Stephen A. Smith’s latest college football take set off a fresh wave of backlash, this time over his comments on Utah’s place in the rankings.
Smith reacted to a top-five list from ESPN’s Chris Canty and zeroed in on the Utes at No. 2.
"What the Hell is this team doing at No. 2?"
Smith asked of Utah. "Your quality wins?
I’ve got BYU, Houston, that’s it. That’s all it is.
And Houston was suspect to begin with.... I’m not sold on Utah being the No. 2 team in the nation."
He didn’t stop there, adding that Alabama should be in the top five as well. But it was his dismissal of Utah that drew the loudest response, especially given what the Utes have done so far.
Utah is 9-0 and has outscored opponents by an average of 38-16. The schedule hasn’t featured a long list of elite teams, but the resume has still been enough to put the Utes at No. 2 in the current CFP seeding.
Social media wasted no time pushing back.
"The Utah hate is unreal considering they let Notre Dame pass with a weak schedule every year."
That reaction pointed to another part of Canty’s list: 8-1 Notre Dame at No. 3, while the Irish sit No. 5 in the CFP rankings despite a schedule that many online considered no more impressive than Utah’s.
"ESPN has ruined college football. Utah hasn’t lost bama and Texas lost twice. The man that can’t speak proper English is trying to sell 2 losses better than 0."
Smith’s praise for Alabama also drew scrutiny, with critics noting that the Tide’s two best opponents were both losses.
"Let’s compare Notre Dame and Utah’s common opponent..."
That common opponent was BYU, which beat Notre Dame and lost to Utah.
"Stephen A logic, being mad at Utah’s inclusion and Bama’s exclusion pic.twitter.com/4dQ4ZnbLY8"
Some viewers also saw a broader pattern behind the take.
"As soon as you realize ESPN has an agenda the sooner you realize why these stupid takes exist. This clown hasn’t watched Utah play once all year."
Another response took aim at Smith’s Houston comment directly.
"Suspect" Houston’s two losses: at current #2 Utah and at current #10 Texas Tech. Both by one score, both came down to the final possession.
But sure, Screamin’ A. Whatever you say.
For plenty of viewers, that was the problem in a nutshell: Smith’s narrative didn’t seem to line up with the facts people were pointing to, and they let him hear about it.
In Other News...
Utah Fans Have A Real Reason To Worry About Huntsman Center
The Jon M. Huntsman Center has long been one of the defining buildings in Utah athletics, but the numbers around it are getting harder to ignore. The arena operated at a $765,859 loss last fiscal year, and the projection for this year points to a deficit that could top $1 million, leaving the university to keep covering the gap while the building remains central to the Utes basketball identity.
Utah is already looking for a different path forward, with plans to renovate the arena through a private equity partnership with Otro Capital and Crimson Brand Partners that would handle commercial sports events and facility operations. The bigger concern is that the Huntsman Center is not standing alone in the red, either, since athletics overall is also projected to run a deficit amid conference changes and new salary pools for student-athletes, adding another layer of pressure to a department already trying to balance tradition with a tougher financial reality. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Fans Suddenly Have A Very Uncomfortable Reason To Watch Utah
The latest College Football Playoff rankings have given the Big 12 a real spotlight, with Utah sitting at No. 2 and BYU at No. 10 while several other league teams also landed in the top 25. For Utah, that kind of position only sharpens the stakes of every remaining result, because the Utes are now part of a conference picture that suddenly looks a lot stronger than it did a few weeks ago.
For BYU fans, though, the uncomfortable part is that Utahs path matters far beyond Salt Lake City. The Utes are now tied into a web of playoff possibilities that could ripple through BYU and Texas Tech depending on how the next games and the conference championship shake out, which means Cougar supporters have every reason to keep one eye on their rival. And even if this years bracket leaves some teams sweating, next seasons expanded 24-team playoff should make the road a little less nerve-racking for everyone involved. [Read more 🡒]
Utah's New Backcourt Class Says A Lot About Alex Jensen's Plan
Utahs 2027 recruiting class already gives a clear early look at how Alex Jensen wants to build his backcourt. The Utes announced the signings of Pierce Thompson and Jamaal McKnight Jr., adding two guards with different profiles but the same long-term value for a program trying to establish a new identity under its head coach.
Thompson brings a 6-foot-4 frame and international experience, while McKnight arrives as a four-star point guard who picked Utah over finalists that included Kansas. The pairing gives Jensen a mix of size, playmaking and versatility for the 2027-28 season, and it suggests Utah is not waiting around to reshape its guard room with talent that fits multiple roles. [Read more 🡒]