BYU and Utah are showing up near the top of the national charts in a place that matters a lot in college football: turning talent into wins.
That’s the heart of Brett Ciancia’s evaluation in his “Pick Six Previews” look at the 2026 season. His numbers point to the Big 12 as the country’s best league for player development and win conversion, with BYU leading the way.
Ciancia frames the idea simply: a program lands a strong recruiting class, maybe even stacks a few of them, and then the real test begins. “Player development and converting the raw talent into wins on the field.”
Using recruit rankings from 247Sports and comparing them to actual results, Ciancia’s win conversion matrix puts BYU at No. 2 nationally behind SMU. Kansas State is No.
3, Texas Tech No. 4, Utah No. 7 and Houston No.
- By Ciancia’s count, the Big 12 owns five of the top 10 win conversion teams.
The same league is also loaded in player development. Ciancia’s second formula compares recruit rankings from 2019 through 2022 with NFL draft picks from 2023 through 2026, and the Big 12 again shows up in force.
Texas Tech is No. 2, Kansas State No.
3, Arizona No. 5 and TCU No. 7.
Illinois sits at No. 1 in that category.
What jumps out is who is missing from the top of that development list. Ohio State, Oregon, Michigan, Alabama, Penn State, Miami, Florida, Florida State, Texas and Texas A&M all recruit at a high level, but they are not in the top 10 in Ciancia’s player development matrix.
For BYU and Utah, the numbers line up with the way both programs have been discussed this offseason. Kalani Sitake’s run at BYU has drawn national praise.
Brett McMurphy of On3 Sport ranked him as the top Big 12 coach and pointed to the Cougars’ 15-3 record in league play over the past two years. Brandon Marcello of CBS Sports went even further, ranking Sitake No. 5 among FBS coaches and calling him a major overachiever.
Marcello wrote that Sitake “has done a spectacular job under difficult circumstances ... (coming) very close to making the CFP despite having a total of two NFL draft picks in those two seasons.”
BYU defensive tackle Justin Kirkland, who transferred from Oklahoma State, said the difference between the two programs comes down to more than football. “The biggest difference ... is just the culture at BYU.
And everybody is so much older ... a little bit more mature ... the spiritual aspect of BYU. ... It’s just a little bit of a higher standard.”
Utah’s transition from Kyle Whittingham to Morgan Scalley has also drawn strong backing from inside the program. Whittingham said, “Morgan Scalley is an exceptional football coach. ...
He’s a proven commodity. ... His track record as far as player development speaks for itself.”
He also described Scalley as a “relentless preparer and an outstanding teacher ... really good schematically ... has all of the tools to be a great defensive coordinator.”
Cornerbacks coach and associate head coach Sharrieff Shah said Scalley has been “preparing for this position for a long time,” and pointed to notebooks full of staff ideas from years ago. Shah also described him as “infectiously optimistic” and “unrelentingly positive,” while stressing how deeply he has invested in the program.
Defensive lineman Junior Tafuna was just as direct: “That’s the right guy for the position. The program is in great hands ...
Coach Scalley has been a great defensive coach, a great coach, and a great friend to me. I think no one else deserves it.
Quarterback Devon Dampier said Scalley’s arrival changed the tone quickly. “just lifted us up from the jump. ... Practices were hard.
Just grateful for ... the way he handled everything, and that’s kind of what kept us together." Dampier added that the team’s buy-in has been obvious all summer: “I think the way Scalley’s came in, the way our team’s buying in, just the way this summer’s been, a lot of player-led things, just feels like we’re coming together as a team.
So I’m pretty excited just to kick off the new era of Utah football.”
Sitake is set to host media members on Thursday at Timpanogos Golf Club in Provo for a golf outing that gives his staff, a few players and the beat writers a more relaxed day before camp. Interviews are expected throughout the day, which should bring more football talk before the season gets rolling.
In Other News...
Houston Is In The Big 12 Talk But One Doubt Remains
As the Big 12 looks toward 2026, ESPN analyst Greg McElroy sees a league with plenty of intrigue but not enough proven firepower at the top. He pointed to the conferences coaching turnover and the lack of true superstar talent compared with the other Power Four leagues, while noting the Big 12 has not produced a national champion since the four-team playoff era began in 2014.
Utah still belongs in the conversation, though, because McElroy listed the Utes with Texas Tech, BYU and Houston as teams that could reach the playoff. The catch is the same one hanging over the rest of the league: getting there is one thing, and making a real run is another, especially when the national title picture still feels out of reach from the Big 12 side. [Read more 🡒]
Utahs 2026 Ceiling May Come Down To One Brutal Stretch
Utahs 2026 outlook looks sturdy enough through the first two months that the bigger question is not whether the Utes can handle the early schedule, but how much margin they will have left when the calendar turns. The path runs through familiar Big 12 pressure points, with BYU, Arizona and TCU all looming as the kind of games that can shape whether a promising season stays on track or starts to fray.
The concern is what comes after the fast start, when the roster and staff may no longer look quite as settled as they do on paper now. With coaching changes and notable departures already part of the conversation, the final stretch could be where Utahs ceiling gets tested most sharply, and where a team built to contend has to prove it can still hold together when the schedule gets cruel. [Read more 🡒]