The Edmonton Oilers needed help up front, and on Wednesday they got it, sending defenseman Spencer Stastney to the Pittsburgh Penguins for forward Filip Hollander in an in-season swap for the second straight year between the teams.
On paper, it checks a box for Edmonton. The forward group has been hit hard by injuries early, so bringing in another body there makes sense. But the other side of the deal is harder to defend: the Oilers gave up a defender who had quietly given them useful minutes and some real stability in a role they’ve struggled to fill.
Stastney only played 36 games for Edmonton after coming over from the Nashville Predators last season, and his role was straightforward. He worked mostly on the third pair, chipped in one goal, and filled in where needed. That kind of player can be easy to overlook until the lineup starts thinning out, and for Edmonton, that’s exactly where the concern sits.
His value was built on the defensive side. Stastney leaned conservative, even if that approach occasionally drifted into over-aggression.
He averaged more than 16 minutes of ice time per game last season, blocked 38 shots, and finished at minus-10. His expected goals against also dipped below zero.
The penalty kill is where he stood out most. Edmonton’s shorthanded work struggled in 2025-26, but Stastney was one of the few clear bright spots. His steadiness and ability to get pucks out helped the Oilers survive a few more kills than they might have otherwise, and the numbers backed up the eye test: he was impactful when the team was down a man.
He also fit well beside Ty Emberson. The two formed a defensive-minded pairing that logged a shade over 226 minutes together and posted an expected goals against per 60 minutes of just 2.15. They matched each other’s style and gave Edmonton a look that actually held together.
That matters because the Oilers have been here before. Over the last couple of seasons, they’ve leaned on depth defenders to keep the blue line from cracking when injuries hit.
They’ve also limped into the last two postseasons with key players missing time late in the year. In 2025-26, every point mattered as they tried to stay in the playoff race, which makes reliable depth even more valuable.
Edmonton does have other options in the system, including Shakir Mukhamadullin, Alec Regula, and Josh Brown. But Stastney offered something a little different: a more settled NHL-ready presence who could step in without much ramp-up time.
That’s why this trade brings back a familiar feeling for the Oilers. In November 2025, they put Troy Stecher on waivers to make room for the returning Zach Hyman.
At the time, Stecher was another veteran squeezed out of the lineup. Later, when injuries and defensive problems piled up, Edmonton could have used him.
Instead, the Toronto Maple Leafs claimed him.
Stecher made the most of that chance. He put up 14 points in 58 games with Toronto, tied his highest total since 2022-23, averaged more than 19 minutes per game, and earned a two-year deal worth $1.35 million annually to stay with the Maple Leafs.
Stecher and Stastney are not the same player, and this is not the same moment. Still, the pattern feels awfully familiar.
Edmonton needed forward help, and Hollander will be worth watching when he gets into the lineup. But moving out a defender who was helping stabilize a shaky area of the roster is the kind of decision that can come back to bite a team.
If Hollander becomes a star, nobody will care. If he doesn’t, the Oilers may be left wondering why they gave away a piece of the blue line they’ve spent so long trying to steady.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs Face One Trade Question That Could Reshape Their Blue Line
The Maple Leafs have already added to their roster since the offseason, but the blue line still looks like the spot that could most use another swing. A high-impact left-side defenseman would fit the kind of upgrade Toronto has been circling, and Simon Edvinsson has emerged as an intriguing name because of his age, size and upside. For a team trying to harden its back end without sacrificing future value, he checks a lot of boxes on paper.
What makes the situation worth watching is the possibility that Detroit could be open to moving him under the right circumstances. Edvinsson has the profile of a player who would draw interest across the league, and Toronto would make sense as one of the clubs keeping tabs if the Red Wings decide to listen. For the Maple Leafs, the question is whether they want to push in now for help on the left side or trust the current group to carry the load a little longer. [Read more 🡒]
Nylanders Honest Take On A New Leafs Arrival Will Get Attention
William Nylander has been one of the Maple Leafs early catalysts this season, piling up six points in five games, but the conversation around him in a recent interview with The Athletic drifted beyond the scoreboard. Nylander touched on the arrival of Sergei Bobrovsky, a major new presence in Torontos mix, and also opened up about the people and players who shaped him growing up, giving a more personal glimpse into the winger behind the production.
There was also some notable honesty in the way Nylander discussed his connection to former Leafs star Mats Sundin, since the relationship has long carried extra weight for Toronto fans. Nylander revisited his upbringing and the hockey influences that mattered most to him, a reminder that even for a player entrenched in the present, the past still helps frame how he sees a changing Leafs roster. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Make Unusual Avalanche Lineup Move With One Big Decision Looming
The Maple Leafs are making a slightly unusual adjustment against the Colorado Avalanche, sliding Nick Blankenburg into the lineup as John Tavares steps out for the birth of his child. Head coach Jim Hiller said the club will dress seven defensemen and 11 forwards, a wrinkle that gives Toronto some extra flexibility while also opening the door for Blankenburg to get his first action of the season after being a healthy scratch through the first five games.
Blankenburg arrived on a one-year deal after a strong training camp, so this is a useful early look at how he fits once the games start to count. There is still one notable piece left hanging ahead of puck drop, though, because Hiller declined to name the starting goaltender, leaving Torontos final call in net as the other decision worth watching before the matchup begins. [Read more 🡒]