Paul Bissonnette tossed out a theory on the latest episode of his Spittin' Chiclets podcast that is bound to get Toronto talking: could Judd Moldaver be trying to build an NHL super team in Toronto?
Bissonnette, the NHL on TNT studio analyst and a well-known Maple Leafs fan, pointed to recent reports that Norris Trophy winner Zach Werenski would accept a trade to Toronto as part of the idea. Moldaver represents Werenski, the Columbus Blue Jackets defenseman, and he also represents Connor McDavid of the Edmonton Oilers and Auston Matthews of the Maple Leafs.
The notion sounds wild at first glance, and Bissonnette’s Toronto leanings probably don’t hurt the optimism. Still, there are several reasons the idea is not as far-fetched as it might seem.
One big piece is Moldaver himself. In today’s pro sports world, top agents have more influence than ever, and Moldaver sits in that rarefied group.
He is the agent for Werenski, McDavid, and Matthews, three of the NHL’s biggest names. The source compares him to Scott Boras in MLB, Drew Rosenhaus in the NFL, and Rich Paul in the NBA.
If those clients make their wishes known, Moldaver has the clout to push for them.
There is also a strong GTA thread running through the whole thing. Moldaver is from Toronto, and McDavid has long been linked to the idea of one day returning to his home city before his career is over.
Matthews, meanwhile, is American, but has consistently spoken highly of the Maple Leafs, the franchise’s history, and what it means to wear the captain’s “C.” He would also understand exactly what a championship in Toronto would mean for his legacy.
For McDavid, the pull of home could be powerful. Playing in front of family and friends, returning as the local star, and possibly delivering a title to a franchise that has gone without one for the longest NHL championship drought - that is a storyline with real appeal.
The on-ice connections matter too. Matthews and McDavid have a long-standing mutual respect, with Matthews calling McDavid the best player in hockey and McDavid praising Matthews’ leadership, shot, and scoring touch.
They have trained together in the offseason and appeared together in commercials. Werenski and Matthews also know each other well through USA Hockey, including their gold medal run at the 2026 Winter Olympics in Italy.
They have also been together at the World Juniors and the 4 Nations Face-Off.
Then there is the money. The NHL salary cap for 2026-27 is $104 million, and the contracts for Matthews, McDavid, and Werenski all expire in two years.
By 2028-29, when they are expected to reach UFA status, the cap is projected to rise to $132 million. The recent offer sheet to Leo Carlsson, with an $18 million AAV, could also reshape how the league thinks about elite salaries.
If Matthews, McDavid, and Werenski each landed at $20 million AAV, that would still leave $63 million for the rest of the roster. Toronto is projected to have almost $57 million in space for 2028-29, and Leafs GM John Chayka has left room to maneuver for that kind of moment.
Gavin McKenna will also be in the final year of his entry-level deal then, with a cap hit of just over $1 million. William Nylander’s $11.5 million AAV could look like a bargain, as could Matthew Knies’ $7.75 million AAV if he is still there.
Morgan Rielly’s $7.5 million cap hit is also likely to be moved elsewhere by then.
The final ingredient is the league’s shift toward player-driven movement. Matthew Tkachuk started the trend by leaving the Calgary Flames, followed by Quinn Hughes moving on from the Vancouver Canucks.
Both made it clear they would not sign extensions with their teams and were traded to preferred destinations. Brady Tkachuk did the same this offseason, and the Ottawa Senators sent him to Florida to join his brother Matthew.
Dylan Larkin has also asked to be traded and gave a limited list of teams for which he would waive his no-movement clause.
That is the NHL now: more player empowerment, more leverage, more stars steering their own futures. If Matthews, McDavid, and Werenski all wanted the same team and the same city, the current landscape says they would have a real shot at making it happen.
So what started as a playful off-season idea on Spittin' Chiclets starts to look a little less ridiculous when you stack up the pieces. Moldaver’s reach, the cap growth, and the rise of player-controlled movement all point in the same direction. The summer of 2028 could be the defining free-agent window in NHL history, and while a Matthews-McDavid-Werenski trio still sounds outrageous, the conditions for it are there.
In Other News...
Why Alexander Bilecki Could Be A Sneaky Leafs Blue Line Find
Alexander Bilecki has spent the past two seasons with the Kitchener Rangers, and the Maple Leafs have reason to keep a close eye on how his game keeps trending. The defenseman, taken 60th overall, was part of a Rangers team that won both the OHL championship and the Memorial Cup, and his role in that run was hard to miss as the playoff games got bigger.
What stands out most is how much more dangerous he looked in the postseason this spring, when he piled up 11 points in 18 playoff games after a quieter run a year ago. Bilecki still has development time ahead of him before he gets anywhere near Torontos AHL affiliate, but the combination of offensive growth and winning experience gives him a profile the Leafs can dream on a little longer. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Push For Veteran Upgrade As Familiar Cap Tension Builds
The Maple Leafs have kept the roster moving this summer, but the work in front of them still points to the same need: another top-six forward who can fit either at center or on the wing. John Chayka and Toronto have been weighing trade possibilities and free-agent options, and insider David Pagnotta said the club is still exploring ways to upgrade while also leaving room to adjust with players already on the roster.
The challenge, as always, is the cap. Any meaningful addition appears to come with the kind of financial juggling that can force a current player out first, and Toronto still has to be compliant by the start of the season. Veteran names have surfaced in the conversation, including some from Anaheim, but the Leafs are clearly still in the stage where possibilities are being sorted out before anything becomes real. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Reset Suddenly Includes A Respected Name Fans Never Expected
The Maple Leafs front-office reset has moved well beyond a routine shuffle, with John Chayka overseeing a sweeping overhaul that has reached management, player development, scouting and analytics. Fourteen personnel members are out, and the list of departures includes familiar names across the organization, a sign that this is not a cosmetic change but a broad reworking of how the team wants to operate.
Among the most notable exits is Dr. Hayley Wickenheiser, whose presence gave the Leafs a respected voice in player development and a direct line to hockey credibility beyond the rink. Chayka thanked the departing staff in a statement and said some of the openings will be addressed in the coming weeks, but for now the bigger story is how quickly a new leadership group is putting its stamp on the organization. [Read more 🡒]