Robert Griffin III didn’t just disagree with the College Football Playoff committee’s first rankings of 2026 - he blew them up and built his own.
After the committee unveiled its initial top 25 Tuesday night with unbeaten Miami at No. 1 and two-loss Alabama at No. 5, Griffin posted a blunt response on X: “The College Football Playoff Rankings are TERRIBLE AND MAKE ZERO SENSE.”
He then laid out a top 25 that looked very different from the committee’s version, starting with Miami at No. 1 and then elevating the other unbeaten FBS teams. In Griffin’s rankings, 8-0 Utah checks in at No. 2 and 8-0 UCLA sits at No.
- Georgia, which lost to unranked Auburn, drops from No. 2 in the committee’s poll to No. 4 on Griffin’s list.
One of Griffin’s biggest moves came with UCLA. The committee placed the Bruins eighth after they lost quarterback Nico Iamaleava to a season-ending knee injury in a 17-15 win at Oregon. Bob Chesney’s team has kept rolling with senior Ty Dieffenbach at quarterback, and Griffin rewarded that run by pushing UCLA all the way up to third.
BYU and Notre Dame followed at No. 5 and No. 6 in Griffin’s rankings. That’s notable because BYU beat Notre Dame 28-24 two weeks ago, while the committee slotted Notre Dame 11th as the last team in the field. Committee chair Hunter Yurachek defended the Irish by calling them “a very, very good football team” but also said, “when you look at Notre Dame’s schedule and the wins they have versus the teams ahead of them, they don’t have that signature win right now.”
Indiana took a hit in Griffin’s version as well, sliding from No. 4 to No. 7.
The defending national champions’ only loss came against Ohio State, but they still haven’t beaten a team in the committee’s top 25. SI’s CFP rankings prediction before Tuesday’s reveal also had Indiana falling.
Griffin was even harsher on Alabama. The Crimson Tide are 6-2 and sit eight spots ahead of Tennessee in the committee rankings, even though the Volunteers beat Alabama by 16 points.
Griffin left Alabama out of his top 12 entirely and placed Tennessee at No. 12.
Yurachek stood by Alabama’s spot on the rankings show. “Yes, they had that loss to Tennessee,” he said.
“But Tennessee doesn’t have that same level of quality wins. Yes, they beat Alabama, but you have to go deeper.”
That’s a familiar argument from Griffin. He made a similar point last December when Alabama got a playoff berth over Notre Dame and BYU, saying, “If you’re going to punish BYU, punish Alabama.”
Texas also took a tumble in Griffin’s list, dropping from No. 7 in the committee rankings to No. 11.
The Longhorns have wins over Ohio State, Ole Miss and Tennessee, but losses to Oklahoma and Florida kept them from staying higher. The committee’s top 12 includes five SEC teams; Griffin’s version has four.
Two teams Griffin clearly liked more than the committee did were Wake Forest and Texas Tech. He ranked Wake Forest 10th after the committee put the 7-1 Demon Deacons at No.
- Jake Dickert’s team has won five straight, including a 51-7 win over Virginia on Saturday, and its only loss came against Miami.
Wake Forest has also beaten its last four opponents by an average score of 47-8.
Texas Tech moved up from No. 15 to No. 9 in Griffin’s rankings. The Red Raiders beat Arizona 34-26 on Saturday behind three touchdowns from Tommy Castellanos in his first start and 175 rushing yards from J’Koby Williams. Their only loss came the previous week, a 37-24 defeat at Cincinnati.
Saturday’s games will give several of Griffin’s choices a fresh test, including No. 1 Miami at No.
11 Notre Dame, No. 9 BYU at No.
3 Utah, No. 5 Alabama at No.
14 LSU and No. 6 Kentucky at No.
13 Tennessee. The committee’s next rankings come out Tuesday, Nov. 10 on ESPN.
In Other News...
BYU Just Got A Bigger Utah Test Than Fans Realized
The latest Big 12 power rankings from three KSL Sports reporters put the spotlight right where Utah fans expected it to land, on the rivalry game with BYU. The weekly list came with records, recent results and upcoming schedules for the leagues top teams, but the bigger takeaway was how much this matchup now means beyond bragging rights. It is the kind of November game that can reshape the conversation around the conference race and the postseason picture at the same time.
For Utah, the significance is obvious even before the teams take the field. BYUs place in the rankings only sharpens the stakes, because this is no longer just a rivalry meeting with local pride on the line. It is a game with real College Football Playoff implications attached, and the way the reporters stacked the league makes clear that the Utes are staring at a test with far more weight than a typical late-season showdown. [Read more 🡒]
BYU-Utah Could Decide More Than Bragging Rights This Year
The latest BYU-Utah matchup is carrying a little more weight than the usual bragging rights, and Hans Olsen sees it as a game with ripple effects beyond one Saturday in November. The former BYU player pointed to postseason positioning and the battle for in-state recruiting as part of what makes this rivalry matter so much this year, while also noting how the teams recent form has shaped the conversation around the meeting.
Olsen also leaned on memory when talking about the rivalry, recalling BYUs 2000 win over Utah in LaVell Edwards final game as head coach. He believes the Cougars have the edge heading into this one, based on what he sees from both sides and the psychological side of a rivalry game, which only adds to the intrigue for Utah fans watching a familiar matchup with bigger stakes attached. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Faces Its Biggest Test Yet With Everything Suddenly On The Line
The buildup to Saturdays Big 12 showdown has only sharpened with both Utah and BYU sitting in the national spotlight for the first time in their rivalry history. The Utes are undefeated and hosting a Cougars team with one loss, and the stakes go well beyond bragging rights with conference championship positioning and College Football Playoff hopes suddenly in play. For a rivalry that has spent decades carrying its own weight, this one arrives with the kind of national relevance that changes the temperature around everything.
Utah will have to navigate it without right tackle Kelvin Obot, who is out for the rest of the season with a lower-leg injury, a hit to an offensive line that will be tested immediately in a game like this. BYU, meanwhile, has been waiting on running back LJ Martin, who has been sidelined with a leg injury, and his status adds another layer to a matchup already loaded with pressure. When these two meet, the margins are usually thin, and now the margins feel like they could decide far more than one game. [Read more 🡒]