Morgan Rielly’s name is still hanging around the San Jose Sharks conversation, and the door doesn’t sound closed just yet.
After a wild 2026 offseason full of back-and-forth on whether Rielly would be moved, Toronto appears to be in a spot where keeping him is still very much on the table. But the trade talk hasn’t vanished, and there are still teams that could make sense if they’re willing to protect him properly on the back end.
San Jose was already floated as a possible landing spot because the Sharks needed defense help, had plenty of cap space, and could have used Rielly’s veteran presence with a young group. Then they went and added Darnell Nurse, which seemed to shut that idea down. Not so fast, though.
Elliotte Friedman brought the Sharks back into the picture on the final 32 Thoughts podcast of the year, saying San Jose still may be in the market for another puck-moving defender.
“I still think they could use a powerplay quarterback, and I think they might look for one.”
That kind of role fits Rielly cleanly. He has 179 career points on the man advantage, and Toronto has leaned on him for years in that spot alongside high-end talent. If San Jose wants someone to run the power play, Rielly is a natural fit.
The Sharks also wouldn’t be sending him into a barren situation. Their young offensive core includes Macklin Celebrini, Will Smith, Michael Misa, and second overall pick Ivar Stenberg, with Mason Marchment also in the mix after signing a big deal this offseason. That gives Rielly a chance to work with plenty of skill around him.
And he wouldn’t be left to fend for himself defensively. Nurse, Sam Dickinson and Jacob Trouba are all there to help cover, and with Trouba in the fold, Rielly wouldn’t need to be the main option. He could focus on moving the puck and getting involved in the attack.
That matters because Rielly’s game has been muted under Craig Berube’s more defense-first style. Earlier in his career, he reached 20 goals by jumping into the rush, and that kind of freedom could come back if he lands in a setup with a real safety net behind him.
For Toronto, the key is not to treat this like a simple salary dump. Rielly carries a $7.5-million AAV, so if the Leafs move him, they need more than just relief. San Jose would have to show real interest and a willingness to send something useful back.
That return could include a player like Barclay Goodrow or Adam Gaudette, giving Toronto more scoring and versatility. If the Sharks are focused on their NHL roster, Patrick Giles could be another option - a big power forward with a USNTDP background, which is an area the Maple Leafs have had success with lately.
A top prospect isn’t part of the discussion here, and that’s not realistic. But an NHL-ready piece, or a player who can bring physicality and depth at both the NHL and AHL levels, would give Toronto something to work with.
Rielly’s value is still there. The question is whether the Sharks are serious enough to make Toronto a better offer than just clearing the money. And if they are, the Leafs might finally have a path to ending all the stop-and-start noise around Morgan Rielly.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs Could Still Make One More Polarizing Move Up Front
Torontos offseason has already been busy under new general manager John Chayka, with several new faces arriving as the Maple Leafs keep reshaping the roster around their core. Even after that wave of activity, there is still a sense that one more addition up front could make the group deeper and a little harder to play against, especially if it brings another layer of scoring support and power-play help.
One name being floated fits that profile as a veteran with recent production and a long track record in big games. He spent last season with Minnesota, where he was productive over a full schedule, and his rsum includes two Stanley Cup titles and more than 100 playoff appearances. For Toronto, the appeal is obvious: a short-term swing that could bolster the top nine without requiring a long commitment, even if the move would not come without debate. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Are Betting Big On One Risky Scott Laughton Fix
Scott Laughtons departure left the Maple Leafs looking for a different way to patch together the middle of their lineup, and they chose breadth over a single like-for-like answer. Instead of chasing one direct replacement, Toronto spread his old responsibilities across a handful of new faces with different strengths, betting that a more balanced mix can help stabilize the roster without sacrificing too much at the other end of the ice.
The upside is obvious enough in theory: the Leafs want the group to be better defensively than the one it replaces. The question hanging over the plan is whether the offense will come along for the ride, with one newcomer carrying more of that burden while the others project more as limited scorers. For a team trying to squeeze more value out of every lineup spot, that is a calculated gamble worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]