Kyle Whittingham was brought in to steady the ship, but 11 months into the job, the fit looks increasingly off.
Michigan entered this season with room to fall short of last year’s 9-3 record, but the expectation was that the product would at least look cleaner. The Wolverines were supposed to have a clearer identity, and maybe even position themselves as a championship contender in 2027. Even with a brutal schedule, there was a path where fans could live with fewer wins if Bryce Underwood looked better, the team looked competent in all three phases, and the overall operation showed progress.
That hasn’t happened. After eight games, Michigan sits at 5-3, and disappointing feels like the only fair word for it.
Part of the frustration is that the schedule has softened around them. Oregon, which was supposed to be one of the season’s toughest road trips, has cratered.
Ohio State will be without its starting quarterback for the rest of the regular season. Indiana has struggled to score, Oklahoma hasn’t lived up to its billing, and Penn State has fallen apart too.
The Big Ten has opened up enough that Michigan still had a real chance to get into the conference title race if it could simply get its own house in order.
Instead, the best result on the ledger so far, at least in Whittingham’s eyes, is a 13-6 overtime loss to Indiana.
After that game, he tried to frame the defeat as a sign of progress.
“If that’s a number six team in the country, then we’re a pretty good football team even though we’re sitting at 4-3,” Whittingham said.
That wasn’t the only eyebrow-raising moment. On his weekly radio appearance, Whittingham also described Michigan’s 28-21 escape against Rutgers as enjoyable to watch.
"Yeah, I come in early Sunday and watch it all by myself.," Whittingham told Jon Jansen. "The entire game, offense, defense, special teams, back to back to back and it was a pleasurable game to watch on Sunday morning. So yeah, I give myself a couple of hours after that and then on to the next.”
The problem is not that a coach has to be angry every week. It’s that Whittingham keeps talking like someone who doesn’t fully grasp the expectations attached to this job.
At Utah, a win over a bottom-tier conference team might have been enough to satisfy the moment. At Michigan, it isn’t.
Beating Rutgers is supposed to be routine. Beating Rutgers by double digits is supposed to be routine.
Jim Harbaugh looked visibly annoyed during a 78-0 rout of the Scarlet Knights in October of 2016, and that reaction says plenty about the standard.
This was supposed to be a game Michigan controlled. The Wolverines were favored by double digits, Rutgers was working with a backup quarterback, and the Scarlet Knights completed only four passes if you count the two-point conversion that tied the game in the fourth quarter. Michigan still let it become a close one, and the same issues that have followed the team all season were still there.
Tommy Carr’s heroics ended up sparing Whittingham from even more uncomfortable questions about how the team played.
The bigger issue is that the early hope around this hire has faded fast. Michigan fans were willing to believe a disciplined coach with a strong track record could keep the program closer to the Jim Harbaugh era than the Brady Hoke era. But that’s not how it looks right now.
Being the coach at Michigan is not for everybody, and Whittingham is starting to look like someone who has not adjusted to what comes with the job. Brady Hoke wanted the job and still failed.
Rich Rodriguez never fit. Sherrone Moore was a disaster for multiple reasons, and the hope was that Whittingham would be different.
Instead, the comparison that keeps coming up is not Harbaugh. It’s Hoke.
And if Michigan loses to Michigan State on Saturday, Whittingham may find that there’s very little future left to talk about.
In Other News...
BYU Just Got A Bigger Utah Test Than Fans Realized
The latest Big 12 power rankings from three KSL Sports reporters put the spotlight right where Utah fans expected it to land, on the rivalry game with BYU. The weekly list came with records, recent results and upcoming schedules for the leagues top teams, but the bigger takeaway was how much this matchup now means beyond bragging rights. It is the kind of November game that can reshape the conversation around the conference race and the postseason picture at the same time.
For Utah, the significance is obvious even before the teams take the field. BYUs place in the rankings only sharpens the stakes, because this is no longer just a rivalry meeting with local pride on the line. It is a game with real College Football Playoff implications attached, and the way the reporters stacked the league makes clear that the Utes are staring at a test with far more weight than a typical late-season showdown. [Read more 🡒]
Utah Just Got The National CFP Respect Fans Have Wanted
The first College Football Playoff rankings of the 2026 season already stirred up debate, but Robert Griffin III added another layer to it with his own version of the top 25. His list looked very different from the committees, and it gave Utah a prominent spot near the top while also underscoring just how much disagreement still exists over how teams are being judged this early in the season.
For Utah fans, the bigger takeaway is not just the placement itself but the kind of attention it reflects. The committee chair defended the rankings by pointing to quality wins and schedule strength, which only adds to the conversation around where the Utes fit in the national picture. For a program trying to earn respect on the CFP stage, seeing its name land so high in a national voices alternate rankings is the sort of validation supporters have been asking for. [Read more 🡒]
BYU-Utah Could Decide More Than Bragging Rights This Year
The latest BYU-Utah matchup is carrying a little more weight than the usual bragging rights, and Hans Olsen sees it as a game with ripple effects beyond one Saturday in November. The former BYU player pointed to postseason positioning and the battle for in-state recruiting as part of what makes this rivalry matter so much this year, while also noting how the teams recent form has shaped the conversation around the meeting.
Olsen also leaned on memory when talking about the rivalry, recalling BYUs 2000 win over Utah in LaVell Edwards final game as head coach. He believes the Cougars have the edge heading into this one, based on what he sees from both sides and the psychological side of a rivalry game, which only adds to the intrigue for Utah fans watching a familiar matchup with bigger stakes attached. [Read more 🡒]