Utah's Playoff Push Comes With A Huge Devon Dampier Dilemma

With an undefeated record and Heisman-worthy performances, Utah faces the dual challenge of securing a playoff spot while juggling the complexities of contract negotiations in a fast-evolving college football landscape.

No. 2 Utah has spent the season doing the hard part on the field. Now comes the messy part off it.

The Utes are 10-0, coming off a wild 40-39 win at Arizona, and sitting in a place no Utah team has reached since 2008: undefeated with two games left. The crowd in Tucson knew it, too, chanting “undefeated” after the final whistle. Utah still has to get through TCU and West Virginia, but the possibility of finishing perfect is very real.

That’s the football side. The calendar side is where things get complicated.

Morgan Scalley’s team is already deep into a season that has put Utah in the national title mix, and Devon Dampier has pushed himself into the Heisman conversation. Most oddsmakers have him as the third-likeliest player to win the award, and if Utah keeps rolling, a trip to New York for the ceremony is on the table.

Dampier has been central to everything Utah has done. He has thrown for 2,257 yards and 22 touchdowns while rushing for 582 yards and nine scores. If he comes back to college football, he’ll be one of the biggest names in the sport’s offseason market.

And that market is only getting louder.

Mississippi State quarterback Kamario Taylor reportedly signed a $7.5 million deal to return to Starkville, according to On3’s Chris Low and Pete Nakos. That number could climb past $9 million with incentives. It’s the kind of figure that shows just how much money is flowing through college football now - even more than what a number of NFL quarterbacks, including Denver’s Bo Nix, Atlanta’s Michael Penix Jr., and New York Giants’ Jaxson Dart, are set to make in 2027.

For Utah, that reality lands right in the middle of a season that still has plenty left to play. Dampier has another year of eligibility thanks to the new NCAA five-for-five rule that retroactively applies to extra players, which means he’ll be a free agent this offseason along with the rest of the roster.

He has clearly valued his time in Salt Lake City, sticking with Utah even after offensive coordinator Jason Beck and coach Kyle Whittingham left for Michigan. But if he’s not projected to go high in the NFL draft, the financial case for staying in college could be enormous.

And he’s not the only one Utah has to think about.

The Utes are trying to manage a roster of 105 players, and with the transfer portal opening Jan. 4, those conversations can’t wait until the season is over. Utah will sign its 2027 recruiting class in 16 days, and the program already has offers out to players in the 2030 class.

That’s the reality of modern college football: recruiting never really stops, and neither does the need to rerecruit your own roster. NIL, revenue sharing and an essentially unlimited transfer portal have turned every offseason into a negotiation.

The timing is brutal. The College Football Playoff quarterfinals are set for Dec.

30-Jan. 1, just three days before the portal opens. Utah still has a shot at a top-four seed and a first-round bye, which would put the Utes in the biggest game in program history while they’re also trying to keep next year’s team together.

It’s the same kind of squeeze Ole Miss dealt with last season, when Lane Kiffin took the LSU job while the Rebels were in the playoff and Pete Golding had to help stabilize the roster while preparing for one of the biggest games in school history.

Utah is hoping to get ahead of all of it. Ideally, the Utes will have deals in place before the Big 12 championship game, though some players may want to wait and see what the open market brings.

Even with all that pressure hanging around, this year’s Utah team has stayed together. Scalley pointed to the group’s unselfishness, from Dampier pushing for Byrd Ficklin to play more to the broader locker room dynamic.

The key, he said, is keeping the business side from spilling into the team room.

“Limiting the distractions and having a process as to how that takes place, where those conversations take place. If those conversations are being had in the locker room, it’s not a good thing,” Scalley said. “So it’s being very clear to our guys about here’s where those conversations take place, here’s where you’re going to get the best information.”

He also stressed the importance of being direct with players throughout the process.

“So you limit the distractions and then it’s being very upfront with how we go about the process,” Scalley said. “I think if you’re very transparent about how you handle the process and why you make the decisions that you make, they may disagree with you, but at least you’ve given them full transparency into the why.”

In Other News...

BYU Kept Its Playoff Hopes Alive But One Problem Remains

The Big 12 title race is still crowded with two weeks left, and Utah is right in the middle of it as the leagues unbeaten team and the No. 2 squad in the AP Top 25. BYU and Texas Tech are still hanging close behind at No. 12 and No. 11, which keeps the conference picture tight and leaves little margin for error as the regular season winds down.

BYUs win over Baylor helped keep its playoff hopes alive, while Utahs comeback against Arizona preserved its perfect record and strengthened its case at the top of the league. Even with the rankings sorted out for now, the bigger issue is still unresolved: the path to the Big 12 title may run through a logjam, and Utahs standing could hinge on how the next two weeks shake out. [Read more 🡒]

Utah Just Uncovered A Backfield Threat Opponents Wont Ignore

With Wayshawn Parker sidelined by a heel injury, Utah had to lean on a different option in the backfield against Arizona, and Daniel Bray answered with a breakout performance in a game the Utes could not afford to waste. In Utahs 40-39 win, Bray piled up more than 197 rushing yards and topped 200 all-purpose yards, giving the offense a much-needed spark when the pressure was highest.

Morgan Scalley made it clear after the game that the shift to Bray was driven by Parkers injury, but the bigger takeaway for Utah is how quickly Bray turned a temporary opportunity into something opponents will have to account for. If Parkers status keeps the backfield in flux, the Utes may have found a runner who can change the shape of a game every time he touches the ball. [Read more 🡒]

Utah Just Entered A National Debate Fans Wont Want Ignored

Near the end of the regular season, the AP poll picture has tightened enough that every ballot starts to matter a little more, and this one is no different. The top 10 is laid out with confidence, but the real interest for Utah fans is in the broader shape of the rankings, where the margin between teams gets thinner and the debate gets louder as the season winds down.

What makes this ballot worth watching is the uncertainty once the list stretches beyond the top group, where the evaluator is far less certain and the order becomes more open to argument. Utahs place in that conversation will be folded into the consensus Associated Press rankings soon, giving the Utes another chance to see how national perception stacks up against the week-to-week reality of the season. [Read more 🡒]