The Maple Leafs have been quieter since their early burst of moves in NHL free agency, but that doesn’t mean the work is finished. Toronto already made its biggest splash with star goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky, yet there’s still room to circle back to a few familiar names who could help fill out the roster.
Three possible reunions stand out: Michael Bunting, John Klingberg and James Reimer.
Bunting is the easiest one to picture. His two seasons in Toronto were the best of his NHL career, with back-to-back 23-goal years and 112 points in 161 games.
Since leaving the Leafs, the 30-year-old winger has still produced at a steady clip, averaging 17 goals and 40 points a season while moving through the Carolina Hurricanes, Pittsburgh Penguins, Nashville Predators and Dallas Stars. What made him valuable in Toronto, though, was how well he fit into the top six, including alongside Auston Matthews during Matthews’ Hart Trophy season in 2021-22.
A return to that kind of role could bring out the same kind of damage again.
Klingberg is a different case, because the first Toronto stint never really got off the ground. Signed as a major addition in the 2023 offseason, he spent most of that time on injured reserve and managed only 14 games, finishing with five assists.
That made the move a disappointment. But last season with the San Jose Sharks, the 33-year-old defenseman showed there’s still something left in the tank, putting up 10 goals and 27 points in 56 games.
With the Leafs’ new regime leaning toward puck-moving defensemen, another one-year deal would at least give him a real chance to prove himself.
Then there’s Reimer, who feels like the practical option. Toronto had him in camp on a professional tryout last year for veteran depth, but he was let go after the club claimed Cayden Primeau off waivers before the start of the 2025-26 NHL season.
Now the situation has changed. The Leafs have dealt away both Joseph Woll and Dennis Hildeby this offseason, leaving Artur Akhtyamov as the lone backup option behind Bobrovsky and Anthony Stolarz at the NHL level.
Reimer, 38, posted a 7-4-2 record with a 2.42 GAA in 14 games for the Ottawa Senators last season, and that kind of veteran insurance suddenly looks a lot more valuable. With Bobrovsky getting older and Stolarz carrying an injury history, Toronto could use the depth.
It could also give Reimer a fitting final chapter when he eventually hangs it up.
In Other News...
Former Leafs Prospect Nick Robertson Just Got The Payday Toronto Debated
Nick Robertsons next chapter got a little clearer just as his old one was closing. The 24-year-old forward, recently traded out of Toronto, reached a new contract agreement shortly before his scheduled salary arbitration hearing, giving him some stability at a moment when his career had been in motion for weeks.
For the Leafs, Robertsons departure was tied to a season that made him arbitration-eligible and put his value back in the spotlight. He had spent his entire NHL career in Toronto, and after 234 games in blue and white, the debate over what he was worth finally ended with a deal elsewhere, leaving one more reminder of how quickly a young player can go from prospect to a payday another team was willing to make. [Read more 🡒]
Flyers Nearly Made A Franchise Changing Trade Fans Never Saw Coming
A reported 2021 trade conversation has resurfaced as one of those front-office what-ifs that can linger for years, especially when it involves a core Maple Leafs winger in William Nylander. According to a content creator citing a source tied to an Amazon Prime documentary, Toronto explored a deal with Philadelphia that would have taken Nylander out of the picture and brought in Travis Konecny, with the discussions happening among key team executives before the idea fizzled.
What makes the story stand out now is how differently both players careers have settled since then. Nylander remained a central piece in Toronto and later locked in on a long-term extension in 2024, while Konecny did the same in Philadelphia, turning a once-rumored swap into a reminder of how close the Leafs came to a move that could have altered the rosters direction in a major way. [Read more 🡒]