Hans Olsen doesn’t need much prompting to get fired up about BYU-Utah, and this week he went all in on a matchup that already had plenty of juice.
The former BYU defensive tackle, who played for the Cougars from 1996-00, said the game has climbed into a different category entirely.
“This game has reached epic levels. Can you think of a more insane scenario?
Same conference, crazy records, national rankings, the whole coaching combo - Morgan and Kalani,” Olsen told the “Y’s Guys” livestream show this week. “It just seems like this is a powder keg waiting for a spark to explode!”
Olsen will be in the broadcast booth Saturday morning with Greg Wrubell on BYU Radio, and he sees the stakes as bigger than bragging rights. The result could reshape the postseason picture.
“Utah (8-0) beating BYU (7-1) would destroy BYU’s goals and hopes because they already have the one loss,” he said. “BYU beating Utah would be another top five victory for BYU, which would almost certainly qualify them for the CFP.”
He also pointed to the long view, saying the rivalry still carries weight in recruiting and in the fight for in-state control.
“Most kids now, if they are at the level of being recruited by Utah, then they are at the level being recruited by BYU, and vice versa,” Olsen said. “I think (the game) plays a role in state dominance.
When Utah was running off consecutive wins and now that BYU has put three together, I think that it shows the sign of power and growth. There are so many layers that make this thing so critically important.”
Olsen is picking BYU, and his logic has less to do with X’s and O’s than with what happens inside a locker room after a big win or a tough stretch.
“I think the way the last two weeks have played out plays in BYU’s favor. Everybody could have told BYU after the Notre Dame win, ‘Don’t have the UCF letdown!
Don’t have the UCF letdown!’ It’s just something wild that happens in a locker room.
Utah just thumped Cincinnati. Embarrassed them.
BYU has been in the trenches. They have been soul searching after a loss to UCF and a close win against Arizona State. ...
They have all kinds of negative plays to go back and look at. They are not looking at the positives.
They are looking at the negatives.
“Utah players are in the locker room, and they are watching the highlights and they are like, ‘Man, are we good boys! Are we good!’
And you can’t stop that. You can’t stop it.
So, who’s battle tested? Who’s got the scars to remind you, ‘Maybe I shouldn’t walk into the barbwire next time?’
BYU, they have the scars, and I think it’s going to play out on Saturday, give me BYU 28-24.”
For Olsen, Rice-Eccles Stadium will always bring back one game above all others: BYU’s 34-27 comeback in 2000, LaVell Edwards’ final game as head coach.
That night, quarterback Brandon Doman led a seven-play, 80-yard drive in the final minute and finished it with a 4-yard touchdown run with 23 seconds left. The win gave Edwards his 257th victory, pushed BYU to 6-6, and kept the Hall of Fame coach from ending his career with a losing record.
“When I reflect back on my 20 years of football - seven years professional, five years at BYU, four years in high school, and I started playing when I was 8 - the greatest moment and memory was that send-off for LaVell,” Olsen said. “The fact that we got to lift LaVell up and take him off that way, that thing couldn’t have played out any better.”
He also ranked his favorite moments from the rivalry, starting with the memory of that 2000 game and working backward through a list that includes some of the most dramatic finishes in series history.
At No. 5, Olsen went with BYU’s 37-17 win in 1996, his first taste of the rivalry and the last time the Cougars beat Utah by double digits.
He remembered the battle between BYU defensive lineman Henry Bloomfield and Utah running back Chris Fuamatu-Ma’afala as “He Man vs. King Kong.”
At No. 4, he chose BYU’s 22-21 win in 2024, the game decided by Will Ferrin’s 44-yard field goal. Olsen called it “The Will Ferrin field goal game,” and said the smile on Ferrin’s face before the kick stuck with him.
No. 3 was BYU’s 33-31 win in 2006, the one sealed by John Beck’s final-play touchdown pass to Jonny Harline. Olsen called it “one of the first games that I covered (as a journalist) after my playing career” and said, “It’s hard to say it’s not one of the most magical endings in rivalry history.”
His No. 2 memory was BYU’s 26-24 win in 1998, when Utah’s Ryan Kaneshiro missed a 32-yard field goal off the upright. Olsen said, “I don’t know to that point how many times I had even seen a ball hit an upright, and that thing just doinked and the whole crowd could hear it.”
And at No. 1, nothing topped the 34-27 BYU win in 1999, which he called “LaVell’s last miracle.”
In Other News...
BYU Just Got A Bigger Utah Test Than Fans Realized
The latest Big 12 power rankings from three KSL Sports reporters put the spotlight right where Utah fans expected it to land, on the rivalry game with BYU. The weekly list came with records, recent results and upcoming schedules for the leagues top teams, but the bigger takeaway was how much this matchup now means beyond bragging rights. It is the kind of November game that can reshape the conversation around the conference race and the postseason picture at the same time.
For Utah, the significance is obvious even before the teams take the field. BYUs place in the rankings only sharpens the stakes, because this is no longer just a rivalry meeting with local pride on the line. It is a game with real College Football Playoff implications attached, and the way the reporters stacked the league makes clear that the Utes are staring at a test with far more weight than a typical late-season showdown. [Read more 🡒]
Utah Just Got The National CFP Respect Fans Have Wanted
The first College Football Playoff rankings of the 2026 season already stirred up debate, but Robert Griffin III added another layer to it with his own version of the top 25. His list looked very different from the committees, and it gave Utah a prominent spot near the top while also underscoring just how much disagreement still exists over how teams are being judged this early in the season.
For Utah fans, the bigger takeaway is not just the placement itself but the kind of attention it reflects. The committee chair defended the rankings by pointing to quality wins and schedule strength, which only adds to the conversation around where the Utes fit in the national picture. For a program trying to earn respect on the CFP stage, seeing its name land so high in a national voices alternate rankings is the sort of validation supporters have been asking for. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Faces Its Biggest Test Yet With Everything Suddenly On The Line
The buildup to Saturdays Big 12 showdown has only sharpened with both Utah and BYU sitting in the national spotlight for the first time in their rivalry history. The Utes are undefeated and hosting a Cougars team with one loss, and the stakes go well beyond bragging rights with conference championship positioning and College Football Playoff hopes suddenly in play. For a rivalry that has spent decades carrying its own weight, this one arrives with the kind of national relevance that changes the temperature around everything.
Utah will have to navigate it without right tackle Kelvin Obot, who is out for the rest of the season with a lower-leg injury, a hit to an offensive line that will be tested immediately in a game like this. BYU, meanwhile, has been waiting on running back LJ Martin, who has been sidelined with a leg injury, and his status adds another layer to a matchup already loaded with pressure. When these two meet, the margins are usually thin, and now the margins feel like they could decide far more than one game. [Read more 🡒]