Jazz Draft Debate Just Got More Complicated After Latest 2024 Fallout

Despite the criticisms surrounding Cody Williams' trade, recent player performances suggest the Jazz's draft strategy may have been more astute than initially perceived.

The Utah Jazz may have moved on from Cody Williams, but the 2024 NBA Draft keeps offering reminders that this was never a clean exercise in talent evaluation. Atlanta’s decision to waive Devin Carter only adds to that picture.

The Hawks are waiving former lottery pick Devin Carter, according to league sources.

  • Jake Fischer (@JakeLFischer) September 11, 2026

Carter went three picks after Williams, and that matters because it underscores just how murky that draft class looked two years ago. Williams was always seen as a project, and Utah understood development would take time. He did start to show some signs of growth, but it wasn’t enough for the Jazz to keep investing in him.

That doesn’t mean every player taken after him was a miss. Matas Buzelis has clearly turned into a better outcome, and there are others who have separated themselves as well.

Still, at the time, there was no obvious answer sitting there waiting to be taken. That’s the reality of the class: a lot of uncertainty, a few bright spots, and plenty of swings that didn’t land cleanly.

There were some top-end names who looked the part right away, including Stephon Castle, Donovan Clingan, and Zach Edey. But the deeper you got into the lottery, the harder it became to feel confident about any one direction. Zacharie Risacher is already on a new team, Reed Sheppard looks like a perfectly adequate sixth man, Ron Holland is meh, Rob Dillingham is also on a new team, and does anyone know who Tidjane Salaun is?

That’s why the Jazz taking heat for not picking a lane early feels a little different in hindsight. Sure, people will always question whether they should have committed harder one way or another, but the class itself didn’t exactly hand out can’t-miss answers.

Utah’s other two picks, at least, gave them something tangible. Isaiah Collier, taken late in the first round, and Kyle Filipowski, selected early in the second, both turned into reasonably productive players.

Neither is projecting as a star, and after Williams was traded, Utah’s long-term plan with them is fair to question. But for where they were drafted, and considering how uneven this class has been overall, the Jazz can feel pretty good about landing them.

Williams wasn’t expected to be the name on the move, but his lack of traction, combined with Utah’s win-now push and their preference for players who are ready sooner, led to him being moved out. Carter getting waived doesn’t erase Williams’ struggles. It does make the Jazz’s decision look a lot more defensible.

In Other News...

Jazz Fans Have One More Reason To Love The Walker Kessler Trade

When the Jazz sent Walker Kessler to the Lakers months ago, the return already looked like the kind of move that could shape the rest of their rebuild. Utah came away with two unprotected first-round picks and two first-round pick swaps, a hefty haul for a young center who had already become one of the franchises more dependable interior pieces.

Now there is another layer to why that deal keeps aging well for Utah. Detroit center Jalen Durens next contract talks have reportedly turned into a standoff, with the Pistons and one of the leagues more promising big men still far apart as the sides weigh the path forward, and the possibility of a much murkier outcome for Detroit only makes the Jazzs long-term return look even more valuable. [Read more 🡒]

Former Jazz Big Man Just Sparked A Brutal LeBron Debate

A former Jazz center has stirred up a familiar kind of NBA debate by taking a hard line on LeBron James. On SiriusXM NBA Radio, Olden Polynice argued that James has underachieved in his career, framing his case around a benchmark that has become shorthand for all-around production in the modern game. It is the sort of old-school take that instantly gets people talking, especially when it comes from a player who once wore Utah colors and knows how quickly those conversations can spill across the league.

For Jazz fans, the larger point is less about agreeing with the criticism than recognizing the trend behind it. Former players have been increasingly willing to weigh in publicly on current stars, and the tone is often blunt, sometimes even dismissive, whether the target is a reigning legend or a defensive anchor like Rudy Gobert. In James' case, the backdrop is impossible to ignore: the records, the titles, the longevity, and the career that has rewritten several parts of the NBA ledger all sit right there against the criticism, which is why this kind of take never stays quiet for long. [Read more 🡒]