Maple Leafs May Already Regret Two Quiet Offseason Decisions

As former Maple Leafs players find success on new teams, Toronto is left questioning their offseason decisions.

The Maple Leafs spent the offseason reshaping their roster with the idea that it would push them back toward contender status for the 2026-27 NHL season. Some of those moves have helped. Others have left Toronto looking a little thinner than it wanted to be, especially now that more than a quarter of the season is already in the books.

That’s where two former Leafs start to stand out. Both are producing with their new teams, and both are the kind of players Toronto could use right now as its own struggles continue. Matias Maccelli and Dennis Hildeby may not have been the biggest names in the offseason shuffle, but they’re starting to look like the sort of losses that sting.

Maccelli’s time in Toronto lasted only one season after the Leafs brought him in during the 2025 offseason. His year with the club was uneven, but the production was still there in stretches.

Across 71 games, he put up 14 goals and 25 assists for 39 points while averaging just under 15 minutes a night. Toronto had bigger expectations for him, especially after he posted 17 goals and 57 points with the Arizona Coyotes in 2023-24.

When the season ended, the Leafs moved on and did not bring him back.

Now with the New York Islanders, the 26-year-old winger has started to rediscover that offense. Even after missing time because of a lower-body injury suffered against the Leafs, Maccelli has chipped in two goals and eight assists for 10 points in only 11 games.

That pace has him scoring nearly a point per game, which is something he hasn’t done since entering the league in 2021-22. With Toronto having trouble generating offense lately, it’s easy to see why Maccelli’s current form would feel useful.

The other departure that looks more painful is in goal. Toronto sent Dennis Hildeby to the Tampa Bay Lightning for Nick Paul, and while Paul has been doing a solid job for the Maple Leafs, the net has become a bigger issue than ever. Sergei Bobrovsky has struggled immensely this season, and Hildeby is giving Tampa Bay exactly the kind of steady backup work Toronto could use.

In five starts behind Andrei Vasilevskiy, the 25-year-old has gone 4-0-1 with a 2.56 GAA and a .899 save percentage. That follows a promising stretch last season in Toronto, when injuries and inconsistency hit Anthony Stolarz and Joseph Woll.

Hildeby appeared in 20 games as a rookie and finished with a 2.80 GAA and a strong .914 save percentage. At that point, he looked like a goalie the Leafs could build around for the future.

Instead, Toronto moved on quickly, and that decision is starting to look questionable. The article even raises the possibility that Hildeby could follow the same path as Tuukka Rask. If that happens, the Leafs won’t just be missing him now - they could be regretting the move for a long time.

In Other News...

Maple Leafs Just Got A Front Office Warning They Couldnt Ignore

The mood around the Maple Leafs has only grown heavier after a 6-3 loss to the Chicago Blackhawks, and the response from above came quickly. MLSE CEO Keith Pelley went into the locker room afterward to address the teams poor performance, a sign that the organizations patience is being tested as Toronto continues to linger near the bottom of the division.

Pelley reportedly spoke with some key personnel in the room, though the club has not confirmed exactly who was involved. No firings or trades have followed, but the visit itself sent a clear message: the Leafs are being watched closely, and the front office is no longer treating this slide like something that can be brushed aside. [Read more 🡒]

Maple Leafs Face One Big Trade Question On Defense

The Maple Leafs are still looking for ways to sharpen the roster, and the blue line is where the conversation keeps circling back. Brandt Clarke of the Kings has surfaced as a possible target, which makes sense for a Toronto team that could use more offense from its defense and more long-term upside on the back end.

The catch is simple: a player like Clarke is not the kind of add a team lands cheaply. Any serious pursuit would likely mean parting with meaningful assets, whether that is prospects, current players or draft capital, and that is where the real debate begins. Morgan Rielly has even been floated as a possible trade piece in the discussion, but for now it remains exactly that, a discussion, with no confirmed move on the horizon. [Read more 🡒]

Leafs Just Made A Telling Change With Gavin McKenna

Gavin McKennas role with the Maple Leafs is already changing in a meaningful way. After carving out a spot on the third line, he has been bumped up to the second line and placed back on the top power-play unit, a clear sign the coaching staff wants to lean harder into what he has brought through his first 23 games.

The move comes with McKenna sitting among the NHL rookie leaders in goals and assists, production that has made it hard to keep him buried in a lower-profile role. For Toronto, the adjustment is about more than reward - it is a push to give him more ice time, more offensive touches and a bigger chance to keep driving the attack. [Read more 🡒]