Jim Rutherford’s run with the Vancouver Canucks ended in a way few would have drawn up, but another chapter of his hockey life just earned a major spotlight.
On Thursday, the Pittsburgh Penguins announced that Rutherford will be part of their 2026 Hall of Fame class. He’ll go in alongside goaltender Marc-Andre Fleury and defenceman Larry Murphy, while Jack McGregor - who helped bring the Penguins to Pittsburgh for their inaugural 1967 season - will also be inducted.
For Rutherford, the honour comes from the organization where he built his strongest legacy. He’s already enshrined in the Hockey Hall of Fame as a builder, and Pittsburgh is the place where his front-office work still carries the most weight.
Rutherford is tied forever to the Penguins’ back-to-back Stanley Cup titles in 2016 and 2017. He inherited a core built around Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang, and Fleury, then went to work. During his seven seasons in Pittsburgh, he made more than 50 trades, putting himself among the league’s most active general managers.
A lot of those moves were all about support pieces, and plenty of them mattered. Patric Hornqvist, Ben Lovejoy, Trevor Daley, Ian Cole, Nick Bonino, Carl Hagelin, Justin Schultz, Ron Hainsey, and Marc Streit all came in as part of the depth that helped turn the Penguins into a repeat champion.
And then there was Phil Kessel, Rutherford’s most recognizable trade. That one worked out, too.
That success is what made his arrival in Vancouver so intriguing. The hope was obvious: maybe Rutherford could bring the same kind of touch to the Canucks.
In 2022, he sounded a lot like a GM convinced a quick reset was possible. “I would like to think with the players we have, that this team can be retooled, and that we can get it to a point that we get more comfortable with it over a two-year period to contend again,” Rutherford said back in February 2022.
For a stretch, it looked like he had read the room correctly.
The Canucks put together one of the best seasons in franchise history in 2023-24, won the Pacific Division, and came within a game of the Western Conference Finals. Rutherford and GM Patrik Allvin made moves that helped fuel that rise, including the trades for Elias Lindholm and Nikita Zadorov. They also bought out Oliver Ekman-Larsson and filled out the roster with useful pieces like Carson Soucy, Ian Cole, Teddy Blueger, and Dakota Joshua.
But Vancouver’s version of Rutherford’s story isn’t going to be defined by that high point.
It’s going to be remembered for what came after: the Canucks crashing to the bottom of the NHL standings only two seasons after owning the league’s sixth-best record. Much of that spiral was beyond his control, but his time there will also be tied to the blunt Quinn Hughes soundbite and the public comments he made about the J.T. Miller/Elias Pettersson feud just days before Miller was moved.
Maybe that view changes over time. Canucks fans wanted a rebuild, and now they have one. If the Ryan Johnson regime eventually gets the club where it wants to go, Rutherford could end up being seen as the man who helped set the table, even if that wasn’t the plan.
For now, though, the Hall of Fame executive gets the kind of honour that fits best: one from the team he actually helped win a championship.
In Other News...
Canucks Face A Real Braeden Cootes Development Dilemma
Braeden Cootes is already at the heart of one of the Canucks more interesting development questions heading into next season. The 2025 first-rounder signed his entry-level deal in July and has only a brief NHL sample to his name, but his work in junior has kept the conversation moving fast. For Vancouver, the issue is less about whether Cootes has long-term upside and more about how quickly the organization should push him after a summer of important contract business.
The Canucks have enough center depth that they do not need to rush him, yet the path becomes less simple when a young player starts looking ready before the team wants to make a permanent commitment. Starting the 2026-27 season in the NHL would give Cootes a chance to learn on the fly, while the AHL could offer a steadier runway if the club decides his game still needs more refinement. However Vancouver handles it, the decision will say plenty about how it views his timeline and how much patience it is willing to exercise. [Read more 🡒]
Canucks Face A Telling Scoring Bet Up Front
The Canucks scoring picture up front has a familiar kind of uncertainty attached to it, with Jake DeBrusk and Drew OConnor sitting on very different goal benchmarks as camp and the season approach. DeBrusk brings the more established track record, along with power-play value that can push a winger toward a big number when the usage is right, while OConnor is coming off a role that suggests a more modest scoring ceiling but still enough opportunity to matter in Vancouvers forward mix.
What makes the comparison more interesting is how much both players paths could be shaped by what happens off the ice as much as on it. DeBrusks place in the lineup and his trade status remain part of the conversation, and OConnors contract situation could make him just as relevant to future roster decisions as to the present one. For a team trying to sort out where the goals will come from, the bet up front is as much about stability as it is about production. [Read more 🡒]
Max Sasson Has A Bigger Canucks Role To Earn Under Malhotra
Max Sasson has finally settled into life as a full-time NHL player after spending the early part of his pro career bouncing between the AHL and the Canucks. At 25, he carved out a regular spot last season and showed why the organization has kept investing in him, bringing speed and the kind of offensive push that can tilt shifts in Vancouvers favor.
The next step is less about proving he belongs and more about proving he can handle more responsibility under the new coaching staff. Sasson still has parts of his game to clean up, especially in areas that can decide whether a player stays in the lineup every night, but the opportunity is there for him to expand his role if he keeps rounding out the details. [Read more 🡒]