With NHL free agency opening up, the Maple Leafs are expected to keep busy as they build toward the 2026-27 season. Toronto has already been active this offseason, turning over the management side, adding defensemen Emil Andrae and Darren Raddysh, and using the first overall pick on Gavin McKenna.
But not every available name should be on the Leafs’ shopping list. Some players might look like clean fits at first glance and still end up creating more problems than they solve. Here are three free agents Toronto should steer clear of.
Boone Jenner is the kind of player who makes sense in a quick glance. If Max Domi’s status for next season remains unsettled, Jenner could slide into the third-line center role and bring a steady scoring touch, with the source pointing to a 30-40 point range. He’d also add grit, physicality and a hard-working edge that would help deepen the bottom six.
The problem is availability. Jenner has not played more than 68 games in a season since 2019-20, and that kind of injury history is a real concern for a team that already dealt with major injury issues during the 2025-26 season. Toronto doesn’t need another player whose time in the lineup could be limited.
Rasmus Andersson brings a different kind of appeal. He’s one of the top defensemen in the market, and there’s no shortage of interest in him. The Leafs were among the teams linked to him when he was traded in-season last year, and his résumé is easy to see: top-pair ability, double-digit goals and a 40-50 point ceiling.
That said, the price could get out of hand fast. A crowded market could push his contract into overpay territory, and Toronto also has to think about fit in the playoffs.
Andersson’s postseason with the Vegas Golden Knights was quiet, as he finished with six assists in 22 playoff games during their Stanley Cup run. With Raddysh now in place to help on the blue line and Morgan Rielly’s return appearing more likely, the case for chasing Andersson gets thinner.
Then there’s Sergei Bobrovsky, a name that has been connected to Toronto in recent rumors. On the surface, it checks some boxes.
He’s a proven winner and a two-time Stanley Cup champion. He also has some familiar faces around the Leafs already, including former Florida Panthers teammates Anthony Stolarz, Oliver Edman-Larsson and Steven Lorentz, which could ease the transition.
Still, the numbers from last season are hard to ignore. Bobrovsky posted a 27-23-1 record with a 3.07 GAA and .877 save percentage, which is not the profile Toronto should want from a goalie expected to start.
Age is part of the concern too, since he’ll be 38 when the 2026-27 regular season begins. For a team trying to reset and get back on track, that’s a risky bet.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs Could Quietly Define Their Summer With These Forward Targets
With the salary cap still shaping every summer decision, the Maple Leafs are looking at the market through a familiar lens: finding forwards who can help without forcing a major commitment. The appeal here is straightforward. Toronto needs more punch up front, but it also needs flexibility, and that makes the middle tier of free agency especially important for a team trying to stay competitive while keeping its books manageable.
What gives this search some intrigue is the range of fits available if the price lands in the right place. One option brings speed on the wing and some right-shot balance, another carries the familiarity of a former Leaf who could make sense as a value reunion, and another comes with the kind of buy-low appeal that can tempt a front office if it believes the players recent dip is tied to injury rather than long-term decline. For Toronto, the summer may come down less to splash and more to choosing the right kind of useful. [Read more 🡒]
Leafs Fans Just Got A Sudden Twist In The Werenski Chase
Trade chatter around Zach Werenski has quieted for the moment after reports indicated the Blue Jackets defenseman, his agent Judd Moldaver and Columbus GM Don Waddell spoke to address the recent speculation. For Maple Leafs fans who had started to wonder whether a big swing was suddenly available on the blue line, the update is a reminder that these conversations can move fast, then stall just as quickly, especially when a player holds the kind of control Werenski does.
Werenskis no-movement clause has always made any potential deal complicated, and this latest round of reporting suggests the noise may have been more about clearing the air than opening a real door. Still, the fact that Toronto keeps showing up in the conversation tells you why the Leafs were paying attention in the first place, with any serious pursuit likely to come down to whether Columbus ever decides to revisit the idea and what kind of return would even be possible. [Read more 🡒]