The Toronto Maple Leafs are navigating a challenging 2025-26 season, leaving fans and analysts alike questioning whether a simple retool can right the ship or if a more drastic rebuild is necessary. With their offense, defense, and even their once-reliable goaltending faltering, the team faces tough decisions ahead.
If the Leafs opt for a rebuild, identifying untouchable players becomes crucial. Let’s dive into three surprising candidates who should be considered essential to the team's future.
John Tavares
A rebuild often requires veteran leadership to guide younger players through the transition. John Tavares, with his wealth of experience and leadership qualities, fits this role perfectly.
His full no-movement clause through the 2026-27 season means he's staying put, but it's his commitment to the team that truly stands out. Tavares took a significant hometown discount with a $4.5 million AAV contract, demonstrating his dedication to Toronto's long-term success.
His presence could be invaluable in steering the team through a rebuild.
Jake McCabe
Finding top-tier defensive talent willing to join a rebuilding team is no easy task. That's why retaining a player like Jake McCabe is vital.
McCabe has consistently been a standout on the blue line, contributing both offensively and defensively while bringing a physical edge to his game. His skill set is exactly what new recruits should emulate to become impactful players in the league.
At just over $4.5 million AAV, McCabe offers tremendous value and stability for the Leafs' future.
Matthew Knies
While big names like Matthews and Nylander often dominate headlines, it's Matthew Knies who could be the cornerstone of a rebuild. Despite being involved in trade talks, letting go of Knies would be a mistake.
Rebuilds are about cultivating young, elite talent, and Knies is already proving his worth. At 23, he's a 30-goal, 60-point player with room to grow.
His smart hockey IQ, relentless work ethic, and leadership potential make him a future captain in the making.
Trading stars like Matthews or Nylander could bring in a substantial return, accelerating the rebuild process. But Knies is the critical piece Toronto should hold onto for a swift and successful turnaround. His potential and current performance make him indispensable as the Leafs look to the future.