A small-defenceman trend has quietly taken hold around the Toronto Maple Leafs, and Vinny Borgesi just made it harder to ignore.
At 5-foot-8, Borgesi was arguably Toronto’s best overall player through two games at the prospects challenge over the weekend, a showing that forces a familiar hockey debate back into the spotlight: how much should size really matter when a defender has enough skill, skating and sense to make everything work? Montreal Canadiens blueliner Lane Hutson offers a reminder that small defencemen can absolutely survive at the NHL level, even if Borgesi is nowhere near that comparison yet.
Still, Borgesi’s week was enough to get people talking. The 22-year-old signed a two-year entry-level contract with the organization in March, but he arrived at the prospects challenge with relatively little buzz.
Last season, he had one assist in seven games with the American Hockey League’s Toronto Marlies and did not appear during their Calder Cup championship run. This time around, he looked like someone eager to push for more when the Marlies get back to work.
His skating stood out immediately. Borgesi moved laterally with ease, stayed active, and kept plays alive at the offensive blue line.
He showed quick processing with the puck, found his wingers efficiently and helped create chances from the point. He also flashed some offense of his own, including a smart goal against the Winnipeg Jets on Sunday when he flew down the wing and finished the rush.
He drew notice from others covering the event, too. Steven Ellis singled out Borgesi among Maple Leafs prospects who looked good at practice, while Nick Richard called him Toronto’s clear standout after the overtime loss to the Ottawa Senators on Saturday.
The obvious question is how far a 5-foot-8 defenceman can really go. That concern doesn’t disappear just because a player skates well in a prospect setting.
The playoffs are a different animal, a place where board battles and net-front scrums can expose every weak spot. But Borgesi has at least shown enough to make the size conversation more complicated than a simple yes-or-no answer.
That same conversation has started to hover over Toronto’s broader defensive picture, especially after the club brought in Nick Blankenburg on a professional tryout. The Maple Leafs have also added Emil Andrae and Darren Raddysh, and the list includes two more undersized blueliners in Andrae, listed at 5-foot-9, and Blankenburg, also listed at 5-foot-9. Raddysh brings more size, but the overall direction is clear: mobility and puck movement are getting a real push under John Chayka’s management group.
There’s a reason for that. Toronto had trouble moving the puck out of its own zone last season, and the new brain trust seems determined to fix it.
A defenceman who can escape pressure, make the first pass and turn defence into offence changes the whole rhythm of a game. Smaller defenders do not necessarily have to win every physical confrontation if they can keep those confrontations from happening in the first place.
Sometimes speed is less about wheels and more about decision-making.
The lingering concern, though, is obvious. Can a blue line built this way hold up against Atlantic Division teams like the Florida Panthers, Tampa Bay Lightning, Buffalo Sabres and Canadiens when the games get heavy?
That is still an open question. One undersized defenceman is one thing.
Too many players with the same profile, all being asked to survive the same grind, is where the danger starts to show up.
That’s what makes training camp so interesting. Chayka does not appear to be assembling a roster of small defenders just for the sake of it.
He is trying to build a faster, more mobile group that can move the puck and defend with intelligence. If those players are good enough, their size won’t be the first thing anyone notices.
If they can’t handle playoff-style pressure, the concern gets much louder.
Borgesi’s weekend performance only sharpens the issue. It would be easy to argue Toronto needs bigger defencemen, and then a 5-foot-8 prospect goes out and looks like one of the best players on the ice. Hockey rarely hands out neat answers, especially when it comes to height and weight.
So the real test for the Maple Leafs is not what their defence looks like on paper. It is whether that group can handle the game when opponents decide to make it miserable.
Chayka seems willing to trust skating, puck movement and hockey intelligence to cover for size. That is a bold bet.
The only question that matters now is whether it still looks smart when April arrives.
In Other News...
Former Canuck Pushes Back On J.T. Miller Blame Narrative
During a recent podcast appearance, former Canuck Nikita Zadorov offered a different version of the J.T. Miller story than the one that has followed Vancouver through much of the public conversation around the team. Zadorov spoke positively about Miller as a teammate, describing him as competitive and team-oriented, and said the reports of a feud with Elias Pettersson had been exaggerated.
Zadorov also made clear he was not around for the later stretch of the Canucks reported locker-room drama, which makes his perspective limited to what he saw firsthand. Even so, his comments added another layer to a narrative that has often been driven by social media and outside noise, which he said tended to blow the situation out of proportion. [Read more 🡒]
Canucks Could Land An Overlooked Difference-Maker Before Opening Night
The waiver wire is about to become one of the Canucks first real roster-building tools for the new season, and Vancouver is planning to be aggressive when it opens on Sept. 17. General manager Ryan Johnson said the club intends to use its top priority position to add players who fit the teams vision and can provide real value, which keeps the door open for a move that could matter before opening night.
It is a path the organization has used before, with waiver claims such as Martin Gelinas, Brian Glynn and Kyle Wellwood turning into notable depth additions in different eras. Whether this years opportunity produces a similar kind of overlooked difference-maker remains to be seen, but the Canucks are clearly treating the market as more than just a roster afterthought. [Read more 🡒]
Bo Horvats Islanders Rise Still Says Plenty About Vancouvers Choice
Brock Boeser has spent much of camp talking about the Canucks effort to put last season behind them and open a cleaner chapter, and his message has been simple enough: progress has to come from the players in the room. He pointed to improvement and leadership as the real drivers of a turnaround, which fits a Vancouver team still trying to settle into a more stable identity after a difficult stretch.
Boeser also took a moment to revisit one of the franchises defining recent decisions, praising former teammate Bo Horvat for the work ethic and professionalism that have helped make him captain of the New York Islanders. It was a reminder that the Canucks 2023 trade of Horvat is still part of the backdrop here, not just as a roster move, but as one of the choices that continues to shape how Vancouver talks about where it is headed. [Read more 🡒]