The NCAA’s latest eligibility ruling may have slammed the door on a bizarre path back into college football, but not before it forced coaches like Lincoln Riley to think through a question few ever expected to face.
On Friday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit paused the nationwide ruling that had temporarily given Class of 2022 athletes a shot at a fifth season.
That means players leaning only on that decision are no longer eligible to play this fall. Some athletes who received separate rulings from state courts, though, remain eligible.
The issue had created an unusual possibility: former college players who had already finished their eligibility, and in some cases even signed with NFL teams, potentially returning to the college game. That scenario sparked plenty of debate about fairness, age, and whether it made sense for players in their early 20s, some with preseason NFL experience, to be competing for snaps against teenagers.
Riley was asked about that exact possibility just one day before the latest ruling, and he didn’t hide where USC would stand if the rules opened the door.
“There’s things within the rules of the game that if there’s a place to have an advantage for USC, we would always look at it whether we agree with it or not,” Riley said Thursday.
Former USC receiver Jay Fair was mentioned as one possible Trojan who could have been part of that conversation.
Riley’s answer wasn’t just about roster building. It was a window into how college football works now - a sport where coaches live and die by results, and where the pressure never really lets up. A single win or loss can shape the future of a staff, and the 2025 season saw more than ten mid-season head coaching dismissals before the regular season even ended.
That reality leaves coaches with tough choices. Riley said he wishes the situation weren’t part of the sport at all.
“That is definitely something that I wish wasn't happening right now in college football, and not for any individual's sake, just for the overall good of the game,” said Riley.
He also made clear that USC has already been paying attention as different court decisions have unfolded around the country.
“For us, it's something we're looking at, it's something we have looked at as some of these different judges' decisions have transpired across the country. There's never going to be a stone that's not going to be uncovered, that's not going to be looked at, discussed.”
Still, Riley drew a line. USC would not simply bring someone back because the option exists. The player would have to fit the team, the culture, and what the Trojans are trying to build.
“Ultimately, at the end of the day, you've got to feel like bringing in somebody is in the best interest of the team, right?” Riley said
“Addition doesn't always mean necessarily making you better, right? And we feel very strongly about the group that we've put together, we feel very strongly about the kind of culture and attitude and vibe of this team right now, and so first and foremost, we're going to protect that, and if at some point someone comes up that we feel like can add to the roster and add to the intangible part of this, then we would certainly look at it.”
For Riley, the issue sits right at the intersection of principle and pragmatism. He may not like where college football is headed, but if a rule creates a real chance to improve USC, that’s not the kind of thing a coach at this level can casually brush aside.
In Other News...
USC-UCLA Has One Tradition College Football Should Stop Copying
When Alabama and Tennessee announced they would both wear their home uniforms for their meeting this season, it stirred up an old college football debate: whether more rivalries should embrace the look that has long defined USC and UCLA. In Los Angeles, the setup works because it is tied to one specific game, one specific feel and one of the sports most recognizable visual traditions, with the Trojans cardinal and the Bruins blue playing off each other in a way that instantly says something about the rivalry itself.
But making double-home uniforms a routine habit across college football would risk turning a special wrinkle into a gimmick. The NFL learned as much during its Color Rush experiment, where color-on-color matchups sometimes looked fresh and sometimes just looked awkward, and thats the caution here for USC fans who know the rivalrys aesthetic is part of the event. What makes USC-UCLA stand out is that it is not everywhere, and college football is usually better when it leaves a few traditions alone. [Read more 🡒]
Why USC Fans Still Treat One Enemy Different Than Everyone Else
For USC fans, the old grievances still have a way of dwarfing the modern rivalry map. ESPNs recent list of arch-enemies for power conference programs put the NCAA at the top of the Trojans board instead of a fellow school, a nod to how deeply the sanctions from the Reggie Bush investigation still linger in the fan bases memory. The punishment tied to improper benefits never faded into simple history around here; it became part of how USC supporters tell the story of what the program lost and who they blame for it.
The resentment is sharpened by the feeling that college footballs enforcement has never looked even-handed. USCs punishment remains a touchstone in debates over fairness because the NCAAs handling of violations has often seemed inconsistent, and Penn States less severe sanction for far more serious infractions is still a painful comparison for Trojan fans. So while rivalries usually come with a school, a mascot or a border war, USCs most personal beef remains institutional, and it is not hard to see why that edge has never really gone away. [Read more 🡒]
USC Secondary Hype Around Jontez Williams Comes With One Big Catch
Jontez Williams arrives at USC with the kind of rsum that naturally gets people talking. The Iowa State transfer was an All-Big 12 Second Team selection in 2024, and his reputation as a disruptive defensive back has already made him one of the more intriguing pieces in the Trojans secondary heading into the upcoming season. An analyst even slotted him 145th among college football players, which says plenty about the respect he carries and the level of expectation surrounding him in Los Angeles.
For USC, the appeal is obvious: Williams is expected to play a significant role right away in a unit that needs difference-makers. The catch is just as obvious, though no less important. His value to the Trojans hinges on health, and that makes his availability one of the quieter but more consequential storylines as USC tries to stabilize its defense and turn a promising addition into a real asset. [Read more 🡒]