The Maple Leafs have reached the point where John Tavares is no longer a comfortable answer down the middle.
Toronto’s slide has turned ugly fast. The club has dropped six straight at home, sits last in the Atlantic, and what looked promising a month ago has already unraveled into something much harder to stomach.
Even in a better effort against Edmonton, the Leafs still came away empty-handed in a 1-0 loss, a rare scoreline in today’s NHL. A big reason for that was the second line, where William Nylander is seriously broken right now and Ryan Tverberg is only now getting his first real taste of NHL action.
But the bigger concern is Tavares.
The former captain and longtime 2C has taken a clear step back this season, and the decline is showing up everywhere. He is currently on pace for his lowest point total since 2012-13, he is getting beaten regularly at 5v5, he is being outscored at a frightening rate, and the defensive game that used to be one of his strengths has fallen off a cliff.
Since returning from injury on Nov. 7th, Tavares has gone pointless in five games. He has managed 10 shots in that stretch, but he has also been a minus-8 and a miserable 36.3% in his first three games back. Overall, he has just seven points in 12 games, and Toronto needs to make a decision soon.
The Leafs can’t keep running Tavares at 2C and expect the 5v5 battle to tilt their way. A move to the wing could help, at least by lightening the load and giving Nick Paul a chance to come in and help defensively.
The problem is that Toronto is thin, and without Colton Sissons, the team has been forced to keep Tavares at 2C for now. Once Sissons returns, he can cover for Paul on the third line.
That would also open the door for Tverberg to slide down and use his energy and relentless motor to help Gavin McKenna while giving him a better offensive outlet. Sissons would serve as the defensive anchor, with a reputation for winning puck battles and keeping plays alive.
At this stage, it feels like a move worth trying. Sheltering Tavares more and surrounding him with extra defensive support might be the best way to shake him out of this rut.
He is one of several Maple Leafs stuck in the mud right now, but he may be the hardest one to pull free. Only time will tell - for better or for worse.
In Other News...
Auston Matthews Just Fueled A New Leafs Coaching Debate
Auston Matthews gave the Maple Leafs latest postgame conversation a little more fuel by noting that head coach Jim Hiller usually does not address the team after games. Matthews said the group instead leans on video review and adjustments, a routine that has become part of the backdrop as Toronto tries to sort through its recent struggles.
Matthews also made a point of praising Hillers steady attitude and energy, which only adds to the debate around the bench. For fans, the comments have opened another round of speculation about Hillers coaching approach and whether the Leafs current process is enough to get the team moving in the right direction. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Have A Real Chance At A Risky Cup-Proven Scorer
Andre Burakovsky has emerged as a name to watch if Ottawa decides to shake up its roster, and the idea naturally lands in Toronto because the Maple Leafs are always looking for ways to deepen their scoring without overhauling the top of the lineup. Burakovsky has a track record that includes Cup-winning experience, but this season has been a difficult one, with his production lagging and a lower-body injury adding another layer of uncertainty to any move.
For the Leafs, the appeal is obvious enough: a chance to add a skilled winger who could help the bottom six without asking him to carry a heavy load. The risk is just as clear, though, because any deal would have to account for his salary and the questions surrounding his fit, both on the ice and in the room, which is why this is the kind of trade idea that sounds intriguing right up until the details start to matter. [Read more 🡒]
Bobrovsky Rumor Puts Leafs Goaltending Anxiety Back In Focus
A social media rumor about Sergei Bobrovsky wanting out and heading back to Russia was enough to jolt the Maple Leafs conversation right back to the crease, where uncertainty has already been building around his play. The claim has not been backed by any credible journalists or official sources, but it landed in a spot where Toronto is already sensitive about goaltending and every whisper tends to get amplified.
Bobrovskys performance has not matched expectations, which is why even an unverified report can take on extra weight around the team. For now, his future intentions remain unclear, and the Leafs are left with the same uneasy backdrop they have been trying to manage: a starting goalie under scrutiny, a fan base looking for answers, and no real clarity yet on what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
