The trade deadline has stirred up quite the buzz around the Toronto Maple Leafs, with whispers that Matthew Knies might not be donning the blue and white in the 2026-27 season. Knies, a young power forward on a favorable contract, is the kind of player any team would covet.
If the Leafs were to part ways with him, they’d likely find themselves scrambling to fill the void he leaves behind. Trading Knies seems counterintuitive unless the Leafs are contemplating a major rebuild, in which case cashing in on him might be a bitter but necessary pill to swallow.
Elliotte Friedman from Sportsnet has reported significant interest in Knies from several teams, including Anaheim, Chicago, Montreal, New Jersey, and Utah. While the Canadiens have denied deep involvement, the mere mention of Knies’ availability has put teams on high alert.
Let’s dive into what each potential suitor could offer Toronto in return for Knies and whether these deals would make sense for the Leafs.
Anaheim Ducks
The Ducks are an intriguing option, especially if Mason McTavish is part of the conversation. Despite being a recent healthy scratch, McTavish has the potential to slot in as a key center for Toronto, possibly even nudging Tavares to the wing.
While there are risks with McTavish’s recent struggles, his age and contract align well with Toronto’s needs. If McTavish is indeed available, the Leafs would be wise to explore this possibility.
Chicago Blackhawks
Chicago’s appeal lies more in future assets than current roster players. While their top-five pick is likely off the table, they could offer the 11th overall pick, which might tempt Toronto if they’re shifting towards a rebuild. Prospects like Frank Nazar or Sam Rinzel could also be part of the package, though it would require additional assets to pique Toronto’s interest.
Montreal Canadiens
The Canadiens have some enticing young centers like Kirby Dach or Alex Newhook, who could make an immediate impact for Toronto. However, these players come with their own set of challenges, including injuries and lower production in the 2025-26 season. If Montreal sweetens the deal enough, Toronto might consider trading Knies for a chance to bolster their center depth.
New Jersey Devils
Simon Nemec’s name entering trade discussions was a surprise, but a one-for-one swap involving this promising right-shot defenseman could be appealing. Before pulling the trigger, Toronto would need to understand Nemec’s contract demands. Acquiring Nemec would address a defensive need but could leave a gap upfront.
Utah Mammoth
Reuniting Knies with Logan Cooley in Utah makes sense for the Mammoth, but what can they offer in return? Their first-round pick, likely in the late teens, could be part of the package, along with a roster player like Lawson Crouse, Barrett Hayton, or Jack McBain. While these players add depth, Toronto would need more to justify trading Knies.
As we weigh these options, the idea of trading Knies doesn’t seem as daunting as it initially did. While the Leafs are undoubtedly stronger with Knies, preparing for potential roster changes this summer is a prudent strategy. The future remains uncertain, but being open to possibilities might just be the Leafs’ best play.