The first chapter of Conor Garland’s Blue Jackets tenure has not gone the way Columbus hoped.
After arriving from Vancouver ahead of the 2026 trade deadline with a six-year extension already in place, Garland has opened the 2026-27 season with eight straight games without a point. That follows a stretch last season in which he posted five goals and two assists in 21 games after the trade. For a player who was supposed to bring value and versatility, the early returns have been thin.
To get a better read on what’s going on, I spoke with Mark Scheig of The Hockey Writers, who covers the Blue Jackets daily and is a member of the Professional Hockey Writers Association. His read is that the biggest issue isn’t effort so much as instability.
“There are moments where you can see Garland’s speed and ability to disrupt, but it’s been far too infrequent,” said Scheig. “His role changes game-by-game and sometimes period-by-period.
I think that inconsistency plays a role in this. One moment, he’s in the top-six and on the power play.
The next, he’s playing on the fourth line. You can tell the team is still learning about each other.
That results in mistakes and inconsistency. There’s still a player there, but until the team finds his role, I think we’ll see more of the same.”
That uncertainty has been a theme around Columbus as a whole. The Blue Jackets are 3-5 and sitting last in the Metropolitan Division, and the problems have extended well beyond Garland.
Scheig pointed to special teams as the major culprit, with Columbus dead last in the league on the power play and sitting at 70% on the penalty kill. He also noted the team’s second-period issues have been a factor in the slow start.
“The Blue Jackets have actually been decent in first periods and at 5-on-5. But special teams have killed them,” noted Scheig.
“They are last in the NHL on the power play and have a 70% penalty kill. Couple those issues with their second-period collapses and you start to get a picture of their season.
The story to watch is Bowness’ message. He recently said after the Maple Leafs game that culture is not the problem which is a toned-down message from his earlier comments.
Sense I get is players receive the same messaging in the room before Bowness says the same thing to the media. They know they have to be better.
But calling them out only goes so far. Their next few games will tell us if the message is truly being received.”
Rick Bowness, who had ripped the team’s work ethic in his end-of-season availability last season and said he would bring a culture change if he returned, is back behind the bench. Scheig said the coach’s public tone has softened some lately, even if the message itself hasn’t changed.
Garland’s own usage has been part of the puzzle. After spending much of last season as a top-six player, he’s now being moved around constantly, and that has made it hard for him to settle in. Bowness recently referred to him as “a Swiss Army knife.”
“Garland was mostly a top-six player last season,” added Scheig. “You noticed him because he irritated the opposition.
Now, we’re seeing constant switching of roles. Bowness recently called Garland ‘a Swiss Army knife.’
Bowness likes him as a player, but they haven’t been able to unlock his game to this point. The question to consider is whether the Blue Jackets have the kind of roster that can truly get the most out of him.
So far, the answer is no.”
That’s the concern for Columbus, especially with Garland locked in on a six-year contract that includes a full no-move clause for the first three years before shifting to a 15-team no-trade list in 2029-30.
The talent is still there. Garland has long shown he can drive play as a winger, and what Columbus is seeing now sounds a lot like the version of him that existed in Vancouver before Rick Tocchet arrived and Garland’s role changed for the better. But right now, the fit hasn’t clicked.
The Blue Jackets will get a chance to revisit the story when they visit Vancouver on January 16th.
In Other News...
Canucks Just Added More Fuel To The Elias Pettersson Debate
The Elias Pettersson conversation around Vancouver just got a little louder, and this time it came from outside the market rather than inside it. According to Elliotte Friedman, the Carolina Hurricanes were working through trade possibilities on the same night they landed Mikko Rantanen from Colorado, with Vancouver and Colorado both in the mix as Carolina pushed for each clubs best offer.
For Canucks followers, the eye-opener is less about the deadline mechanics than what it says about Petterssons place in the leagues trade chatter. Carolinas approach under GM Eric Tulsky has been to press hard, compare options and move quickly when the right fit appears, and this report suggests Vancouver was part of that calculus until the Hurricanes settled on another direction. The broader takeaway is simple enough: Pettersson remains a name other teams are willing to explore, even if the details of how close it came are still doing a lot of the work. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Lineup Shift Could Create A New Problem For The Canucks
The Oilers are getting a key piece back in the middle of the ice, and that could matter for the Canucks whether they see Edmonton this week or later on. Ryan Nugent-Hopkins is set to make his season debut Thursday after missing the first nine games with a lower-body injury, and the expectation is that hell step right into the second-line centre role, giving Edmonton a deeper look down the middle.
For Vancouver, the timing adds another wrinkle to an already familiar division puzzle. Coach Mike Babcock has pointed to the lineup shift as a move that leaves Edmonton in a better spot at centre, while also touching on how the group will manage other injured players. The bigger issue for the Canucks is obvious enough: a healthier Oilers lineup can change the matchups in a hurry, and Nugent-Hopkins return is the kind of adjustment that can ripple beyond just one game. [Read more 🡒]
Canucks Shake Up Top Six With Pressure Suddenly Building
The Canucks got a healthier-looking practice group back on the ice as they continued prepping for a busy stretch against the Red Wings and Wild. Vancouver worked through five-on-five drills, and Marco Rossi was back at practice after missing the past two games because of illness, giving Manny Malhotra a little more flexibility as he sorts through his forward combinations and line chemistry.
Victor Mancini also skated with Zeev Buium, a pairing that at least hints at a possible change for Thursdays matchup with Detroit. With the top six still under the microscope and the schedule moving quickly, the Canucks appear to be weighing whether a few lineup tweaks can help settle things before the pressure builds any further. [Read more 🡒]