Vanderbilt's Real Offensive Problem Is Getting Harder To Ignore

Despite growing pains under pressure, freshman quarterback Jared Curtis isn't the root of Vanderbilt's struggles against top-tier opposition.

Vanderbilt’s loss to No. 3 Alabama offered a pretty clear snapshot of where the offense stands right now, and Jared Curtis was not the main thing dragging it down.

The five-star freshman quarterback had a chance late to keep the Commodores alive. On third down with six yards to go and Vanderbilt needing two touchdowns in the final minutes to force overtime, Curtis dropped back, checked his options and took off for a first down at the Alabama 15-yard line. The run extended the drive and gave Vanderbilt a sliver of hope before the 21-6 loss was sealed.

But that possession never really got off the ground after that. Mitchell Smith’s holding penalty on second down put Vanderbilt behind the chains, and the drive eventually died on a missed fourth-down try. It was the kind of sequence that summed up the day: one positive play followed almost immediately by something that undercut it.

Clark Lea pointed directly to the penalty problem afterward.

“I felt like we made progress in eliminating these and we’ve played cleaner. Today, it really robbed us of a chance to put pressure on Alabama,” Vanderbilt head coach Clark Lea said about the penalty issues in the game.

The numbers tell the same story. Vanderbilt finished with 235 total yards, including 223 through the air and just 12 on the ground.

Even if you strip out Curtis’ sacks, the Commodores managed only 32 rushing yards combined from Sedrick Alexander, MK Young and Martel Hight. Add in 11 penalties for 63 yards, and the offense spent most of the afternoon fighting uphill.

That’s why Curtis, for all the missed throws and uneven moments, doesn’t sit near the top of the blame list.

He completed 25 of 40 passes for 223 yards, didn’t throw a touchdown and left a few throws on the field. But he also protected the ball, and that matters. Against Alabama, he went without an interception for the second straight week after earlier conference games had featured more of those growing pains.

Young saw enough to stay encouraged.

“He’s growing and I can’t wait to watch that guy grow. He’s stepping into who he is and I love that even more.

And just him quarterback-wise, I think he’s making plays. You see that even on the third down in the red zone.

He converted that. He had made a couple guys miss,” Young said.

There’s also the larger issue of what Curtis is being asked to do. Vanderbilt’s offense was sloppy and out of sync, and part of that can be tied to a young quarterback still learning the pre-snap details. Still, the bigger problems were obvious: the penalties up front and a run game that never showed up.

When the offense is losing roughly 30 yards to penalties while barely producing anything on the ground, the structure around the quarterback is shaky from the start. Lea has been saying for weeks that the other 10 players on offense need to help Curtis more, especially by improving the run game.

Mississippi State offered a hint of that. Alabama did not.

Instead, Curtis spent much of the day under pressure and scrambling to survive behind him. Lea said he won’t let the rough stretches erase the good moments.

“We’ll need to look at it and say ‘what are the things that we need to do to help him the best we can to put him in good positions to win in those moments?’ And part of that’s going to be the run game,” Lea said.

“But with all the doom and gloom of the day, you still saw moments and flashes of him ripping the ball and plays being made on the perimeter. It’s all there.”

Curtis still has room to grow. That much is obvious. But Saturday was less about a quarterback failing to carry Vanderbilt and more about an offense around him failing to give him much help.

“He’s different and you guys will see that. We’ll continue to grow with him and I’m just super excited to see where he goes,” Young said.

In Other News...

Nick Rinaldi Made Alabama Weekend About More Than Vanderbilt Football

Nick Rinaldi has turned Vanderbilt football weekends into something bigger than the usual game-day routine, using his platform as a linebacker to create a lasting connection with Special Olympics Tennessee. Throughout the season, he has helped bring athletes to Commodores home games, giving them access to practices, team dinners and the kind of behind-the-scenes moments most fans never see.

One of those guests, Reese Wiemeyer, has become part of the fabric around the program, with the Vanderbilt community honoring him during a game after he spent time around the team and around campus. Wiemeyer, who has Cerebral Palsy, has been included in several football-related activities, and Rinaldis effort has made Alabama weekend feel like more than just another SEC date on the schedule. [Read more 🡒]