Lincoln Riley’s job status is back in the spotlight, but Fox Sports analyst Joel Klatt thinks USC would make a huge error if it panics.
The debate came up on “The Herd,” where the conversation centered on coaches leaning too hard on the transfer portal and NIL. The show’s host lumped Riley in with Colorado’s Deion Sanders and former LSU coach Brian Kelly, calling the portal and NIL “a little fool's gold.”
“Brian Kelly, Deion Sanders and Lincoln Riley all went heavy when NIL came out,” the host said.
He also pointed to USC’s shift toward high school recruiting after the school hired general manager Chad Bowden from Notre Dame. Bowden’s first cycle delivered the nation’s No. 1 class for 2026.
“His mistake to me is, like Brian Kelly, he's like, 'I'm going portal,'” the host said.
Klatt pushed back, saying the portal can work - but only in the right setup.
“I can understand how you philosophically get there. I don't think it's correct,” Klatt said.
“And the reason is because we've seen teams that have been built through the portal succeed. I think that generally happens when a coach moves and brings his core with him.”
He pointed to Riley’s best season at USC as an example. Caleb Williams followed Riley from Oklahoma through the portal, and the 2022 Trojans finished 11-3.
“So your transfers, they have to be yours. And what's difficult is to build a new culture out of the transfer portal,” Klatt added.
Klatt also drew a line between NIL and the portal.
“Because NIL, everybody is paying players,” he said. “Everybody has players that are making well over a million dollars on their roster.”
For Klatt, the best programs are built from the inside out.
“What I see right now is that the best teams in college football have built their teams and a culture from within, and then they sprinkle in positions of need out of the transfer portal,” Klatt said.
Riley’s situation has been under the microscope since USC’s 41-27 home loss to Oregon on Sept. 26, when CBS Sports insider Matt Zenitz reported that his future had come under “serious question.” Riley is 5-15 against ranked opponents at USC, and his reported buyout is $70 million.
But the pressure eased at least a little when USC came back from 21-10 down to beat Washington 25-21 on Oct. 3.
The student section chanted “Fire Lincoln!” during that game, yet the Trojans are still 5-1 overall and 2-1 in Big Ten play.
“They're closer to Oregon than they were a year ago,” Klatt said. “But this process is working at USC. This is a much better team than they've had over the last couple of years.”
On “Big Noon Kickoff,” Klatt also put a price tag on any coaching change, estimating it would cost USC “$100 to $120 million.” He named freshmen Luke Wafle, Kaden Dixon-Wyatt, Trent Mosley and tight end Mark Bowman as players other programs would try to chase if the Trojans made a move.
The segment didn’t focus on Sanders’ future, but Colorado’s season has already slipped. The Buffaloes are 2-3 after a 29-7 loss to No. 12 Texas Tech, and Sanders is 18-24 in Boulder, which has kept him in the latest college football coaches hot seat index.
USC’s next stretch is a big one, with a trip to Penn State on Oct. 10 and a home game against Ohio State on Oct. 31.
In Other News...
USC Linebackers Just Changed A Big Concern Before Penn State
TaMere Robinson stepped into the lineup for suspended Desmond Stephens II and made the kind of impact USC has been looking for on defense, helping the Trojans grind out a 25-21 win over Washington. The unit tied a season high with five sacks and 48 total tackles, and linebackers Robinson, Deven Bryant and Elijah Newby each earned game balls after a performance that gave the defense some real momentum.
Lincoln Riley praised the depth and effort from that linebacker group, and the timing matters with Penn State next on the schedule. USC is heading into a road environment where communication will be tested by expected crowd noise, so the Trojans now have something tangible to lean on from Saturday beyond the result itself. [Read more 🡒]
USC Just Lost One Of Its Most Respected Special Teams Leaders
USCs special teams unit took a jolt in the Washington game when linebacker Roman Marchetti went down with a left leg injury on a kickoff return and did not come back. For a team that has leaned on him as one of its most dependable special teams pieces, the loss carried immediate weight beyond just one snap. Marchetti had become a respected presence in that phase of the game after arriving as a walk-on and eventually earning a scholarship, a path that made him easy to root for inside the program.
Marchetti later announced on social media that the injury brought an end to his 15-year football career, turning a painful in-game moment into something much bigger for USC. It is a reminder of how much value the Trojans had in a player who built his place the hard way and earned the trust that comes with it. Even without the full football ride continuing, his departure leaves a gap in a part of the roster where reliability matters as much as anything else. [Read more 🡒]
Lincoln Riley Faces A Pressure Game USC Fans Can't Ignore
The mood around Lincoln Riley has shifted from unease to open frustration, and it surfaced loudly during USCs Week 5 game against Washington. Even with the Trojans sitting at 5-1, the performance did little to calm a fan base worn down by repeated penalties, uneven play and the same old issues away from home that have followed USC into the Big Ten.
Penn State now looms as the kind of test that can either steady the conversation or deepen it, with a hostile road crowd waiting and little margin for another flat showing. Since joining the Big Ten in 2024, USC has not looked comfortable outside its own stadium, and that history is what makes this next trip feel bigger than just another game on the schedule. [Read more 🡒]