His playoff numbers don’t tell the whole story. Eichel scored six goals during the 2023 Stanley Cup run, and he had only two goals this postseason, but the impact went well beyond the box score. He made the players around him better, and that showed up in the biggest moments.
Jonathan Marchessault is the clearest example. His career-high 42 goals in 2023-24 came with Eichel feeding him and creating chances on his line.
Marchessault’s Conn Smythe run in the 2023 Stanley Cup playoffs - 13 goals and 12 assists - is part of that same story. Without Eichel, it’s hard to see Marchessault getting that kind of platform, or the deal with the Nashville Predators that followed.
Eichel’s absence would have changed more than Marchessault’s path. Alex Tuch likely would have stayed with the Golden Knights, and Peyton Krebs would have been in the mix too. Tuch would have been a more useful shooting winger for Vegas, while Krebs would have been dead weight.
The ripple effects even reach the current roster picture. Mitch Marner coming to the Golden Knights feels less likely without Eichel already in place, and the same goes for the kind of talent that gets linked to Vegas when Eichel is there. That includes Dylan Larkin, whose name would make more sense if his Olympic buddy were already wearing a Golden Knights sweater.
And then there’s the biggest roster question of all: who fills the 1C spot? Without Eichel, Vegas would still be searching. Connor McDavid and now Macklin Celebrini would come up in the conversation, but whether Kelly McCrimmon would be willing to spend that much of his cap space on a replacement is another matter entirely.
In Other News...
Golden Knights Fans Will Argue These 4 Franchise Changing Moves
The Golden Knights have never been shy about making a splash, and the franchises rise has been built on a few moves that changed the shape of the roster almost overnight. From the expansion draft that gave Vegas its first true face in net to the high-end additions that followed, the organization has repeatedly bet on bold swings, and more often than not, those bets have pushed the team from intriguing newcomer to perennial contender.
That is why the debate around the most franchise-altering move still has plenty of life in it. Some fans will point to the stability and leadership that came with Alex Pietrangelo, others to the star power of Marc-Andre Fleury or the impact of the Jack Eichel trade, while the newest wave of discussion centers on Mitch Marner and what his arrival could mean for the next chapter. In a market that has come to expect big moves, the real argument is not whether Vegas has changed itself, but which decision mattered most in turning the Golden Knights into what they are now. [Read more 🡒]
Golden Knights Just Reached The Final But Doubts Are Already Rising
Bleacher Reports latest NHL Power Rankings still have the Golden Knights near the top after their run to the Stanley Cup Final in 2025-26, but the writeup also nudged them into a different conversation. Vegas landed fourth in the rankings, a reminder that even a contender with recent hardware can draw skepticism once the calendar turns and the roster starts to show its age.
The concerns are familiar ones for a team that has built its identity on staying aggressive and adapting quickly. Analysts pointed to the Knights as one of the leagues older groups and suggested the front office may not be done tinkering, especially if it wants to keep pace with the top of the West. The organization has usually answered coaching changes with a strong response, and the bigger question now is whether it can do it again while navigating a roster that may still have more moving parts ahead. [Read more 🡒]