USC got out of Piscataway with a 42-35 win over Rutgers, but the final score did a lot more flattering than the performance deserved.
This had all the familiar USC fingerprints: a long trip, a supposedly new setup, and a game that still turned into a grind against a team the Trojans were expected to handle. USC spent the offseason pointing to changes - the move into the Bloom Center, the new defensive coordinator and staff on the back end, the altered travel schedule that sent the team east on Thursday instead of Friday - and yet the Trojans were dragged into a one-possession fight on a beautiful day in New Jersey.
The game was still in doubt until one of the final kneeldowns, when Jayden Maiava fumbled but USC recovered. That was the kind of night it was.
The Trojans did get real help from the depth they had talked up all summer. With Trent Mosley out and Waymond Jordan not at his usual level, Corey Simms and Riley Wormley stepped into bigger roles and delivered.
Simms broke loose for a 52-yard touchdown down the left side, taking a pass, turning upfield and finishing it off for USC’s first big answer. That score made it 17-7 with 11:59 left in the second quarter.
Wormley kept adding to the damage. He punched in a 12-yard touchdown run to push USC ahead 35-21 after Kayden Dixon-Wyatt hauled in a sharp two-point conversion catch.
Later, Wormley finished another drive by snagging an imperfect bootleg throw from Maiava on third-and-goal from the 2. The 5-foot-9, 190-pound second-year freshman finished with 52 rushing yards on three carries and that touchdown reception.
Simms had four catches for 72 yards and his score.
USC also found explosives in other places. Prophet Brown came up with the biggest defensive play of the night, reading a slant from Rutgers quarterback Dylan Lonergan and taking it 99 yards the other way for a touchdown.
It was a huge swing in a game where USC needed every edge it could get. The Trojans also had four more completions of at least 20 yards and eight runs of 10 yards or more.
Still, that should have been enough to put Rutgers away, and it never happened.
USC was sloppy again. The Trojans dropped an untimely pass and racked up eight penalties for 76 yards after being told penalties were an "intolerable" issue against Louisiana. Lincoln Riley didn’t pretend otherwise.
"[Offensively] there was a lot of good," Riley said. "Guys made some clutch plays.
I'm most proud of being able to run it out there and end the game with the ball in our hands. That's the thing I was most excited about.
We made some big-time plays, but we also had some big-time mistakes and untimely penalties that'll have to get better."
Special teams briefly looked like it might give USC some breathing room. Mike Ekeler was fired up when Trestin Castro pinned a great Lachlan Carrigan punt at the Rutgers 5.
But Rutgers answered with a 95-yard touchdown drive that included a 40-yard gain on a fake punt, and suddenly the game was 20-14 USC. That sequence made it clear the Scarlet Knights were not going away.
They never really did. In the second half, Rutgers moved the ball with ease against Gary Patterson’s defense, scoring 21 points and averaging 7.8 yards per play.
The Scarlet Knights ran for 132 yards on just 18 carries, a staggering 7.3 yards per attempt. USC did manage one huge defensive stand, stopping Rutgers on a fourth-down gamble that followed a bad Wildcat call by Greg Schiano, and that stop helped the Trojans escape.
Riley didn’t like what he saw on that side of the ball either.
"[Defensively] I like our good," Riley said. "But when we get teams behind the chains, we got to do a better job of making them pay.
That's when the game is in your favor defensively, and that's when we were at our worst today. So we got to be better at that, and we got to do a better job.
Some of the explosive plays in the run game. There were probably two runs that really got out, maybe three the entire day, and they probably averaged a couple of yards a carry on everything else.
We misfit a couple of runs and missed a few tackles in the secondary. That we got to be able to get those down.
When you play good, your explosive runs are a 10- or 11-yard gain and not those. So, just got to be better.
Got to improve."
The larger issue is that USC won because it had more talent and enough firepower to outscore Rutgers, not because it controlled the game. The Trojans didn’t dominate physically on defense.
The pass rush never really showed up against a quarterback who was already inaccurate without pressure. On offense, King Miller gave USC another lift with 16 carries for 102 yards, a 6.4-yard average, and the line gave Maiava time to throw.
But with Maiava off his game, the balance still looked off: 32 passes and 31 runs.
That’s the part USC has to live with now. Oregon comes to the Coliseum next Saturday, and the Trojans have already shown enough through four games to believe they can beat Dan Lanning’s team. They also showed, once again, that they can slide back into the same sloppy, inconsistent version that has cost them in these kinds of games.
Lincoln Riley is now 6-13 against ranked teams as USC’s head coach, and the record against top-10 teams is even worse. This was the kind of game USC has failed to close under Riley before, and for much of the night, it looked like another one of those nights.
It didn’t cost them against Rutgers. It can’t become the script moving forward.
In Other News...
USC Escaped Rutgers But One Troubling Issue Still Lingers
USC survived a tense battle with Rutgers, pulling out a 42-35 win that was far less comfortable than the ranking suggested. The Trojans needed big days from redshirt sophomore Miller and redshirt-freshman Riley Wormley to keep the offense moving, with both players supplying key runs and touchdowns as Rutgers stayed within striking distance throughout the afternoon.
The result will count, but it also left a familiar concern hanging over the Trojans. USC leaned heavily on individual playmakers, and the offense still had stretches defined by penalties and uneven passing, the kind of issues that can make even a win feel like a warning sign. Rutgers kept forcing USC to answer, and the bigger question now is whether the Trojans can clean up the rough edges before a tougher spot in the schedule turns those flaws into something more costly. [Read more 🡒]
USC Stayed Unbeaten But One Problem Looms Before Oregon
Southern California escaped its Big Ten opener with a 42-35 win over Rutgers, a game that looked more comfortable on the scoreboard than it felt on the field. Jayden Maiava threw for 277 yards and two touchdowns, King Miller added 102 rushing yards and a score, and the Trojans did enough to stay unbeaten even as Rutgers Dylan Lonergan pushed back with 272 passing yards and three touchdowns.
The bigger concern now is what comes next. USC gets Oregon at home, and the Ducks will be a far different test than a Rutgers team that hurt itself with turnovers, including a 99-yard interception returned for a touchdown. The Trojans survived this one, but the margin for error gets a lot thinner from here. [Read more 🡒]
Rutgers Fans Wont Like How USC Kept That Drive Alive
USCs first road trip of the season had the kind of third-quarter sequence that tends to linger long after the final whistle. In the middle of a pivotal drive against Rutgers, an inadvertent whistle wiped out a completed third-down pass, forcing the down to be replayed and turning one clean conversion into a fresh round of pressure for the Trojans.
From there, the drive took a winding path, with USC failing on the replayed third down before going for it on fourth and eventually hitting a 32-yard completion to keep things moving. It was the sort of break-and-response sequence that can swing a road game, and the No. 12 Trojans made enough of those plays to leave New Jersey with a win and a 4-0 record. [Read more 🡒]