The first College Football Playoff rankings are about to give the sport another fresh debate, and the biggest question is whether the committee will stick with the AP poll’s new No. 1 or decide the top spot should go somewhere else.
Miami moved into first in the AP rankings after a chain reaction of losses shuffled the board - Ohio State fell to Texas, Texas then lost to Oklahoma, and Georgia later dropped a game to Auburn. That opened the door for the Hurricanes, who are unbeaten and sitting at the top of the conversation.
But the committee may not be ready to hand Miami the same crown.
The case against the Hurricanes starts with the schedule. Their résumé does not offer much in the way of elite tests, and their only win against a ranked opponent came against Wake Forest. On top of that, Miami has had to work far harder than expected in several games, going to double overtime to get past a struggling Florida State team and needing a late fourth-quarter push to slip by North Carolina.
There’s also the issue on defense. Miami’s offense has been able to overwhelm plenty of opponents, but the other side of the ball has not looked nearly as clean. A banged-up secondary and repeated breakdowns have let lesser teams hang around.
That’s where Georgia enters the picture. In a season where nearly everyone has taken a hit, the reigning SEC champion still looks like the most stable team in the field.
The Bulldogs do have a strange blemish of their own, though: a home loss to unranked Auburn. Even so, that came after what may have been the most impressive performance by any team this season, a road win over Alabama.
Georgia’s edge also comes when compared with Kentucky, which is tied with the Bulldogs for first in the SEC standings. Kentucky’s only loss is to that same Alabama team Georgia beat, but it was an ugly one.
Still, there is one team lurking that could force a real shake-up if the committee wants to get creative. Utah is 8-0 after a convincing win over Cincinnati, has climbed to No. 3 in the latest AP poll, and owns the nation’s longest winning streak at 14 games.
The Utes are also in first place in the Big 12, with a clear path to a conference title. That kind of profile could tempt the committee to make a bold move.
But the safer bet is that the selection committee lines up with the AP voters.
An undefeated record is likely to matter more than a better win paired with a loss, and that should give Miami the edge over Georgia for the top spot.
If that happens, Notre Dame may be the team that benefits most. The Irish host Miami this week, and a win there would give them a strong argument for owning the best victory in the country and keeping their playoff hopes alive.
In Other News...
Utah Gets A Tough Holy War Week Reality Check
Ahead of the Holy War, Utah got a clearer picture of its roster and a reminder of how thin the margins can be this time of year. Morgan Scalley said Kelvin Obot will miss the rest of the season because of a lower-leg injury, while also indicating that Noah Bennee, Braden Pegan, Wayshawn Parker and Ethan Day are expected to be available for the rivalry game against BYU.
Scalley also used the buildup to push for a more civil tone around a rivalry that rarely lacks edge, even as he praised Devon Dampiers performance and leadership. And with BYU quarterback Bear Bachmeier, Scalleys view has evolved as well, after initially sizing him up one way and then acknowledging how much his passing game has improved. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Heads Into Utah Showdown With A Backfield Problem
BYU is heading into Saturdays rivalry game with Utah carrying more than the usual questions about its ground attack. Kalani Sitake acknowledged the challenge this week, praising Utah back Wayshawn Parker as an NFL-caliber runner while also taking stock of a BYU backfield that has been hit hard by injuries and has not had much stability in recent weeks.
The Cougars have been forced to navigate those issues while trying to keep the running game functional against a Utah defense that will be ready for a physical fight. Sitake did not sound like a coach expecting easy answers, and with the backfield still unsettled, BYUs ability to generate offense on the ground could end up being one of the more important subplots in the matchup. [Read more 🡒]
Utah Just Added A Recruit Who Changes The Feel Of 2027
Utah kept building out its 2027 class with a notable in-state pickup, landing high three-star offensive tackle Manase Brown from Corner Canyon High. Brown gives the Utes another big body up front and adds to a class that already includes four offensive line recruits, a clear sign that the program is making the trenches a priority early in the cycle.
Brown is also now one of Utahs top-rated prospects in the class, ranked second on the Utes board for 2027. For a program that has long sold itself on development and line play, adding a player with Browns profile only sharpens the look of the class and raises the stakes for what comes next in the recruiting run. [Read more 🡒]