The Maple Leafs have had plenty to answer for over the past few weeks - a rough homestand, shaky goaltending and a defense that has left too many holes. But the biggest flashpoint has been Jim Hiller’s handling of rookie forward Gavin McKenna.
McKenna began the season in the top six, but he has since been pushed down to the third line and asked to make do with lesser-skilled linemates. He is still learning the league in his first NHL season, and the growing pains have shown up.
That part is expected. What has not sat well is the way Hiller has used him after saying at the start of the season that the goal was to put McKenna in the best position to succeed.
That plan, at least lately, has not held up.
There have been injuries and some lineup shuffling, so McKenna’s drop to the third line is not hard to understand on its face. But if the Leafs want him to become a real part of what they are building, Hiller has to show more trust in him. Instead, the coach has already made a few decisions that have raised eyebrows, and McKenna’s usage has become one of the loudest.
The clearest example came against the Buffalo Sabres, when Hiller benched McKenna and did not put him back in for the rest of the game. The postgame explanation only added to the confusion. In a game where Toronto needed offense and the scoring had dried up, McKenna looked like exactly the kind of player who should have been on the ice.
The trend started before that. McKenna was moved to the third line and spent time with depth players such as Nick Paul, Colton Sissons and Dakota Joshua, especially with Paul and Joshua recently.
That group has avoided giving up goals, but it has not produced much either. McKenna has also been bumped up to the second line at times, but not enough to suggest a steady role.
If the idea is to help him grow, the Leafs need to give him more than spot duty. Hiller has leaned on veterans in key moments, but those choices have not paid off.
McKenna can force plays that carry risk, yet the veterans around him have not exactly been cleaning up the simple stuff. At some point, if the experienced players are not delivering, it makes sense to give the rookie more chances.
That was on display again against the Chicago Blackhawks. McKenna was skating well and earned another look on the second line.
Then, right after Toronto tied the game, Hiller turned to Joshua. Joshua’s turnover led directly to Connor Bedard’s go-ahead goal.
It was another example of a veteran choice backfiring in a crucial spot.
Rookies usually get the short end of the stick, and McKenna is no exception. But if Hiller is going to hold him accountable for mistakes, the same standard should apply to the veterans.
There is still a straightforward way to clean this up.
The first option would be to keep McKenna on the second line, but the results with McKenna, John Tavares and William Nylander have been ugly, with an expected goals percentage of 29.5%. Since Tavares and Nylander have continued to struggle without him, that setup does not look like the answer.
The better fit may be on the top line. Easton Cowan has looked strong with Auston Matthews and Jack Roslovic, but McKenna has also fit there.
The McKenna-Matthews-Roslovic trio has posted an xGF of 54.5%. If Cowan needs to move, he has shown he can handle time on the second or third line and still play a responsible game.
The other adjustment is on the power play. McKenna was not bothered by being moved back to the second unit, but Toronto looked far more dangerous when he was on the top group than when Tavares was there. The puck moved faster, the lanes opened up and the chances looked much more threatening.
McKenna is still a rookie, and he has to earn his place. But with the way the veterans have performed, Hiller’s reluctance to lean on him when the Leafs need a spark is a real issue. His usage over the past few weeks has not been ideal, and it needs to change.
In Other News...
Leafs Have Reached A Breaking Point Fans Can Feel Coming
The Maple Leafs slide has reached the kind of point where every part of the operation starts to feel heavier. A 6-3 loss to the Blackhawks was just the latest reminder that the problems are piling up, with seven straight regulation defeats dragging the team into a stretch where coaching choices, uneven player performances, special teams issues and shaky goaltending all seem to be feeding off one another.
For a fan base that has lived through plenty of frustration before, this is the sort of run that can turn routine criticism into something louder and more personal. The Leafs have been here before in different forms, with past coaching controversies still part of the backdrop, and the longer this skid goes on the more the conversation shifts from fixing one problem to wondering how many more can be addressed before patience finally runs out. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Skid Puts Pressure On Jim Hiller To Shake Things Up
The Maple Leafs latest loss only deepened a rough stretch that has now reached seven straight, and it left Jim Hiller sounding like a coach searching for answers. Toronto had the lead after the first period against the Chicago Blackhawks, but the game slipped away in a 6-3 defeat, another night where the early positives were quickly erased by what came after.
Hiller pointed to defensive breakdowns as the main culprit rather than goaltending, a distinction that matters when a skid starts to feel like a larger problem. With the losses piling up and the frustration clearly building, the next step could be lineup changes as the Leafs try to stop the slide before it gets any worse. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs May Need A Cheap Blue Line Fix Fast
The Maple Leafs are looking at the waiver wire for help on the blue line, with Anaheim placing defenseman Travis Mitchell on waivers and Toronto reportedly weighing a claim. It is the kind of low-cost move that can make sense when a team is trying to stabilize its defense without spending much cap space, especially with the Leafs in the middle of a losing streak and searching for more reliable depth.
Mitchells appeal is straightforward: he is a pending free agent with a modest cap hit, which makes him an inexpensive option if Toronto wants another body on the back end. With questions lingering around the health and performance of the current group, the Leafs could use a quick fix, and this is one of the few avenues available that does not require a bigger roster shuffle or a major financial commitment. [Read more 🡒]
