A strange online argument has taken on a life of its own, and it’s one that falls apart the second you look at the names involved.
The claim making the rounds is that the Toronto Maple Leafs somehow got the better bargain by signing Darren Raddysh to an $8.5 million cap hit than the Colorado Avalanche did when they locked up Cale Makar at a league-high $20.4 million AAV. On the surface, it sounds like the kind of comparison meant to spark arguments. In reality, it doesn’t hold up.
Makar is in a completely different category. He’s already got the Norris Trophies, Stanley Cup and Conn Smythe Trophy to justify the kind of money Colorado committed to him. Raddysh, meanwhile, is a solid addition for Toronto - though the view here is that the Leafs still overpaid.
That’s why the idea that Toronto landed a better deal than Colorado is so far off base. If the Maple Leafs had a shot at Makar, they would have paid him the same way. This is less a real hockey debate than a piece of bait designed to get people talking, and it worked.
The only part of the comparison that does make some sense is how Raddysh’s deal now looks tiny next to Makar’s. An $8.5 million cap hit can feel modest when it’s sitting beside a $20.4 million AAV.
But timing matters. The two contracts were signed at different points, and that changes the whole conversation. If Makar had signed that huge extension in June, before free agency opened on July 1, Raddysh’s camp would have had a much stronger case to push for more.
It probably still wouldn’t have reached $20 million, but the asking price could have climbed to at least $10 million. Against Makar’s number, even that would have looked like money found in the couch cushions.
In the end, Toronto benefited from the timing of Raddysh’s deal. If Makar had reset the defense market first, the Maple Leafs and Raddysh could have been looking at a very different outcome. Raddysh may have no regrets about signing when he did, but in another version of events, the Leafs might have been the ones who escaped a bullet.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs May Regret Passing On A Low-Cost Scoring Fix
The Maple Leafs are heading toward training camp with the kind of salary cap squeeze that makes every inexpensive roster move look more important in hindsight. That is why the decision to pass on Eeli Tolvanen, who landed a one-year deal with the New York Rangers, stands out as more than a minor footnote. Toronto has been looking for ways to shore up its depth without spending heavily, and the market still includes a few veterans who could fit that bill.
Gustav Nyquist and Jonathan Drouin are among the other names that sit in that low-cost, high-upside lane the Leafs may want to keep circling. Players on show-me deals do not solve everything, but for a team trying to protect itself against thin scoring depth, they can be useful bets. The challenge for Toronto is whether it keeps waiting for the perfect fit or starts acting on the kind of bargain opportunities that tend to disappear quickly. [Read more 🡒]
Leafs Fans Will Hate This New Twist In The Laughton Pick Deal
The Flyers have added a familiar name to their amateur scouting department, bringing in Dave Morrison after his 23-year run with the Maple Leafs. Morrison spent more than two decades helping Toronto identify talent, and now he is moving into a role where he will help Philadelphia do the same as it builds out its next wave of prospects.
For Leafs fans, the timing gives the Scott Laughton trade an extra layer of sting. Philadelphia still has not used the conditional first-round pick it acquired from Toronto in that deal, and Morrison will be part of the group evaluating the player selected with it. It is the kind of front-office twist that can make an old trade feel a little more personal, especially when the person helping make the next call spent so long in Toronto's own scouting room. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Fans Should Watch This Marlies Shakeup Closely
The Toronto Marlies are entering the kind of offseason that can quietly shape the Maple Leafs future depth chart, with both the coaching staff and front office getting a fresh look. Chris Bourque has been promoted to assistant general manager, while Denver Manderson has been added as an assistant coach, a pair of moves that suggest the organization is tweaking how it develops and evaluates players throughout the pipeline.
For Leafs fans, the significance goes beyond the AHL bench. The Marlies are often the first stop for prospects who could eventually help in Toronto, so changes in that room can ripple upward in a hurry. And as the hockey media landscape keeps shifting, with more games moving to streaming platforms in North America, the attention on development systems like the Marlies only figures to grow as the next season approaches. [Read more 🡒]